Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law & Ethics

Nazi Avatar - Should it be allowed on this site?
Find answers to your legal question.





Nazi Avatar - Should it be allowed on this site?

I have posed a few Q's on the military site and on two occasions have had answers from a member (level 2) who's avatar is the 3rd Reich’s symbol of a swastika being carried by a Spread eagle.

I personally find this offensive and have reported the matter as such, with the suggestion that this symbol be removed.

What do you guys think?
.
Additional Details
Message to yp_paul_collinsville. I lived in Germany for 18 months and have personaly experienced Neo'sThey are frightening.

I come from UK so maybe you might change your mind with the threat of Nazi invasion and the Holocaust.


    




malaclypse
Rating
people should be able to put swastikas on whatever they want. if seeing a swastika can actually turn someone into a nazi, or incite some type of hatred, then we have bigger problems as a society than whether or not swastika avitars should be allowed.

as for you finding it offensive, i don't mean to be cold, but that's your own problem.

on a somewhat unrelated note- the swastika is a beautiful symbol with positive connotation used by many cultures that predate the nazis by thousands of years, and to let a bunch of nazi ******* ruin the symbol is kind of a shame.


John B
I think that everybody should be allowed to openly express his stupidity as he so chooses.


jj raider
Rating
while the symbol is repulsive to me --- I believe in freedom of expression so I don't believe that is enough reason to remove this avatar?
after all someone else might be offended by your avatar.


anthony9223
I think this is still a free country but we are losing our freedoms through people like you it is just a symbol it dose not mean anything unless you want it to


The Patriot
Rating
I do not like the nazi swastika, but I think that the person should be allowed to have it as their avatar.

Put it this way, what about the Hindu one? If the 'Nazi' uses that instead, would you still report him/her.

If they want to make it even easier for us to see how evil and intolerant his/her right wing policies are, so be it.


ligiersaredevilspawn
Rating
If it offends you don't look at it. The guy has the right to express what he beleives in just as much as you do; it's a free country and what our grandparents fought for. Simply going around saying this should be banned and that should be banned simply because you find it offensive is offensive to me; does this mean you should be banned?
Don't get me wrong here I don't beleive in all that zich heil stuff either but you need to realise that we need to protect our freedom of speech, and that includes the right to use images in my mind ( so long as they can't corrupt ).


The conservative lifer
yahoo can make their own rules ebcause it is their site. If it was a US government run site, they could do this because it is freedom of speech.


Captain Sarcasm
Surely freedom of speech and the right to express yourself is more important than upsetting someones sensibilities?


2600
unless the guy or girl is saying nasty stuff i would let them alone each to their own, a lot a people knock me for mine and my user name


banjet15
A swastika not being carried by an eagle has it's origins in India.


galyamike
Rating
Who cares? That was all a long time ago.


Sam S
Just ignore it then. What is so terrible about being 'offended'? Nobody ever died from being offended as far as I know.


Al
i agree, shouldnt be allowed


Paul W
I can see your point, and yes it is very upsetting to some people. The problem is where do you stop? There are probably people who find all kind of avatars offensive, do we also remove them? Do we also remove the Hammer and Sickle and those that portray anti-Christian, Satanist symbols, etc. I think in this day and age it would be most difficult to remove these kinds of symbols purely because people find them offensive.


nick p
Rating
Personally, I think that if crooks and criminals run this country and are free to do what they want in the USA, then do you really think that a little avatar is really going to hurt you.


