Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law & Ethics

Should guns be banned (or severly controlled) in the USA after the latest school shooting?
Find answers to your legal question.





Should guns be banned (or severly controlled) in the USA after the latest school shooting?

I know it's in the constitution but surely after what's happened they should amend it? After the Dunblane (Scotland)shootings all handguns were taken from licenced owners (the owners were compensated for this). Would this help if the same was done in America?


    




Archangel Gabriel
Rating
I don't care about your poxy constitution. If I visit the USA, I expect to retain my right not to be shot at or otherwise violated by gun carrying crazed individuals. Dump Charlton Heston and the NRA and start educating your children to live without fear and without weapons.


rz1971
Probably not, the ones who want guns will still have them. It would not reduce anything from what I can see. What we really need to focus on is our society.


Red
No we need guns to protect our selves and our stuff.


idiotsreside
Blaming these shootings on guns just detracts from the responsibility of the criminal for the crime he committed and makes about as much sense as blaming pencils for misspellings, cars for drunk drivers and spoons for Rosie O'Donnell's obscene obeisity


judge_and_jury_72
Rating
what would be the point? You would just do what happened here and take away the rights of the many to enjoy a perfectly safe sport. Here in Briatain guns are pretty much banned but plenty of people are still getting shot. It doesn't solve the problem at all. All it does is stop law abiding people from doing something they enjoy doing. Why would someone intent on killing someone give a stuff about a law that says they can't? Prohibition fails. Always has, always will. these occurences are tragic but they won't be prevented by banning guns.


Nickynackynoo
It should have happened after the FIRST shooting like this. In the UK things changed after Dunblane, too late for my mother though who was killed with a gun in 1988.

Gun crime is rising again in the UK, if people want guns they can get them, even if guns were banned in the US, people would still be able to get them. Drugs are illegal but look how many people are using!!!

there must be more control though, how many times are we going to see this type of thing on the news?


msmissy
Rating
If just one person in Norris Hall had been armed and used his licensed weapon to take out the shooter- how many people would have been saved.
You can't blame murder on the weapon- if he had driven his car into a packed cafeteria would we be screaming for tighter regulations regarding the licensing of drivers or the purchasing of cars?
It appears that what would have stopped this shooter was for him to have been denied entry into this country in the first place.

Edit: Amen to Feed me


Boomrat
No, we like our guns, we like to hunt. Just cause some nut case took two and went to school doesn't mean we need to change the books. There are already enough laws on the books. If no guns are around, the next nut case will use gas, or some other means to kills. The Media is a big problem... If they would stop talking about it and stop sticking the camera in peoples faces, people would so called issuses would find something else to do.


maka
Rating
Of course it wont help, IT DIDNT HELP IN THE UK gun crime is worse than ever.
If that guy hadby got hold of a gun, he could have used a sword, a knife,a bomb, a car or anything else. The guy was the one who decided to go and kill a lot of people, the gun didnt talk him into it


Carpe diem
Banned or not, yesterdays shooter and anyone else with a buck could still get them...


thequeenreigns
Rating
Never happen!!! The NRA will protest and say their usual mantra- " Guns don't kill people, people kill people"
People will scream from the rooftops about their 2nd amendment rights are being violated, even though I can't see what the big deal is about waiting a few days to buy a gun to make sure the people is NOT an ex-con with no right to purchase a gun or to make sure the purchaser isn't a non citizen such as a non immigrant or a nutjob who can turn around and kill senselessly with the newly purchased weapon but then that's just me. The regulation isn't denying them the gun, it's just making sure they have the RIGHT to buy it. It is not seen that way.


Patrick M
Rating
No, Criminals will find other ways to murder. Why not ban kitchen knives or severly control them after all the stabbings we have in this country.


leroykbrown
Guns should've been banned many years ago.


Lancaid
Rating
Yes, and after the guns were taken, the violent crime rate went way up. Just like it did with Austrailia, just like it did with Canada. Should guns be banned? That school was all about gun control. It was a "Gun Free Zone". Didn't freakin work did it! You think you make people safe by taking away their self defense?!! You are a tard.


Hibee
Rating
Brilliant, SKIP G. You cannot change the Constitution. Especially the Second Amendment.


tacosarethebest
What would the point be? People would still get them if the really wanted them. But think of this...even if there was a way to enforce a no-gun policy, don't you think people would get creative? They would use knives, clubs, rocks, chemicals, whatever they could get their hands on to accomplish their task.


Butterbar Bob
Rating
And have gun crimes rise like they did in England? No thanks - I don't want to live in fear of armed criminals.

A citizen is responsible for his own immediate defense of himself, his family and his property. A citizen is always the first line of defense of society.

A subject isn't allowed that responsibility.


missfattyfudgecake
GUNS SHOULD BE BANNED!!! I FIND IT HARD TO BELEIVE THAT A COUNTRY AS FORWARD AS THE US HAS SUCH A BACKWARDS APPROACH TO SOMETHING AS SERIOUS AS THIS. GUNS SHOULD NOT PLAY ANY PART IN A CIVILIZED WAY OF LIFE.WE CAN ALL GET ALONG JUST FINE WITHOUT THEM. I LIVE IN THE UK BY THE WAY.


chocolahoma
Rating
A responsible, Licensed "conceal-and-carry" permit holder could have saved dozens of those lives.

