Is this inhumane?

kehkohjones

Sounds great if only you could be sure that you were not sending at least one innocent person there, too.

I suggest doubling the time for all prisoners and making it mandatory for them to learn a skill and be put to work to offset the cost of their keep. For example, they should learn to sew and have them make clothes for the poor in Africa or Indonesia. Teach them to make shoes for the poor. If they refuse to learn a trade, they must work for their food or be given the worse food in prison. When released from prison, they will have ten years with which they must stay clean and out of trouble, or be returned to prison to repeat the sentence or do the new one, whichever is longer.

If they become violent in prison, they should be sent to the island where the sharks are kept fed to some extent (to attract sharks and ensure they don't try to escape by swimming or building a raft). That is not inhumane; it is called segregating the criminal predators that cannot be rehabilitated from society.

missourim43

Appologies to our fine Aussie friends and allies for the crude remarks.......
Those comments have no relationship the the Australia of today.

scouse_182fan

Good idea about the island, but what about dropping a WMD right in the middle and wiping every one of the filthy scumbags out . I`d pay money on pay-per-view too watch that

zac

Too good for them!!

chris s

aries was nearly right, save its a-merica not a-ustralia,!

passionparties_by_suzanne

That is mor humane than my idea.

I Seek

You think THAT'S inhumane!? Check out the inhumane treatment U.S. citizens will experience next. Who do you think are the worst criminals of all?...
http://www.global-conspiracies.com/fema_concentration_camps.htm

methamphetamine_symposium

There is a fair chance they will kill each other fairly quickly, so great idea!

sunflare63

Sounds like a genious idea . Great Idea Sherlock Holmes....

Tetchy Old Git

Sounds too constructive to me.
A giant hamster wheel is better. Twenty hours a day, seven days a week.

rere

I've had that idea for years..........or maybe a Siberia.

telboy everton forever

yes give them Poland as they are all coming here

goldengirl

How about putting them on survivor island with a guest host televised..

fae

good idea.

scout485

Why an island. I want to go to one, and not have to do anything but just grow my own food. Sounds like paradise to me. Send them to antartica, make it a lot tougher. Leave the islands for those of us who are law abiding.

Veritas

Like your first respondent stated, that was the idea behind Australia about two hundred years ago. Don't forget, that the man who recently spent three years in jail for a rape that he did not commit, would have gone there.

plss*dont*kill*me

Australia ? why ? i dont get it

mike

put two murderers(or robbers)in a cell 1 bullet & 1gun.put the living with a rapist.then shoot the rapist.
see it all works out with my plan.

BJK

wow not a bad idea, but good luck catching them all.
Happy Hunting!

Lady

No it's not inhuman, but then on the other hand everybody makes mistakes, and am sure that both you and I had done something we wished we could change but can't.
All those people you mention deserved everything you said, but I believed in second chances and I believed that everyone should be given one.

No, I have always thought that the "Escape from New York" idea was a great idea. Let them fend for themselves. I don't think it is very realistic in today's society but maybe someday in the future.

Robert Abuse

Could you really tolerate more `Neighbours` or `Home and Away` ?

Because that is what the future would hold.

suzr12002

This is my opinion as well..they deserve nothing. Austrailia of course

banditblue1200

Can they make a living out of being a child abuser, rapist or murderer ?

can I have the job throwing them out of the plane?

Raj

It's not inhumane and in fact is not a bad idea but it would never happen. It's not practical.

mighty_power7

no. they would realize that life isn't easy and they dont always get what they want.

C_Millionaire

not a great idea, not exactly inhumane, but pointless. impractical, and stupid because one of the major reasons for punishing people is so they learn to not do it again, and your scheme doesn't allow for that, never mind all the logistical problems. and of course the vast majority of them DO work for a living anyways, that's how they buy food and pay the rent. how did you think they did it?

Cal

That's how Australia got started.

Enter Your Message or Comment

User Name:
User Email:
Post a comment: