Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law & Ethics

Is my job racist in how they compensate / reward bonuses?
Find answers to your legal question.





Is my job racist in how they compensate / reward bonuses?

I am a 26 year old black female, who for the most part, tries to look at the bright side of things. Well, this past friday, the company I work for awarded fiscal year bonuses. Now, there is a 40 year old white woman who does the exact job I do and gets paid the same wage that I do (she showed me her check stub one day). This person started about 6 months after me and daily she comes to work, does her job, surfs the internet, collects her check at the end of the week, and that's that. I on the other hand, come to work daily, do my job, assist others with their job, have requested to move to one of the other teams (my department has several teams with different functions and I wanted to learn them all), sign up for additional training classes my company offers (ocassionally coming in on my off days), and collect my check. This same co-worker and I were talking today and she said her bonus was $1850 but mine was only $1200. I'm confused and I don't think it's fair. Are they racist?
Additional Details
I ran out of space for the initial part of the question but here are the extras:
1. We do the same job
2. We make the same amount
3. I NEVER asked her how much she made or what her bonus was... she volunteered the information. SO I WAS NOT BEING NOSEY!!!!!
4. The only difference between us is that she is a 40 year old white woman and I am a 26 year old black woman.


    




DeCiMaL
Rating
Yeah, I'd go straight to the boss and ask why EXACTLY was their such a considerable difference in bonuses.

Don't leave until you get a satisfactory answer.

White people will never understand why race is an issue. B/c deep down inside, it really is. They'll never know what it feels like to be less important than their "all-american looking" counterparts just b/c they promote the right image.

And sometimes bosses think with all the overacheiving and question asking that you are a trouble-starter, rather than a fall-in-liner, which unfortunately is what some employers want.


♥ ♥Be Happi♥ ♥
I guess you could say that, I wouldn't say it, because I don't see how it is a racist decision.

If you were going to the mall to shop at one of there 75% off all merchandise sales, that started at 6:00 a.m. and ended at noon, you found some things you liked, got in to line, but by the time you got to pay it was 12:30. Are you going to say the store is racist because the people in front of you were white and got the discount?

You can refer to race in anything you want, doesn't make it the case. You could also go to your boss and ask them how the bonus was determined, and see what they tell you!


iseaulater2
Rating
Maybe not......you may think your work is above hers but the reality may be she is a better worker than you. Maybe you should ask your boss if your work meets standards. Why does race always have to be an issue? Maybe you are not as efficient as her. Besides if you have the time to see what she is doing all the time then obviously your not worrying about your work.

PS... before listening to the suppose attorney below think this out.....I was in a major discrimination lawsuit...attorneys love them because they get $$$ for them....however, they are not what you think it is....you will lose your job (no matter if you win), you will lose your friends, you will be alienated from other workers and it WILL be the worse time of your life. People that telll you to file are usually people that have never experienced it. Caution: remember like one lady told you there is 14 years of experience between you and the other lady. I know I get a few hundred a week more than a new employee due to my experience. You will too when you get the experience.


DB
Why would deliberate racism on the part of your employer be your first thought!


IF YOUR BOSS WAS RACIST, THAT PERSON WOULDN'T HAVE HIRED "YOU!!!!"



It sounds like you're racist and jumping to conclusions.




.


Twoshot
Rating
Having been in positions were something seems or is unfair, I try to remember there is two sides to every story. It may seem that this other person is doing less and getting more and it may be true that they are, but have you researched this to make sure? Also you stated she was 40 years old. Her 14 years of experience may be why she got a bigger check. Before you do anything make sure you have your ducks in a row. Otherwise you may be opening a can of worms you don't want to eat.


R T
You didn't say if you worked on commission or was it a piece work type of job. You yourself said she does her work, is this bonus in relation to sales? I once had a job where we did the same job but any bonuses were in relation to our sales, one month I would have more ,the next his was more. Racist, probably not, unless you were to cry discrimination, than it becomes a racial issue, for what it's worth


wolf
I doubt if it's racist.
Maybe unfair.
Which is common in the workplace, and everywhere else.
But "be careful". She may be lying about it.
Most people lie about their bonus.


www.scapegoatz.com
Rating
If your check was more than hers would you still think they where racist? Only $1200.00 thats better than I got this year a huge $50.00. Most of the times they figure in the amount of time you worked there. 1/2 a year will make the bonus bigger normally.


