Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law & Ethics

Saw this on Dr Phil today....?
Find answers to your legal question.





Saw this on Dr Phil today....?

On Dr Phil today, a woman was sued for breaking up a marriage (having an affair with a married man). She claims she did not know he was married (he said he was separated). She was sued and settled.....in what states is this legal?
Additional Details
I'm not sueing anyone....just curious to see where this was legal (luv my hubby). I found it hard to believe and just wondered what state would allow this!


    




schazjmd
You used to be able to sue for alienation of affections. "However, since 1935, the alienation of affections tort has been abolished by at least 39 states as an archaic and outdated form of revenge. Since most states have abolished alienation of affections, wronged spouses have tried to recover damages under the cause of action known as intentional infliction of emotional distress (IIED). Courts have generally recognized IIED as separate and distinct from alienation of affections, so that IIED may be available against a third party for conduct that breaks up a marital relationship, even in states that have abolished alienation of affections."

http://www.divorcenet.com/states/ohio/ohart_10


Momma
Rating
I don't know but thats GREAT,
If my old man ever cheats on me I will sure both of them

Meg


Julia D
Rating
Wow I don't know what states that's legal in, but that's awesome!


Jerry C
Rating
In every state. You can file suit against almost anyone for almost anything. Whether you get anything out of it or not is a different matter.


The Girl Is A Geek
Rating
I don't know but I am starring your question because it is very interesting!


Home wreckers don't have to deal with any of the fall out they cause....maybe being able to do this would make those people with "happy pants' think twice.


And if she settled, then there must be something more to the story. You don't settle when you are innocent!


Happy
Rating
It's called alienation of affection.

I remembered reading several months ago of a husband suing his wife's lover and winning. You can read the story below. Kinda interesting.


adnerb
I don't know....but I thinks it's a darn good thing. I usually don't go for the suing thing but, having recently been cheated on.........I wish I could nail her butt to the wall....his too......I blame him more than her, but what a nasty woman.


Geoff C
In North Carolina you can be sued for loss of affection for breaking up a marriage

http://www.rosen.com/ppf/Law/Divorce/rosen/201/articles.asp


savahna5
I wouldnt know i imagine its the first case.

However way to go at revenge. I suggest she sue BOTH of them and they both pay for damages. I'm sure this woman had to pay at their hands.


Hillary
Rating
There are a couple of states that technically have these "alienation of affection" laws still on the books, but they're rarely used. It also seems to me that the chick on that show was full of it, or lied about something, because certainly if she can prove or even demonstrate that she didn't know the guy was married, she could have avoided paying anything in that lawsuit. If she didn't know, that's pretty much the textbook definition of an affirmative defense to that action.


Forever
..why..are you worried?? I didn't see it but I think it's great...however if some other woman layed her hands on my man, she'd have me to deal with, much worse than any court anywhere!!


PoohBearPenguin
You can sue any one for any thing. Whether or not you actually have a case or not is a different matter. All you need is $300 and a lawyer to file a lawsuit.

This is why there are so many stupid lawyers out there. Too many greedy lawyers are willing to just charge idiots $200/hr. to file stupid lawsuits. Even if you could fight the lawsuit and successfully counter-sue, you're still going to end up with your own $200/hr lawyer - and for what? So you can extract money out of some idiot who doesn't have a dime to his name otherwise? Oh, and then there's the years and years this whole process will take...


brian
Rating
Well sounds like you need a lawyer to answer this on.
But for real the only one that's guilty here is the judge and his religious beliefs. Think about it! If you fart in public someone in the future will be able to sue. The judge should lose his judge-ship: The separation of church and state is the real issue with a judge playing soldier of God.


wanda
Rating
i am just starting to watch the show now. if they say the state i will get back to u...


bigthinker
Rating
Not sure....But this is great news for women who have lived through Homewreckers HELL.

Please post if you find out.

thanks


baserunner316
Rating
when is Hillary suing Monica and Linda???????? I never heard of this and it's ignorant crap, kind of like saying your someone else's property. what if this guys ex was cheating FIRST???????


spdesai7
Probably Alabama.


qwelzf
It must have been proven that she DID infact know he was married and intentionaly broke them up. Although I'm not even sure if you can sue somebody for that.


