Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law & Ethics

Oklahoma wants to give the death penalty to child molesters... is this right?
Find answers to your legal question.





Oklahoma wants to give the death penalty to child molesters... is this right?

http://www.oksenate.gov/news/press_releases/press_releases_2006/pr20060120a.html

Would this be ethical? Should the State have the power to murder it's citizens? Isn't this more harsh than an "eye for an eye"? Wouldn't this represent too harsh a sentence? Or is this totally appropriate? Should other crimes be listed under the death penalty?


    




cwilson_192002
I was molested by my brother when I was 13 and while I would like to say yes, I can't. I've forgiven my brother since then, but my forgiving him doesn't mean that I've suddenly forgot about the entire incident or that I approve of what happened. I think this is not the corse to take. I do think that harsher penalties should be in place though. There was one case that I was watching on Court TV and this guy raped a minor and only got 6 months for it. That's a slap on the wrist. I don't this would be grounds for you to use the word murder though. These child molesters in a sense have murdered their victims, because I and many others will never be the same. I use the word murder because that is exactly what it seems like because they kill your soul and any hope you had for the future.


.45 Peacemaker
Rating
Absolutely. I have dealt with people that have been assaulted. The damage is worse than what happens with murder.

The law isn't dealing with first timers this is more a habitutal offender law.


?
I'm strongly in favor of the death penalty, but I think that child molester's get punished plenty in prison. I say give them a life of being raped by inmates. That's a better punishment.


Maverick
great idea.
Michael Jackson would be dead by now uh ?


blorgo
If we must have a death penalty, it should be reserved for people who have been convicted of the premeditated killing of another person. There are too many cases where a person convicted of a crime in this country has been proven innocent. If the person is in prison, at least our society can partially rectify the error. That's pretty hard to do if the poor guy is in his grave.


Brujita
Rating
Death penalty for child molesters is an easy escape.
Someone so sick to do anything like that to a child deserves something different.
I agree with the castration.


sheleo72675
Rating
I'm usually quite liberal, but in this case. . . If someone violates a child, honestly, I might support this or life imprisonment. Most states have minimal penalties for this, pedophiles have the highest recidivism rate of any crime and yet they are sent free.


Karma CP
Rating
I say ship them all off to an island (if they try to swim to escape, let the sharks have them). Have little huts, with no running water, some seeds for planting, and a few cows, pigs, chickens, etc... Give them the tools they need to survive, and walk away. Let them survive on their own, without taxpayers having to pay for their room and food, medical, and lawyer bills. Lastly, let them all bugger each other, so that no child ever has to become another victim of this highly repetitive criminal mentality.

There... No death penalty, no tax $ paying for their life behind bars, kids safe.


KittyMeowGrrrr
it all depends on the laws


mason78_03
Rating
what if it were your child? what would you do? I know i'd kill the sicko child molester.


dragonfly9151974
I would like to say yes, but the only crimes that should be punishable by death are high treason and murder.

just for your future reference: The word murder refers to the act of taking human life in violation of the law. The word you should be using in the context you are discussing is execute.


Global Citizen
Child Molestors are horrible creatures. I say creatures because there's nothing human about molesting children, just like those who kill innocent people.

Now if the person who did the molesting is mentally ill, then he or she is excused, otherwise, he should be severely punished, possibly killed. The idea is that child rape is a horrible crime and the death penalty would be a good deterent.


prettygirl
Death penalty is not justice.

But it won't go anywhere. It will only get worse.
One day they will be putting people to death because of their religious beliefs.

In the mean time if you disagree with this, write the Governor.


catfordken
Rating
remember the original idea behind the death penalty was that no one who wants to live would commit the crime but we all know there are those who think they can get away with it,so in a real world you try to find a punishment that fits the crime,what would that be for a child molester,molest him no thanks kick it out of him,that would not work as nor would castration,so whats left


notgnal
Rating
no but they should be castrated


manson_brooke
Rating
let me tell you something..if i have a child and someone molests my child i would kill them myself no matter what the situation is. I think they should execute in more states. I would probally hang them in the middle of my town for everyone to laugh at..they deserve what they get..and no im not psycho but thats the way that i feel


everest
Death penalty is never right under any situation for following reasons:

(1) It's not reversible (what if the person turns out to be innocent - solved 25 years later....)
(2) We can not give life, so we have no right to take it.
(3) There is not strong indication, that death penalty reduces the rate of crimes.


jessardo
Rating
sure, why not?


jeremy_14_13_4
Rating
What would you want to happen to the cruel SOB that victimized a child that you cared about. If you think that a violent offender doesn't deserve whatever punishment he is given, ask yourself this: Did that victim deserve what happened to him?


planksheer
Rating
This is just what I would expect from Oklahoma. Surprised Texas is not doing this first. Wonder if we'll burn them at the stake or be happy with public hangings ?