Daniel
Rating
I wouldnt call your boss racist, however speak with him/her about this issue. Tell him/her what you know and convince them to give you the raise. P.S. do not call Al Sharpton. Good luck!


Phy A
The lady might be right about her paycheck but sometimes,that might be a lie.
You know why most ladies have their men taken by friends? it's because they listen other people more than trying to find out themselves.
I'm wondering how close you are to this lady to make her show you her paycheck. I am very close to my sister,yet I've never seen her paycheck. She might tell me but not let me see it for myself.
If it is too good to be true,it is. Focus on your job and work harder. That woman has now gotten into your head with her paycheck.See it has got agitated.
Racism has got nothing to do with this. Why can't we black people accept the irregularities in life. You can't expect everything to be the same or equal.
Would you call your boss racist if you'd a bigger pay than that lady? of course not; you would back it up that you are fresher,talented and more energetic than that lady,right?
Take it that she is older and more experienced;hence,she gets the lion's share.


crushinator01
Rating
Before I would go asking if they are racist, I would say try and find out if there was a standard that the bonuses were based on. Ask you're boss how the amount for each bonus was decided. then decide if there is a problem.


One Sexy Jeep Girl
Maybe you received a smaller bonus because of how nosy you are. It's none of your business how much others get paid.


LEO53
Rating
Sure why not, if it makes you feel better. Call Rev Sharpton.


honey
Her work results might be better than yours.

She might requested the higher bonus and you didn't.


moon_flower_unicorn_power
i don't think so, she's older than you and right or wrong some people thinks that's a bonus...so maybe age discrimination, but it sounds like you're making the right moves to get ahead...keep it up and you'll reap the rewards...be patient and don't let work consume you


Hokie_Pokey
There could be many other reasons other than racism for the lesser bonus. Why is the racism card always pulled? Fact is, not all companies operate fairly. I once worked for a company that pretty much based their pay scale on how well the owners liked each employee. I was lucky and was one fo the favored ones. My friend was not and whenever she complained about her pay, I felt guilty because I made more. Yeah, it's poopy but what can you do?

$1200 is a damn good bonus.

I suggest that you quit worrying about what other people are making. Stop discussing it - whether you're bringing it up or not. It's rude and makes your co-workers uncomfortable. A lot of companies have policies that if employees discuss salaries, bonus', benefits, etc it is grounds for automatic termination.


David M
Mirry-I'm an attorney for a County and I deal with discrimination cases as part of my job. In contrast to what the other people said (2 answers were up), this appears to be racist and discriminatory. I obviously do not know the whole picture, but from your question you should file a complaint with Personnel or Human Resources if that is an available option. If that is not satisfactory, file a complaint with the EEOC (federal) or your state's Human Rights Department. Everyone else is making assumptions, but my answer is only based on your question and the facts you set forth. EDIT: Mirry-I can't believe some of the other answers. Don't people read your question? You've been there longer and you work harder and you get less money. When I, a white guy and a lawyer, read what you wrote, I only see one answer and that's as racist as some of the responses. It makes me ashamed.


Max Power
I'll answer your question with a question.

We had two fellow employees at work. One was a white male and one was a black female. The white male worked hard, volunteered for and worked all of the overtime he could get, had more enforcement actions than anyone else in his start group and had many friends on staff. Two weeks before his probation was up they fired him because he wasn't a yes man and they didn't like his attitude. They told him that he was on probation and they didn't need a reason to fire him.

The other employee (the black female) never works overtime and half the time she hides in the bathroom on her cell phone during her regular shift. She has 8 enforcement actions in three years (far behind employees hired even two and half years after her), she went on vacation and didn't come back for three extras days (without so much as a phone call). She has missed overtime assignments she was forcibly assigned (mandatory OT is part of our contract) and just left and went home. She actually quit at one point while on probation but they let her come back. She has missed look-outs and yelled at other employees in front of passengers. She then claimed that all of this hard work stressed her out and didn't show up for SIX MONTHS. Still they haven't fired her (they say they need to build a case) Last week they made a deal and transfered her to an area many seasoned officers have tried to get to for years and let her come back to work.

So I have to ask, Is my employer racist?