Steve is a douche
dr phil is a worthless piece of ****


grips
Rating
Maybe she settled, just to get it behind her. Cheaper to settle sometimes than it is to get an attorney and fight it even on a frivolous lawsuit.


lahockeyg
Rating
Wow! I've never heard of such a thing! It seems odd to me that she would be sued and not the husband...I mean he was the one that truly knew his marital status, not her.


BLAIRwaldorf
Rating
I have no idea but the whole tihng sounds ridiculous.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Should today really be a federal holiday?
ok, my car got impounded over the weekend, i went to the dmv to get a reg. slip to get it out... but lo and behold i could not because somebody had a birthday a long time ago and the dmv is closed. ...


 Why is running from the police always a bad idea?
Besides the pepper spray and potential for serious injury, why do people run from the po-po?...


 Should Gay marriage be legal?
What do you think? I for one, do not think it should be legal. I am a strong catholic, and I don't believe it is right, it goes against my religion. I also just think it is plain wrong. A lot of ...


 Why not execute paedophiles and murderers?
I'm just curious here as I got thumbs down on an answer about prison overcrowding so I need to know why not execute paeodophiles and murderers and save tax payers money? They have destroyed or ...


 Advocates of the death penalty claim it's a deterrent rather than a punishment. Do you think it works?
If it was a deterent and it was working, there wouldn't be anyone on deathrow would there?

Though is the prospect of life in prison enough to deter people from committing serious ...


 Can sue ex for publishing personal naughty pics?
can u sue an ex bf for pasting naughty pics he took with u on the internet?

what's the cause of action / what would u be suing him for, if there wasnt any threatening involved (ie ...


 Is it illegal to payoff rear-ended driver without police or insurance involvement?
I witnessed a rear-end collision and money transaction on the freeway. The guy who was rear-ended sustained little to no damage, while the driver who did the rear-ending, his car is smashed really ...


 Why can't Miss California be entitled to her own opinion?
So what; she doesn't believe in gay marriage. That means she can't win. I thought America was a free country. But it's apparent that you must say, and think whatever is PC or your ...


 Say if you got a girl pregnant...?
and she was going to abort the baby. Do you think it would be justifiable (I know it would be illegal) for the father to kidnap the mother and keep her until she is to heavily pregnant to have an ...


 In the state of Michigan, can creditors legally harass you? I mean daily, and sometimes up to 4 times a day.?
EXAMPLE:
Doctors office, Phone Company, Gas company, credit card ...


 Can he stop our daughter from going on holiday?
I have booked a two weeks holiday to florida for me and my family, but my estranged husband is saying he will not allow our daughter to leave the country. Can he do this according to English Law?
<...


 What do you think of the suggestions that we should bring back the death penalty in this country?
First I think it's really silly and secondly I think it would make a mockery of our justice system. Also what does it say about some people's state of mind if they are willing to actually ...


 Do you agree or disagree with this statement?
Police officers tell me that it's a privilege, NOT a right to have a place to live....


 How come cigarettes and alcohol are not considered illegal drugs?
The 2 are just as addicting as cocaine and meth and can kill you as well. So how come they are not illegal so why do they continue to sell them?...


 What the hell were Octomom's doctors thinking?
Can they be brought before the ethics board for implanting so many embryos in a mentally unstable single woman on welfare who already had 6 kids?...


 Should I call the Police on my neighbor for growing a pot plant in his back yard?
He says he has a medical permission. But he has sure got a lot of new "friends" stopping by and leaving since that plant has been back their. What should I do?...


 What would I do when neighbor never returns tools ?
I need a tool, then I remember, I loaned it to my neighbor, but he never returned it. I have asked him to return it several times, what do I do now ?...


 Why do they kill race horses after they break a leg?
Shouldn't we kill our athletes who break their leg too, figuring sometimes they won't be 100% anymore? Why is it ok to just dispose of an animal in this fashion, is it because you can no ...


 Is it true that English wil one day be phased out as an international form of communicating?
...


 Explain to me how you can be Christian and a Bush Republican?
I would seriously like to know how those who describe themselves as Christian can support Bush.

- Even Bush now admits there was never any 9/11-Iraq connection or any WMDs. Isn't war ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.024