Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law & Ethics

Punched in the face, and knocked down by drunk patient in hospital?
Find answers to your legal question.





Punched in the face, and knocked down by drunk patient in hospital?

Just over a week ago i was just finishing my shift in work at my local hospital when i went over to use the cash machine,while i was there a drunk man came out of the A&E and walked over to me, cornered me at the cash point, and leaned over me and sayd in a drunken voice, i dont feel well, i told him to stand back, he was making me uncomfortable, he repeated it again and this time i said, im not a nurse! he then punched me on the cheekbone, fell on top of me were i hurt the back of my neck, he then fell on top of me,were i had to push him off.i then called security and they phoned the police, he was arrested and is been charged with assault, im now off work,with a sore neck, and feel very nervous about going back to work, Ouestion is, does any one think i should sue the hospital, or put a claim in.
Additional Details
Im not trying to make a fast buck, as someone put it, we have a zero tolerance thing in our hospital, to help protect the staff, the drunk man was wondering around refuseing treatment, oh there was nothing wrong with him, only he was drunk, and the security were sitting in the room watching tv, and yes they do have to look out for the staff, i am only trying to get compensated for lose of earnings, i only work part time and not entitled to sick pay, why should i have to suffer because of a drunk man, and why should i be made feel guilty because of it, for those who have been nasty, maybe some day someone will knock you to the ground, and we will see how you deal with it.!!!


    




sicwidit
Rating
Weather or not people believe this, you can sue the hospital due to the fact that it is a state/federally funded institution that must protect the well being of patients/staff and the public. Talk to a Lawyer, they will tell you the same thing.
to all of those who kept saying "just sue the drunk, or you cant sue the hospital", sorry the world has changed, when an idiot makes it impossible or impractical to work, EVERYONE can be held accountable for others actions.

TO EVERYONE WHO IS GIVING NEGATIVE RESPONSES: WISE UP!! one day something will happen, it wont be your fault, and there will be nothing you can do about it, but something will happen horribly someday. like what happened here there WAS someone who could do something about it and they did nothing now a person is hurt. It is not like she is blaming another person for something that she did to herself, a DRUNK PERSON HURT HER ON HOSPITAL PROPERTY AND SECURITY WAS TOO LATE TO REACT. the hospital is responsible due to the fact that they have security within the hospital. read up on the laws. any establishment that willingly or forcibly has a security system/person force is responsible for the safety and well being of all persons within said establishment.


jimi
Rating
You don't need to sue the hospital, just the idiot that assaulted you.


Ammo
Rating
What can you sue the hospital for? The drunken idiot is the one who needs to be sued


Necrid
God we're getting more like the Americans everyday.


Taloollah
Why sue the hospital? They haven't done anything wrong!

The hospital security staff did their job and helped you.

If anything, you should be suing the guy who assulted you!


Nikki C
Sue the guy who punched you, it was not an accident to which the hospital were responsible so I don't see how they can hold any blame.
Only "Where there is blame theres a claim", so the saying goes, which is a very sad culture we live in today !


?
Sue the hospital? Have you been helping yourself to drugs?
I'd give you nothing, just for considering suing the hospital.


David B
can't exactly sue the hospital, but you can sue the person.
contact a lawyer if you want.


Gar
Rating
Compensation should be sought from the man who injured you. Try not to let this incident affect your life, think of all the times you went to work without any problems. It's hard, I know, but it's important to get a perspective on this. Good Luck!


Empress
whilst what happened to you is really terrible im not really sure why you would be suing the hospital?
its not their fault?
and if you win . . . you could be taking money away from an ill patient . . . does that make you feel better about what happened to you?


Joycie
For goodness sake talk sense. Its not the hospitals fault. Sue the drunk!


atlantis
Rating
it really angers me, when people like this abuse the very people that are there to help them! What is happening to this country? Im so sorry that you were attacked in this way hun, its dispicable.
Personally i would not sue the hospital, but i would press charges against this horrible excuse for a person, and sue his butt!!
good luck hun xx


birdie
Sorry, you were hurt!!!...but NOW you are just another scam artist trying to make a buck...and off the very place that you make a living from...that if you win a suit like this will have to keep your wages lower to cover their losses...Sheesh!

You know, they acually don't HAVE to provide you with security. Its nice that they did, though....


ole max.
Rating
you could work at a florist, sure the flowers wont punch you. drunks come into the ER every night. I shoulda sued my school when i got punched in the 2nd grade. i coulda got the kids milk money. wonder if its too late?


momof3granof1
You are better suing the man also claim compensation off the criminal injury board as you have lost time of work etc keep all records of everything police number the lot.
I hope you feel better soon and do not rush back to work they will have Occupation Health for you to go and see and talk this through.


LISA H
Rating
sue the drunk not the hospital, maybe when he can't afford to get hammered he will see the error of his ways.


esmerelda v
See a solicitor, the only way you will get money out of the hospital is if you are able to show they should have taken action against him prior to him assaulting you. If it was obvious to anyone that the guy presented a threat, the hospital should hve called the police BEFORE he caused trouble.

If the guy who assaulted you has any assets, you could sue him.


METALLICA
I would press charges on the Drunk Man.


roger.williams20@btinternet.com
I do not think the hospital is responsible in any way.


Rommel
Rating
why should you sue the hospital? its hardly the hospitals fault that some drunken idiot assaulted you out side the premises.


eentweedrievier2007
In the USA, you have two things to consider:
-Criminal charges against the drunk, for the crime of assault and battery.
-Civil charges against the drunk, for the liability (monetary damages) against you.

