Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law & Ethics

Should abortion be illigal? why?
Find answers to your legal question.





Should abortion be illigal? why?



    




Korky
Rating
Are we not over run with unwanted one parent children
prevention is better than cure
but do the parents use protective measures in the class rooms these days I THINK NOT
not that most of them can read the leaflets anyway


Papa Lazarou
Rating
No Dave, what about rape victims?

Women should be able to choose.


Joseph, II
Rating
No. A woman should have the RIGHT to do whatever SHE chooses with HER body. The Govenment has NO BUSINESS micro-managing people's lives...


just me
NO.... The government has no right to tell me what I can and cannot do with MY BODY!!!! Plain and simple... Even though I personally don't believe in abortion, I think it should be legal so that the industry can be monitored. I also think that if it were illegal, women would still find a way.

Take for example a rape victim. They are give emergency contraception. SO what's the difference between that and an abortion. ABSOLUTELY NOTHING......


prettygal32002
Rating
of course it shouldn't ppl get pregnant by mistake even wen they have used protection or on the pill.ect..
many ppl do it for there own reasons and personal reasons...
so no....


ribena
Rating
no ...one example being if a woman has been raped and falls pregnant she should have the right to choose to terminate the pregnancy ......or not ....


Acyla
Rating
No. It should be a woman's choice to have an abortion. Not many women would want to have a child that is the product of rape, incest or will be born with a deformity that can hamper the child's entire life or cause it extreme pain and ensure that it needs constant care of doctors. There are some cultures where if a woman has a child outside marriage she can be stoned to death, what do these women do if they have been raped by their brother in law?

Besides if you make it illegal women can just travel to places where it is legal (especially if they live in Europe or travel to a different state if they're in the USA) or, even cheaper, get a baseball bat. The truth is if a woman doesn't want to have a child or her child after it's born she can find a way, she can also (sadly enough) dump her kid on the doorsteps of a church and abandon it.


alan m
Recent studies (March 3rd 2007 Womens departure group )on this concluded that illegal abortions means shoddy backstreet abortions. They concluded the woman should decide unless it is very late on in the pregnancy. So perhaps the answer is No but yes if late on in the pregnancy. So its yes sometimes and no sometimes.


Lawyer
no because everyone has the right to choose
If I am pregnant for example and my doctor tells me that my baby has a brain damage,Down syndrome etc etc I WILL CHOOSE to terminate the pregnancy


zo29
Rating
It depends on personal situations, personally I couldn't do it. Only time I personally think it is acceptable is if someone was raped or if there is somthing really terribly wrong with mother or baby. I know someone who had an abortion and the baby was with her long term boyfriend, cos (timing wasn't right) but then a few months later started trying for a baby and had one! Think that was soooo wrong!!!


coragryph
No, it should not be illegal.

Let's set aside the issue of whether you think abortion is a good idea or not, or how often (if ever) it should happen.

Abortion should not be illegal because the concept of reproductive choice NOT being a fundamental personal right is equally bad to pro-life and pro-choice folks.

The thing about the abortion debate is that the two sides are arguing entirely unrelated issues. Pro-life people say "abortion is bad". Pro-choice advocates say "The government not should be making personal decisions that like". It's NOT about abortion. It's about WHO gets to make the DECISION.

Face it -- someone is going to choose. It's either going to be the individual, or it's going to be the majority (through enacted laws). If the majority gets to choose, then they are effectively imposing their belief system -- which is almost always religiously-based -- on everyone. If the individual gets to choose, then it allows for those people who happen to believe that a 6-week old collection of cells is not yet a person, as well as those who believe it is.

But if the Supreme Court decides that reproductive rights are not fundamental rights, if women lose the individual right to choose, and the government makes all the decisions. Try to imagine what could happen, if all reproductive rights are now subject to state control.

New York or Florida could pass a law saying that anyone making less than $30K per year cannot have children, and must abort any pregnancy, because they obviously cannot support them financially. No constitutional challenge, because reproductive rights are no longer nationally protected.

Or North Carolina or Texas decides that convicted felons should never have children, and starts imposing mandatory sterilization as part of criminal sentences. No constitutional challenge, because reproductive rights are no longer protected.

South Dakota has already outlawed abortion, even in the case of rape or incest or permanent harm to the mother. Then, they decide that they have too little population, and require every female under the age of 28 who is not celibate to have at least one child. Or mandating that women serve as surrogates. No constitutional challenge, because reproductive rights are no longer nationally protected.

Once the right to reproductive privacy is taken away by the court, it will be decades before it can be reestablished. Conservatives better start praying, if they get their wish, that during that time they don't become the minority under a legislation that decides to require abortions. Because, once that right to personal choice is lost, the government will always be able to decide whether you can have children or not.

That's why the issue is not about abortion. It's about who gets to make the choice.


WPB_LV_AV
It's not abortion that should be legal - IT'S THE RIGHT TO CHOOSE!!!


caldude1010101
Rating
No. Our founding fathers never intended on the government making decisions for the people in regards to their own bodies.

Seatbelt and helmet laws should be struck down as unConstitutonal, as well.