Texas pioneered laws allowing citizens to take classes and earn the right to carry concealed weapons. This was done in response to a mass shooting in a Luby's restaurant. When the bad guys don't know which of their potential victims is going to vigorously defend him/herself, they tend to think twice about their plans.


Skip G
no, more guns less crime, you cannot change the constitution and the great part is I still have my assault rifle


William D
as long as the N.R.A have a powerful lobby, gun control laws will not vary much in the USA the right to bare arms is in the constitution which is nearly 300 years old what is neaded is for the American people to vote on a change to the constitution which in its time was there to offer the american people a means to protect themselves from invaders from other countries they did not expect people to use this right to shoot each other.


Dado21
Of course any sane society would ban handguns and semi-automatics but we are not talking about a sane society, we are talking about the most paranoid society on earth and if they want to bear arms and waste each other then that of course they should be allowed to do that.


lex C
Rating
Another example of how absolutely fkd up the USA is. This is a country where it is 'normal' to bear arms, a country where the
c unt of a president feels so mutha fkin sorry that this keeps happening but at the same time is a big part of americas gun culture. Im sorry, i have complete sympathy for the victtims and their familes but the USA as a country is not the best country in the world as american slike to think, in fact nowhere near. kiss these nuts man.


nora22000
I agree with you--all handguns should be banned since they are not the 'firearms' mentioned in the Constitution.

I remember when Kennedy was shot--I thought guns would be banned then. When the carnage of the sixties was over, and even Bobby Kennedy was dead, I was incredulous at the national support for individual violence; this country has not progressed since the 'wild west' days.

However, one can only hope. If this shooting results in any real restrictions, at least those people will not have died in vain.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 MY MOM CARRYS A GUN.knowing this would you try to rob,carjack,or rape her?
my mother carrys a 6 shot pistol which shoots .454 casull,if you know about guns,you get it.if not,be afraid!...


 What could happen if someone in my school wore a t-shirt that says Investigate 911?
Im not talkinga bout getting beat up because ive asked around the school and most of them belive that 9/11 was set up. Im talking about legally. Like is there any slander in there anyway? Could the ...


 Do you believe the Death Penalty is just?
Many people believe its against the right of a citizen because of 'cruel and unusual panishment law.' What do you think?...


 Can i legally kill my neighbors dog for trespassing on my property and attacking my cats?
...


 Should you be allowed to take a gun into a polling place?
http://www.publicopinion There's the story. The court sided with Rotz today and he was given his permit back....


 If you were in a pub or restaurant, and you spotted rodent, who would you tell first?
The health inspector or the news paper?...


 Question for American people only !!?
am just wondering do you have in america any kind of offical papers indicate your religon ??!
like the pessport , the birth cirtificate , the school papers , the marrege cirtificate , anything ...


 Was George Bush responsible for the 911 attack on American soil?
I saw the video Loose Change and it rose many questions about the attacks....


 I am a nanny. If the family adds chores that are not in the signed contract, can I ask for additional money?
The chores are child related. I do have time to do them. I do not mind doing them. I'm just wondering since they are not in the signed contract that details the chores we originally agreed to- ...


 Was Saddams punishment a little TOO harsh?
I mean, just killing him won't do much to him. And plus, it wasn't ALLL his evil-doing


dont get me wrong, i hate him just as much as the next guy, im just wondering if ...


 Is this legal?
I want to put a classified ad in the paper to locate a deadbeat dad wanted for criminal charges. Is this legal or not?
Additional Details
his criminal charges are for not paying child ...


 What are you legally allowed to do at the age of 16?
i know there's driving, but anything unusual you know of?...


 Are people entitled to an opinion on a subject they KNOW absolutely NOTHING about?
Expecting a can of worms to open here..............and this question is not aimed at anyone or any subject in particular, open question....


 Why are Democrats so intent on taking away our rights?
OK, Liberals always accuse Conservatives of telling others how to live their lives, but I find it tends to go the other way:

http://news.yahoo.com/s/...


 A girl I know got caught shoplifting...?
On Thursday a girl at my school got caught shoplifting $150 worth of makeup. She wants to be a surgeon when she's older but do you think this will affect it? Personally I don't sympathize ...


 I know a 13 year old addicted to cannabis, any advice?

Additional Details
I know you can not get addicted, but you know what I ...


 What happends if i take off?
what happens if i just up and decide to move across country to start a new life for me (i need it) while on probation or criminal charges (m2, m3, m3) pending? no ...


 Which amendment allows us to bare arms?
...


 Should parents of obese children get prosecuted for child cruelty?
I have just watched BBC news where 2 dog owners have been found guilty for letting their dog get too fat. I think there are plenty of parents of huge children who would be more deserving of their day ...


 Should channel four Dianas dying pictures?

Additional Details
re DILB............men you a one mean ****....show some compassion bruv.........




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.024