Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law & Ethics

Say if you got a girl pregnant...?
Find answers to your legal question.





Say if you got a girl pregnant...?

and she was going to abort the baby. Do you think it would be justifiable (I know it would be illegal) for the father to kidnap the mother and keep her until she is to heavily pregnant to have an abortion?


    




zara c
Rating
Sick puppy


Amanda C
Rating
Well... it wouldn't be a good idea, definately. You would have to feed and clothe her and would worry everytime she went to the loo in case she tried to escape, you would have to keep her quiet incase the neighbours heard her. You wouldn't be able to let her go outside and get, much needed, sunlight and that wouldn't be good. You probably wouldn't be able to go out to work....... too much hassle......
(I'm presuming this is really a 'say if' question, if not I apologise for being insensitive.) Xxx


melb_efc
Rating
ok its ilegal to kidnap anybody but on some level you have your rights too... and i have heard of fathers bringing the woman to court and claiming rights to the baby so after she has given birth he gets the baby.
so maybe look into that.


happyflamepepper
Rating
No! Everyone has a right to do with their body's what they wish. That does not mean i agree or disagree with abortion but it would not be right for someone to kidnap someone else and hold them against their will. While i do feel sympathy with fathers in this situation and i feel that maybe they should have some say in this as when a baby is born that they do not want they are still required to support it, so surely it works both ways.


bisquedog
The kidnap part is way wrong but I get what you are trying to say The way things are now the father of the unborn child has no say at all. That is something that should be changed but how? make it so that abortions require both the father and mother of unborn have to consent to abort the pregnancy except in cases of rape, incest or endangerment to mothers health sound like A 1/2 WAY GOOD IDEA TO ME


fartman
you are in deep poooooooooooop


willowbee
Absolutely not. She is the one that would have to suffer for 9 months and then the labour. My God, how on earth do you think up a question like this? Please don't tell me you are thinking of doing this! I know it's not particularly fair because obviously men don't get a say if a woman decides she is going to abort but there is nothing anyone can actually do about this unless medicine finds a way for men to suffer the agony of pregnancy and then the childbirth itself.
And, lets look at this another way, she wanted the baby and you didn't, would she be justified in kidnapping you to look after the child? No? Thought not!


thecharleslloyd
Rating
Humm you can't do that. Calm down and talk to your GP now. You are going mad. If you did kidnap her, that at least 15 years inside. Get help you are cracking up


Shep
Rating
No, it's not. The only thing you can do is try to get a court order stopping the abortion but you're going to have to prove that you're more than capable of raising this child on your own and even then, it's still her body that is carrying the child and the courts may not grant the stay simply on that fact alone.


kirsty b
Rating
not really at the end of the day its her body and therefore her choice. i no that doesnt seem fair to the guy but he isnt the one having to give birth.


Ajescent
No.


virgo
Rating
No, that sort of action wouldn't be justified. It would be the action of a psychopath, which isn't be the ideal candidate for parenthood. The mother wouldn't have opted for an abortion if she'd wanted to keep the baby. What's the point of bringing an unwanted baby into the world. It would just cause misery for mother and child.


SHIE L
Rating
it would be easier for you to just walk away while you can, otherwise the next time you walk free, it will be after 15 years...think about it.


Owen Money
No, two wrongs don't make right, I think the stress you would put her under would probably induce a miscarriage anyway. The real answer is Always use a condom if you don't want a baby, and make sure both of you do before planning it.


Robert B
As certain traits are hereditary maybe she does not want a baby with these traits of the father. I think you have watching to much TV . How would you cope serving 25 years for kidnap and leave behind a girl that hates you and a child that will grow to hate you ????


bead_head
If you did that and therefore made her a mother against her will, would you really think she would want you in her life and around the child? You'd only make the both of you miserable (and the child as well, because it was not wanted)


Free
Do you even know the meaning of the word justice?!
You could probably get arrested just for even thinking such a thing!! -Just you because no one else even thought of it!!