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Question for ALL smokers -?
How will the smoking ban effect you whilst out in bars and clubs after the July 1st? Are you dreading it?
Will you go to bars and clubs as often or will you hibernate in Winters?
I am not ...


 How can the government allow a product that says smoking kills to be sold?
I dont know of any other product on sale that says this kills you
and is allowed to be sold i think it is incredible
i know the government makes a fortune out of it but i just
...


 If i was selling a teddy called Mohammed...?
would anyone buy it??

Im thinking about designing and buying a shed load of cuddly toys from a factory in the North of England. My plan was then to have each teddy embroidered with the ...


 Can i drop out at age 16 ? teacher sed no cause of court ?
she sed the court will chose if yes or no to drop out at age 16 ?

live in lexington kentucky usa

yes i know i need parent signature but court if yes or no ? cause i missed ...


 Is it against the law to NOT pay for your child's funeral with the life insurance check??
I know its sorry but I was wondering if there is actually a law against it. My 9 month old grandbaby died and instead of the "dad"(I use this term loosely) paying for the funeral, ...


 Can the war on drugs be won?
The governor of Florida recently stated that he wants to start executing drug dealers and that he can win the war on drugs.
Can the war on drugs be won if this policy is implemented?...


 Can my employer stop me from telling people my current rate of pay?
I live in Duluth, MN USA. Please state the law/rule/ordience if you find one thank you.
Additional Details
Why? I don't care for your opinions, I just want fact. Lets say this ...


 Can I sue for inaccurate background report?
I successfully interviewed for a job and most likely had the job until my background check came back with Armed Robbery,Sale of Narcotics which I was not convicted of...this was not the first time ...


 Do you pay child support on bonus or overtime pay ?
My employee makes $320 wk on 40hrs and gets another $150 on overtime. But we slow down in the winter. Do they base it on 40 hrs , or yearly ? ( in arkansas )...


 Would you favor a 3 strikes law for abortions?
It seems to me that one of the greatest fears of the pro-life crowd is that without regulation, people will use abortions as a form of birth control which I agree is wrong. So, in that line, would ...


 Should marijuana be legal?
Marijuana is just as bad as cigarettes and alcohol, so why should it be excluded. other states are beining to agree, such as colorado. so why are we so worried about it. it would keep more people out ...


 Why is marijuna illegal?
I never understood why marijuana is illegal. It's been scientifically proven that is nor a physically addictive or brain damaging drug. Only a small percentage of marijuana smokers use it on a ...


 Should a library in a Black community be forced to carry books by the KKK?

Additional Details
This question concerns a fundamental misunderstanding of the first ammendment.

The right to free speech means you can say or publish anything you want.
...


 Should the government reduce taxes on cigarettes to make smoking more affordable for young people?
Right now I have to work for 1 hour just to be able to afford a pack, this has got to stop!...


 If one innocent person is executed, is the price too high to keep using capital punishment?
I challenge anyone to prove that no innocent person has ever been executed in the US....


 In some states prositution is legal , do u agree or oppose that it stays legal?
...


 Should an obese person get the privelage to park in a handicap spot?
At work today there was a gentleman in a wheelchair (who is legitimately handicapped) who couldn't park in the handicapped spot because someone who is overweight parked there due to his handicap-...


 I have recently experienced English justice in an English court, 5 points for who guesses what happened?
My first time in an English court! Regarding the Police and the Judge and the Solicitor and Myself, can you guess what happened?...


 What does it mean when people say "I plead the 5th" in court??????????
i was just wondering because i say it on "THE CLOSER" a few days ago....


 How can we make churches/synagogues/mosqu... pay taxes?
IMO religion/spirutal services are bought and sold just like cell phone service or cable TV. How can we (the voter-taxpayers) get them paying taxes, just like other businesses?...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.034