Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law & Ethics

Should a "DUI" stop, be worse than a crash by a sober driver causing 3 seriously injured?
Find answers to your legal question.





Should a "DUI" stop, be worse than a crash by a sober driver causing 3 seriously injured?

I would think so, but not here, a woman ran a stop light and smashed into i mini-van putting 4 in hospital, all she got was a $ ticket, Judge said "She suffered enough knowing what she did". But same Judge put a friend of mine in jail for 6 months because he got stopped at a "DUI check point" and tested .12. That was his first ticket ever, speed or anything. Judge told him "You know how many people are injured by drunk drivers every year?". OH well. Yes I will get the comeback "You know how many are killed by drunk drivers every year?"..No, I don't know, but that woman should have got prison time. This isn't a rant, but damn, put all bad drivers in prison, drunk or not.
Additional Details
Yes same lame resonses on here, I said should someone that CAUSES a crash be treated the same as one who MAY cause one. Yes accident, no fooling, but bad driving, I say put her in prison.


    




mnwomen
The difference is that in the woman's case it was an accident. She did not set out to harm anyone.
In the dui case your friend made a decision to drive and put others at risk. Luckily they caught him before it happened.


Don't Make Me Come In There!
Anyone who runs a stop light is obviously 'impaired'. If you're a crappy driver, yet continue to drive, is there not intent behind that as well? Don't get me started on DUI laws...and I don't even drink.


bcnu
If you have a problem with how the criminal element was handled, speak to the district attorney about the message this is sending.

You can also (in many states) file an administrative complaint against any licensed driver, pointing out their bad driving and requesting the registrar of licensing hold a hearing to determine if her license to drive on public streets should be revoked before she kills somebody.

Finally, you can call the local investigative TV news team and offer them an interview with an enraged citizen who isn't going to take this lying down.


Strudel
That woman made a mistake. A big mistake, but a mistake. People do it all the time. She didn't mean to hurt people. But a person that gets into a car after they have been drinking is making a decision. They are asking for someone to get hurt. Everyone knows that an impaired driver cannot react as fast as a driver that is sober. All people that drink and drive should be put away! Shame on your friend! I hope he's not driving on my roads!


Big Tom
Rating
I agree especially if they are doing something like talking or texting to cause the crash. That is the same reasoning behind who DUI is punished so hard because the person knowingly drank and drove and that is what caused the accident.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 In what states can you become a legal guardian at age 18?
...


 Is it possible for an employee to get fired while out of work due to illness?
I wanted to know if anyone out there knows about employment and what to do if a person was employed with a private own company for about a year but recently was out of work due to a health condition ...


 Why does Chicago hate their law abiding citizens?
With the city's gun ban certain to be overturned, Mayor Richard Daley on Thursday introduced what city officials say is the strictest handgun ordinance in the United States.

The ...


 Legally, is a broken leg considered a serious bodily injury? (Indiana)?
DUI accidnet in which sober individual who was hit suffers a broken leg which wil heel fine, assume scrapes and bruises as well. Is it possible that the person could be initiially charged with DUI ...


 cars and guns can both kill people... so why are classes and permits unreasonable for the latter?
...


 Elian Gonzalez was happy to be sent back home. Should we should help all illegals and do the same for them?
We barge into their house with automatic weapons and drag them to a van and speed away. Once they're back home, everyone will be happy.

http://content.usatoday....


 How does a state supreme court decide which cases will be heard with oral arguments and which will not?
In particular, Maine? I have a case pending with the supreme court and they sent me a letter via my attorney that they will hear the case without oral arguments the next time they are in session....


 Is he legally charging me or is he swindling money from me?
Ok so today some guy from whirlpool came to do a diagnostic on my fridge and is charging us $124. He didn't fix anything, he just told us to move our food products from the cooling vent and ...


 Do I need to get a student work permit to work at the age of 16, in the state of Texas?
I'm planning to work in Target around the time I turn 16 this August, and I was wondering what I need to get the job . Referring to paper work or documents?...


 What do you think of the new text law that went into effect in michigan today?
No texting while driving a simple solution to many accidents! What do you think of these baby laws we have to come up with as america becomes dumbed down by uneducated society? I'm all for it, ...


 my friend was beaten tazered and pepper sprayed then injected with a truth drug is this right?
My freind who is a deaf mute with downs syndrome was taping the charts of the radio and selling the music at carboot sales , he was pulled by some undercover police officers who beat tazered and ...


 why do american flags in the courtroom have a gold lining?
...


 If kids get charged as adults for federal crimes are they seperated from adult inmates?
...


 Is PayPal allowed to do this?
They want me to provide proof of delivery on an item they know I sent via Regular Post. I have 72 positive feedbacks on my profile, and they're siding with the buyer, who chose Regular Post ...


 I need some legal advice on an injury of a pet.?
An accident occurred in my home last night. A person with a mental handicap stepped on a kitten's head and inured it badly. My husband and I don't have the income to pay for surgery or ...


 When a law is amended can a prior guilty verdict be overturned?
...


 If you post bond to get out of jail do you get that money back when you go to court?
...


 Can DCF give you a drug urine test in your home?

Additional Details
lol ...


 Can someone tell me why did the guy who rape me recently hire a private i to find me after I have moved?
Ok, the guy who rape me is deny that I have a son by him because of the rape. He knows that I gave our son away to one of my relative in the south, so can you please tell me why he has recently hired ...


 engagment ring drama?
My ex fiance bought me a ring for engagment, he broke up with me, and asked for ring back....I didnt give it back to him.

So my ex fiance decided to break up with me in the middle of my ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.004