Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law & Ethics

Should I Feel Guilt over my Grandfather involvment in the Holocaust?
Find answers to your legal question.





Should I Feel Guilt over my Grandfather involvment in the Holocaust?

My Grandfathers Both served in varying stages of the death camps Should I feel Guilt ?


    




Lady Ghost
Rating
No, you should not.
My Grandfather was also involved in the holocaust. He got into a fist fight with a priest and when he died they had to find a priest who was drunk to bury him.
Do not feel guilty about the past, but feel proud. Proud that your generation has not been like that, and that you have broken the cycle before it could start. What he did has not influenced who or what you are, and you should be proud.


Ms. GTO
Rating
No, you shouldn't feel guilty, but if you want to make yourself feel better, learn about the Holocaust and use your knowledge and experience to teach others so that it won't happen again.


gcbtrading
Of course you can not assume their guilt... you can, however, piss on their graves.


Joshua H
No. You weren't involved. Disgust at what they did is enough.


Matt
No, you cannot inherit the sins of your father. (Then again, that doesn't say much about a grandfather)


Jackie O
Rating
You can be and should be ashamed of THEIR actions, but you were not involved in the killings, so why should you feel guilt?


msegar
The son is not responsible for the sins of his father or grandfather.

Your life cannot be dictated by your past, unless you allow it.

Free yourself up from this situation, stay clear of like groups and life your life the way you see fit.

Let it go! This is only your problem if you want it to be!


ichyedad
You can only control what you do with your life, not what your ancestors have done with theirs. We all make enough of our own mistakes we can feel guilty about without carrying the guilt of previous generations.

If you agree with what happened in the death camps, then you should feel guilty. Otherwise, forget it. I don't feel guilty because some of my ancestors may have owned slaves or done some terrible act. I only feel guilty about my own shortfalls.

Hope this helps you.


robot_hooker3
No.


purplehippo12395
definently not! we only have family history so that we can learn from it, not be ashamed of it. learn from his mistakes and make you life more worth while. do something for someone else, make yourself not be known as the grandson of a Natzi, but a person who was reliable and helpful. make your own name. you are your own person, make "you" who you want to be.


P3epe
Not unless you were directly involved. Your ancestors' crimes aren't yours.


sixtiesradical
Rating
If you enjoy inherited ill-gotten gains like the Bush Crime Family did from trade with Nazi sweat shops. Otherwise, probably not.


tha_masha_redux
Rating
Why would you feel guilty for someone else's actions? Just because you are related does not mean that you share the same values.


skeptical
Rating
Of course not! YOU didn't do it, therefore, you are not guilty!


Senor Magoo
Rating
No. We do not punish the sons for the sins of their fathers. That is inhuman.

And the concept of collective guilt is pure evil personified, little different than the same notion of collective guilt that lead to the Holocaust.


Bill
my grandfather died in one of those death camps

he fell out of a guard tower


i'm watching washinton d.c.
Rating
Hell NO


dufus
My grandfathers rounded up people in Africa, I have no quilt only sorrow that America has to deal with all the crime now.


Natasha
Rating
The only instance I can think of where the child is legally punished for the crimes of the parent is abortion -in the case of rape or incest


Paje
Rating
We all need to be aware of injustice. As English philosopher Edmund Burke said, ‘The only thing necessary for the triumph [of evil] is for good men to do nothing.’





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Proper attire to wear to court?
I am going to go to court today to fight a ticket i received in the summer, and am now dressed in a black business suit with gray shirt and pink tie... is this too much? ...


 Do you think that students should be suspended and/or expelled for bullying and harrasing?
...


 Can I get a felony removed from my record?
it was a drug arrest for purchsing heroin...i am clean for three years ...


 If murder were legalized, would more people be murdered?
...


 Do you think there should be a law that says to only speak English?
For example, if someone is speaking some other language in a public place or home, should he be required to speak english only?
Additional Details
And live ...


 How to stop teenagers from committing crimes?
How can the problem be ...


 Why are Americans so afraid?
Whenever I get into a discussion about guns with Americans (I'm Canadian) they claim they need to have a hund gun, to protect themselves.

From what? The boogeyman?

They'...


 Death penalty - who thinks it should be applied to rapists and child molesters?
...


 How old do you have to be...?
to drop out of high school in the US?...


 Are my servants right to protest at my charges?
I pay my servants between £50 and £130 per week, and charge them each between £30 and £70 rent to sleep in their quarters. Apparently this is amount is 'crippling', especially given that I ...


 Can two people be assigned the same social security number?
...


 Someone stole my identity n im 15!!?
My unlce stole my ssn when i was small and now they cancled my health insurance and they told me that they want copies of my checks n stuff. now i have to pay for something when i turn 18. I dont ...


 If a pharmacy tech yelled out the name of medication you were taking, can the pharmacy be sued?
Especially if it was yelled out in front ogf the general public (other customers) And if so how can you sue them?...


 Can I sue? (Please HELP) My life was at risk. Serious lawsuit question...?
I was feeling ill, so went to my local clinic. There, the doctor gave me an injection for migraines without even running tests. I thought I would feel better but days later I was still feeling very ...


 Is Guantanamo bay American Soil?
...


 I've been caught shoplifting twice. What's going to happen now?
The first time i got caught shoplifting was 3 years ago. Just recently, I decided to steal a can of soda from a grocery store. I had a bag of groceries I had already bought, and put the can of soda ...


 I wore a veil on my wedding day. Should I have been banned from the church for security reasons.?
...


 How many people here are against the smoking of marijuana and can actually support their opinion?
Now c'mon seriously people.
There are plenty of valid cannabis related questions being asked here which are immediately cast aside by the uninformed and the over-opinionated. I've ...


 A serious question.....?
if someone commits murder and is sentanced to the death penalty....what makes it right that some one should sentance them to death.....how can that be justified.....
2 wrongs dont make a right......


 If you would be in charge of the system what punishment would a pedofile?
receive ?
Additional Details
receive as punishment?...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.014