Lauren Barkley
If I were pregnant wanting to abort and you kidnapped me until I was too pregnant, I would kill the child after giving birth to it.

I might even kill you too.

They would put me in jail for insanity.

I would tell the courts that I was a grown woman with a man who wanted to treat me like a child (thus the word "kidnap") and in return I treated him like a child. I took away the only thing that made him think he was an adult.

After doing that I still saw a boy in front of me so I killed him too.

If you believe your kidnapping scheme is somewhat justifiable, this is how it would be more so.

If I were her I would pretend like things were okay and when your guard was down, I would kill you both.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Explain to me how you can be Christian and a Bush Republican?
I would seriously like to know how those who describe themselves as Christian can support Bush.

- Even Bush now admits there was never any 9/11-Iraq connection or any WMDs. Isn't war ...


 TV LICENCE, I don't have one, can they get a police caution and search my flat?
I had a letter from the tv licence people saying they will be sending people out to check if I have a tv on the premises. If I do they will fine me £1000. Can they get a police caution and search ...


 I was evicted for rent arrears, i have two kids but no one will rehouse us in any borough! do i have any right

Additional Details
the rent arrears wernt intentional, i am a single working parent and was willing to pay them off,...


 Do you think car insurance should be mandatory in all of the United States?
I live in Wisconsin. Car insurance is not required for cars trucks and anything else on the road. I think this is wrong with medical and car repair bills being so expensive these days. Worst part ...


 If you could introduce a new law...?
...what would it be and what punishment would you assign?...


 Why do most of the people who support abortion oppose the killing of whales, the cutting down of trees, the?
culling of seals, the killing of terrorists and the death penalty being imposed on convicted murderers?

This is total hypocrisy in my opinion as what is being said in effect that the ...


 I'm confused about Obama's religion.?
Obama states in his own books that he was not raised in a religious household, yet he attended a Muslim school for high school. He also states that he was raised by his mother and her parents, but ...


 If it was legal to smoke cannabis would you?
i personnally dont smoke it and dont think i would however i do think there is less violence when people are smoking it compared with alcohol i sometimes think if there was no alcohol but only ...


 Is rape ok if both people agree to it ?
just wondering ?...


 Smoking petition?
why dont all you people do what i just done and sign the petition to bring back smoking, for our landlords sake. wesite http/petitions.pm.gov.uk Details
go to public order ...


 Can excessive perfume be considered a contribution to a hostile work environment?
Many people have complained about a particular woman that seems to think that the lack of normal hygiene can be obviated by large doses of perfume.
I have talked to her about it but backed off ...


 Can some one tell me why smoking weed isn't legal yet in the united states?
i can only think legal marijuana smoking in the united states can help our ...


 I had a 9 month prison sentence in 1993...i served 41/2 months......?
please help.....do i have to admit it for a police check to be a carer?
Additional Details
You tell me tallpaul....it was 15 years ago....i'm hoping its 'spent'....


 Can the cops really search your car if they pull you over?
...


 How can I find out if a certain person owns their house ?
My daughter has been bit by the neighbor's dog and I need to find out if she owns the house in order to get paid for the medical bills related....


 Is it illegal for a 16 year old to learn to drive in an empty car park at night (supervised)?

Additional Details
ok. If I am not on a public road then I am not commiting an offence by driving (as this only applies to public roads). If I am in a private car park, then I may be ...


 It's hard to describe this question in few words, child custody, father in prison..please open.?
My son is now 2 years old. He has my last name and his father has never been in our lives. I admit I made the mistake of being with this "man" when I was young and not so wise, looking for ...


 Why are cigarettes legal? and pot is illegal?
ive tried both. i just cant understand why pot is illegal....


 Does anyone know whether the McCann's will be interviewed about their Child neglect when they return to UK??
Or have the police got something more serious to discuss with them??
Any body got any ideas??...


 What happens if you refuse to allow a police officer to perform a body search?
...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.014