Tiffany
You could have a bit of favortism at your company. I would first speak with your immediate supervisor and ask them what their policy is on bonus' and seniority...Make sure you get it in writing...If it doesn't add up, then you start the process of keeping a record or list of things that seem to be running you into this arena of feeling taken advantage of. You find out who is hire up and what the procedure would be in order to get this taken care of...Be mindlful of who you discuss this with as it could very well turn into a battle...There are several organizations that you can contact as well that could help you with your situation...


gunplumber_462
Rating
Quite possible. Or it could be a mistake or there might be other factors involved. You could ask them to explain the discrepancy and correct it, but if it's intentional you may have a nasty fight ahead of you. Hopefully it's just a mistake.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Does raping a child warrant the death penalty?
The court just rejected this proposal. Your thoughts?...


 Should the hijab headscarf be allowed in Law courts?
i thought a law court is where one faced their acussers and and that wearing a hijab by juror, wittness or defendent would not be allowed. today a juror is found to be listerning to a mp3 player ...


 Should George Bush Stand Trial for Crimes Against Humanity?
...


 Can i **LEGALLY DO THIS ?**?
well im goin 2 mexico city pretty soon and i want to bring like 4 small turtles to the us ........ can i do this legally at all ?...


 Marijuana!?
Why is marijuana considered dangerous?

Despite popular belief it does NOT kill brain cells. It only weakens the dendrites in the brain, which grow back in a few weeks anyway. This myth was ...


 My husband has been hand supeoned for a domestic batterey charge against me before we were married?
he does nopt want to testify against me now bieng his wife, what would happen if he did not show up for court? they have only 10 days left to try the case. what would the conserquence be for him by ...


 Do i have to pay income tax?
there is no law saying i do, cant i just go into court defend myself, and say thats there is no law, so i dont have to pay, i would have an unbeatable case..wouldnt I?...


 My hubby is being harrassed by a german stockholding/shareholders company by phone?
he's spent days telling them no but they keep ringing us, then going on for ages about how great the shares are, then when he says no they start with 'have i just been wasting my time' ...


 About Weed Being illegal!!!!!Who agrees??
I think it should not be illegal anywhere. ITS A FRICKIN PLANT!!!!! It is something of nature so if you get caught with it you get into trouble for having a PLANT with you. What if someone threw some ...


 If you think abortion is murder, would you retrospectively prosecute women if the law changed?
If abortion was made illegal, would you start prosecuting the women who'd had abortions? Of course, there is usually a presumption against retrospectively prosecuting people when a law is ...


 If you are in court and you don't believe in god.....?
who do you swear the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth on?...


 Is it legal to have a butterfly (aka balisong) knife?
I live in New York and it's a butterfly knife. I just want to carry it in my purse, I don't plan on fighting or stabbing people at all. Is that illegal at all? This site makes it seem like ...


 What can be done about assault at work? do you consider it assault?
i was off the clock at work waiting for my ride and sitting on a chair. my co-worker came from behind told me to get off the chair and when i didnt, proceded to grab my neck from behind and throw me ...


 Would it be discriminatory to the elderly to require more frequent driving tests from them?
I'm sure AARP would be up in arms over civil liberties violations, but facts are facts... as the human body wears out, both physically and mentally, driving becomes more difficult and more ...


 Should polygamy be legalized?

Additional Details
Let me just say that I am a married woman AGAINST polygamy, so to a certain someone who called me a not so friendly name, maybe you should think your words through ...


 Why is Sacrifice no longer honorable??
Our military gets harassed for putting themselves on the line...most people don't have the whatever you want to call it to fight for what's right. It's because of sacrifice that the P...


 I was asked to vacate my apartment?
I,m being kicked out after being here at my apartment for one year the lease is up and i was asked to leave they will not give me a reason why Can they do this by law?...


 Bob Spink MP for Castle Point has said that more criminals are black. What do youi think?
In yesterdy's Mirror it read that Castle Point's MP Bob Spink has said that Most Criminals are Black. Being that he is an MP in an area where Blacks are the minority do you think he has a ...


 Change the law!?
I can't believe that if a burgular breaks into my house and is unarmed and I defend myself and shoot them, I will be the one charged not them...WHY???...How does THAT work!
do I ask 'A...


 Do you think drug testing violates human rights?
I need people's opinions on pre-employement drug testing. Should it be legal? Does it violate human rights?...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.074