In either case, the hospital is not the party you are charging.

I am not an attorney licensed to practice law in the state of North Carolina, and I may not give legal advice or accept fees for legal advice.


finglas9
the man will be proven to have asaulted you via police records. you can sue him. The hospital have a duty of care towards you a you ar employed by them and part of your duty is to be able to get food from the machine on there premises. Although the hospital is not directly responsible they have to assist you for an injury whilst you were on duty. I am sure the actions of the security staff would be very much in question if the man had assaulted a member of the public. You are entitled to no less protection. Sue the man then contact your union they will know because unfortunately assaults on hospital staff are common these days. Put a claim in as an assault/injury on duty. The hospital know that drunken louts cause trouble in A&E therfore they have to provide proper protection. As staff are not trained in self defence yet assaults are common.


nolongerhere
Sue the hospital? Perhaps we could sue the estate agents we purchased our homes from following a robbery.........sue parents for our existence..............sue God himself for the crap weather were having! Its terrible whats happened to you, however, trying to find blame with the hospital seems despicable. Perhaps its shock, if its not, you should work in a bubble or on cloud cuckoo. Sorry but that's my opinion. I hope your injuries will recover quickly, I'm sure the care and treatment your receiving is invaluable. Good luck with claiming damages from the perpetrator who done this to you.


NSangel
well, if you take action against the hospital you work at, will sure make things uncomfortable if you want to keep working.

on the other hand, they should not have allowed this man to roam around. that's what security is there for. so, i would file a complaint and ask them to cover my off time and all my medical if they haven't done so already.

and you said your feeling nervous about going back. you should seek a psychologist. you've been assaulted and are feeling experiencing anxiety. i wouldn't let it go unchecked.

i had a similar experience where i was assaulted (grabbed only), and ended up having agoraphobia. couldn't go anywhere alone. had to have a babysitter all the time. this went on over 10 years!

so wish you all the best. hope you get back to your old self very soon.


redgator40
get a lawyer so they can explain your options. sounds like you might have a work comp claim. hey to all the idiots who say sue the drunk. you're dead wrong. you can't sue him. its a work comp claim against the hospital. you can go after the drunk for assault and battery.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 If you are 18 and decide to move out of your parents house is there anyway they can legaly stop you from movin
If you move out of of your parents house, can they stop you from going back and getting your stuff?...


 Can I sue my landlord for not buying me a new washer?
My apartment is $2800 a month. Our washer broke down about 5 months ago. The maintenance guys said we would need a new one and informed the landlord. We have also included a note with every month&#...


 Who is dreading the thought of the smoking ban in enclosed spaces in England 01/07/2007?
I know restaurants, bars and clubs will feel the pinch!...


 Is it stealing ????????
if your spouse washes your clothes and finds 50 bucks and keeps it and keeps it, is that stealing, be honest....


 I got an email form this lady who lived in france saying she's dieing and want to leave me all her funds?
now is this a scam or what but she isnt asking for my credit card# or social security #???...


 Pls HELP! SOMEONE CALLED CPS ON US!!!?
About two weeks ago my husband and I smoked a joint at our friends birthday party and someone found out and called CPS on us. Niether one of us drink beer or smoke and I really regret smoking that ...


 Will cannabis be legalised?
ive heard they are gonna legalise it this year any ...


 Why is it so difficult to legalize gay marriage..i don't understand?
I am an American citizen who pays taxes. why am I made to feel second class, I do not have the same rights as most Americans why is this,. because im different I love my country but don’t understand ...


 Is this abuse? I don't know the law but I am pretty sure it is?
okay so 2day I my dad like freaked out at me cuz he found out that I had like helped my friends spraypaint my principals car I mean it wasn't like I was the one that was spraypainting I was just ...


 Is the smoking ban a good thing.?
i agree with eating places, but pubs and clubs should be left to owners choice, and display a sign in the window by law, eg; smoking, none smoking. after all this is meant to be a free country,people ...


 You think rehab will check for gender in urine if sent to lab?
...


 If somebody pays somebody else to attack a person (me) can that person be prosecuted or only the attacker?
I think someone is trying to get me beaten up, but that person themselves wont be doing it, theyl be paying someone else to.

Can they be prosecuted for this, or can only the person they ...


 If you had an accident and killed a person should you be arrested for manslaughter?
No DUI, nor speeding nor overt distractions (like cell phones, etc). Just someone breaks hard, you dont catch it that instant, and hit them.

Why is Brandy/Moesha being charged?...


 Persons who show disrespect towards Our National Anthem must be given 5 years rigorous imprisonment?
Please comment on ...


 I found the person who molested me as a child?
Can I tell people about it .can he sue me for slander, In Georgia. Atlanta area.can t prove it.hes a millionare buisness man.now.Thanks
Additional Details
the reason I say hes got money ,...


 3 reasons why beers are better than women?
...


 Is to drink under age a crime?
...


 Have you ever?
been handcuffed, either in real or fake handcuffs, in front or in back?...


 Is swearing in the workplace misconduct or gross misconduct?
My colleague has been suspended for using one profanity in the workplace, on one occasion. My colleague has not recieved feedback previously regarding this matter yet has now been invited to a ...


 Where do you stand in the law if ?
you are walking down the street and you accidently kick a stone and it hits a car windscreen?...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.034