Victor E
It should be a matter of individual choice


DIVA2000
Rating
Who knows, because it is a woman's freedom of choice what she want to do with her unborn child. But I feel abortion is taking a child's life before he / she is born. It is wrong to commit a murder.


john m
Rating
Sure no problem, Back street abortionists need the money. I am old enough to remember them, With disgust not at them but at the system that made them the only option for desperate women.


?
Rating
No it should not.


Often Intimidated Always a Dope
Well obviously your going to get different opinions based on one's individual beliefs. Speaking as a Pro-Lifer, I believe that it should be illegal. However I don't believe that it should be done overnight. There are a lot of things to be taken into consideration, For example what is going to happen with all the unwanted babies, there needs to be programs in place ahead of time. All in all it should be illegal but it needs to be thought out and not done hastily


Surfin Tony
Yes. It's just simply killing a human life. And woman use it as a form of birth control.


katy
Rating
no, folk that cant spell illegal should be


rtartt2002
It should most defiantly be illegal!!! I mean look at it, your killing an innocent child thats isn't even born in the world! Thats just plain cold murder!


bay
Rating
only the living can ask this question...It would have been nice if the aborted was not aborted an was here to answer this question... we will not know will we... because there are so many answers.. an ounce of prevention is worth it should be illegal to get pregnant for any one that does not want a baby but made one any way... it is very nice that you are alive to ask this question... it's out and out murder no one has the right to take anothers life especially those that can not speak for themselves..if you know you don't want any children stop being lazy and do what it takes to not get pregnant.. there are many people that even after being raped keep the baby and adopt the baby out... some even raise the baby.. this takes a person with great compassion for the innocent one the baby... I have a friend that is a rape baby and she will never know her dad... her mother raised her she is now a doctor and have a son and 3 daughters.. this is a very beautiful woman out side as well as in side and her mom.. they don't make them like her anymore...it is not a matter of choice.... it is a matter of what is the right thing. most human just will not do what is right...doing what is right has always been hard for us human.. we are most of us are a sad lot.....thank GOD some of us do have a reasoning conscious like my friends mother.... this is why Jesus died for us saying "forgive them father for they know not what they do" ....we don't





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Is this illegal?
If I was good at bowling, and I bowled all gutter balls on purpose.

Next, I'll challenge somebody to a game and bet $100 that I'll win and they accept the challenge because they ...


 Obeying the rules....?
Why do people frequently disobey rules and then kick up a fuss when they get caught?...


 Do you support a ban on smoking in public places?
...


 Should guns be banned (or severly controlled) in the USA after the latest school shooting?
I know it's in the constitution but surely after what's happened they should amend it? After the Dunblane (Scotland)shootings all handguns were taken from licenced owners (the owners were ...


 Do you agree witht he new legislation to let gays be openly gay in the military.?
Bush has basicly failed us again and bowed over to the democratic congress regarding this new legislation that is basicly a gay right bill, and now because of the "Don't ask don't tell&...


 I was convicted of a felony and served 14 months in prison. I have trouble finding work. what can I do?
I am now doing 3 years on probation. I will complete my first year on January 24, 2009. How can I make myself more attractive to potential employers?...


 Rules for keeping a job for a long time?
What do you recommend to do in a job, in order to not get laid off and increase the chances of staying a few years (US)?...


 Now smoking is practically banned what's next for the Politically Correct Police?
...


 If someone leaves something at your apartment and doesn't ever come to get it does it become yours? ?
The item in question is a computer and the person once lived here and hasn't for about a year now and their name is no longer on the apartment ...


 Is capital punishment the same as murder?
I say yes.

They are both the premeditated taking of another's life....


 Fired from work what to do?
Im 15 I have worked at a local McDonalds for about 9 months and i just called today to see if i was supposed to work and i found out i was fired, But they had me illegaly working on grill and fried ...


 Is this considered to be racist? If you pick a doctor based on his name alone?
For example your insurance company gives you a list of doctors you can go to, and thats all you know is their name and phone number.

Are you a racist if you pick Dr. John Davis over Dr. J...


 How do you feel about the "no smoking " in public place's law?
...


 Should cannabis be legalized?
could you give a good answer not just yes or no please! Thank you....


 MY MOM CARRYS A GUN.knowing this would you try to rob,carjack,or rape her?
my mother carrys a 6 shot pistol which shoots .454 casull,if you know about guns,you get it.if not,be afraid!...


 What could happen if someone in my school wore a t-shirt that says Investigate 911?
Im not talkinga bout getting beat up because ive asked around the school and most of them belive that 9/11 was set up. Im talking about legally. Like is there any slander in there anyway? Could the ...


 Do you believe the Death Penalty is just?
Many people believe its against the right of a citizen because of 'cruel and unusual panishment law.' What do you think?...


 Can i legally kill my neighbors dog for trespassing on my property and attacking my cats?
...


 Should you be allowed to take a gun into a polling place?
http://www.publicopinion There's the story. The court sided with Rotz today and he was given his permit back....


 If you were in a pub or restaurant, and you spotted rodent, who would you tell first?
The health inspector or the news paper?...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.034