Whirlibomber
Rating
Well the swastika goes back so far..very often used in Celtic art etc. Old matey Adolf just stole it and twisted it forward to the right a bit. The 'Swastika' itself is beautiful and to be found in very many cultures, so no worries there. Just don't forget it was Hitler that kinda made (in)famous. He couldn't even invent his own symbol and neither can the Neo Nazis(either celtic or Viking). So enjoy the swastika for what it really is-peace.


ronnie m
You have a right to be offended and the other member has a right to use his nazi avatar. You can't choose who has rights and who hasn't in a free society.


james.
Yeah, he's allowed to have that avatar. To ban the swastika as an avatar would be an infringement on the first ammendment to our constitution. The first ammendment is one of the philosophies that makes the USA great. I quote Voltaire: "I may disagree with what you say, but i will defend to the death your right to say it."


junglejungle
Rating
thing is the swastika symbol is also used by hindu's, look it up on google.

but yer if its the eagle and all that stuff.. perhaps you should





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Can my employer stop me from telling people my current rate of pay?
I live in Duluth, MN USA. Please state the law/rule/ordience if you find one thank you.
Additional Details
Why? I don't care for your opinions, I just want fact. Lets say this ...


 Can I sue for inaccurate background report?
I successfully interviewed for a job and most likely had the job until my background check came back with Armed Robbery,Sale of Narcotics which I was not convicted of...this was not the first time ...


 Do you pay child support on bonus or overtime pay ?
My employee makes $320 wk on 40hrs and gets another $150 on overtime. But we slow down in the winter. Do they base it on 40 hrs , or yearly ? ( in arkansas )...


 Would you favor a 3 strikes law for abortions?
It seems to me that one of the greatest fears of the pro-life crowd is that without regulation, people will use abortions as a form of birth control which I agree is wrong. So, in that line, would ...


 Should marijuana be legal?
Marijuana is just as bad as cigarettes and alcohol, so why should it be excluded. other states are beining to agree, such as colorado. so why are we so worried about it. it would keep more people out ...


 Why is marijuna illegal?
I never understood why marijuana is illegal. It's been scientifically proven that is nor a physically addictive or brain damaging drug. Only a small percentage of marijuana smokers use it on a ...


 Should a library in a Black community be forced to carry books by the KKK?

Additional Details
This question concerns a fundamental misunderstanding of the first ammendment.

The right to free speech means you can say or publish anything you want.
...


 Should the government reduce taxes on cigarettes to make smoking more affordable for young people?
Right now I have to work for 1 hour just to be able to afford a pack, this has got to stop!...


 If one innocent person is executed, is the price too high to keep using capital punishment?
I challenge anyone to prove that no innocent person has ever been executed in the US....


 In some states prositution is legal , do u agree or oppose that it stays legal?
...


 Should an obese person get the privelage to park in a handicap spot?
At work today there was a gentleman in a wheelchair (who is legitimately handicapped) who couldn't park in the handicapped spot because someone who is overweight parked there due to his handicap-...


 I have recently experienced English justice in an English court, 5 points for who guesses what happened?
My first time in an English court! Regarding the Police and the Judge and the Solicitor and Myself, can you guess what happened?...


 What does it mean when people say "I plead the 5th" in court??????????
i was just wondering because i say it on "THE CLOSER" a few days ago....


 How can we make churches/synagogues/mosqu... pay taxes?
IMO religion/spirutal services are bought and sold just like cell phone service or cable TV. How can we (the voter-taxpayers) get them paying taxes, just like other businesses?...


 Are pro-choicers also against mandatory seat-belt laws?
just another choice to think about.
Additional Details
Its about choice over ones body....right?...


 I was at the cardiologist yesterday and, while waiting in the waiting room...?
I picked up a magazine from Kraft and it had this recipe for a layer cake which was made from a layer of ice cream sandwiches, you know the kind with the cookie and the ice cream filling, then a ...


 Is it illegal to open post that is not addressed to you?
I am writing an article and need to know if it is illegal and if so does anyone know where I can get more information about this....


 Custody of Daughter???
My daughter, who is 5, lives with me and her stepfather. Her biological father lives across the country, pays child support, but rarely sees her. My mother has been part of my daughter's life ...


 Just trying to settle an argument so my question is, is there anyway that a polygraph test can be beaten?
I am saying it can an several others say no way....


 Legal drinking age?
I'm 19 yrs old..In april im going on a cruise to mexico..someone told me the legal drinking age on the ship is 18, is that true? I know there I can drink while in mexico, but what about actually ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.024