Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law & Ethics

Should holocaust denial be a crime?
Find answers to your legal question.





Should holocaust denial be a crime?

Don't get me wrong, here, I am a good Marxist and rabid anti-fascist and I have spent many a jolly Saturday afternoon scrapping with the NF and the BNP. But why should some judge determine whether or not I can read holocaust denial? I am old enough to form my own judgment on things. Or are we saying that some people are not safe to be left alone with books? The thing about the Nazis is they used to jail people for ideas.
Additional Details
Well, we seem to have agreed on that. Guess the Israelis aren't up yet!!


    




IAMWonder
I hold the freedom to read the books I want to and to believe what I want to. I also respect other people enough to live and let live and read their books and believe their way as well.
I also know that my values, beliefs, and judgements have changed over the years to reflect what my experiences have taught me - about myself and the world around me. And that has been to seek and create greater harmony.


dumdum
Rating
No because being charged with "thought crimes" is wrong--no matter how offensive, dumb, or crazy a thought may be.


Jade D
No, it shouldn't be a crime. It's a really stupid thing to do, but not a crime. If we jailed people because their thoughts/beliefs were different than ours, we'd be no better than them. People are free to have their opinions, no matter how stupid they are.


Alice
Though blatantly incorrect and ignorous, it should not be a crime. Everyone has a right to their own oppinion. If it were illegal, it would be a form of dictatorship. The first ammendment to the American constitution mandates this right.


afreshpath_admin
Rating
The denial of any historical event should not be a crime. If I want, I should be able to deny that the global temperature is on the rise...it would be kind of stupid but not against the law.


woooahdfa
nah, because 99 percent of people knowit to be fact, that measely 1 percent dont mean squat


jrex
no because people are entitled to their own opinions.


shorty b
NO


mick t
'The thing about the Nazis is they used to jail people for ideas'

So do the communists, They are both totalitarian doctrines and have more in common than separates them. The main difference being that the Nazis were more honest about their racism.


CLIVE H
Holocaust Denial is a criminal offence across the European Union, not merely here in UK.

Beware of the Thought Police.

The English Puritans had a saying which went something like this. . . ."The thought is as the deed. . . ." So, if you or any of us dare to read or think something which is not approved of by the "Puritans" (UK.gov) then be ready for the consequences of your own vile actions. . . .

It's a crime to think anything which has not been approved first by Big Brother.

The UK.gov is lead by a mind control freeek. Otherwise known as Big Bros. . . .

Now for something completely difference : -

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CyI349eKhbg

. . . .or how the BNP brought the people St.George's Day.


vdv_desantnik
Rating
no, people are entitled to their own thoughts and ideas. Classifying this as a crime is as bad as the nazis and their ideas


professional student
Rating
Holocaust denial should not be a crime. But those who deny the holocaust should be prepared to deal with the evidence when confronted with it.

It is a simple matter of freedom of thought, and freedom of speech.


healing wings
Rating
Hey, if you want to let crazy people play with your mind...be my guest.


teddy
No, because that would make those misguided people mean something and they don't, i would say that let them have their say, after all there is enough evidence out there for us to know the Holocaust did happen and death camps where people visit to know that this terrible time in history was a fact.


Its OK im the Limo Driver
a denial is a personal opinion

so NO...

as it kills debate along with it


J W
Rating
No, I find it distasteful material. However, banning books is not the solution.


g_man
Rating
There is a big difference between having an idea, and being an @sshole!


;-P
um im sorry but that was dealt with oh idk...... sum time ago!!!
read a book called
Hitler Youth and
Annne Frank in the World (not the diary though)
i think you will get the point but the Hitler Youth explains more about how the kids wee influenced and treated and Anne frank one says more of wat was happening and in the end says how they were "de-nazified"


Tyler Mac XD
Only if organized religion becomes a crime too.


Vandeervecken
Rating
No. Freedom of speech includes the freedom to speak stupidly.


Sssh! its a secret. :)
Rating
In reality, no. In theory I wish! Look, by Evelyn Beatrice Hall said, "I disapprove of what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it"

That is a right I believe everyone should have. There are so many idiots out there saying crap, but they have a right to say it. It's up to the rest of us to be mindful of what they say.


Dan
Rating
No, stupidity cannot be made illegal. There are not enough jails for this to happen.


RayN-here
Rating
No you can say and be most anything you want i e; YOU ''Marxist'' why do you like to be on the losing side?


Liberals make me laugh
Rating
In the US you can deny anything from the moon landing, to the holocaust, to France never surrendering in battle.

You'll look silly and people will laugh at you, but you can do it.


tom_p1980
Rating
No it shouldn't. I have argues this for years and it generally falls on deaf ears, however freedom to discuss a past historical episode shoud not be a crime. Makes you wonder why they made it illegal in the first place?

I do not deny the Holocaust however theres more questions than answers regarding it, and add on the fact it is illegal to deny it (wtf, thought crime!) somethings just don't add up or are not as black and white as they are made out to be.

Remember "He who wins the war, writes the history".





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 If muslim women can wear a veil, surely i can wear a balaclava when shopping?
...


 Please i really need some help?
there is this girl that was trying to break me and my bf up by
saying whole bunch of stuff to people. well we decided to tell her to stop. (me and my bf) we did NOT threaten her OR cuss her ...


 I'm so sick of hearing of cyberbullying and then posting online! What do you think should be done to deter it?

Additional Details
I'm referring to videoing a confrontation and then posting-just happened in my town. Also the consequences of someone killing themselves due to online abuse....


 What is the point of punishment?
Be serious in your answer. Please explain in full sentence....


 Should The Death Penalty Be In The UK?
Should the death penalty be set up in the UK?

Personally, i would say no because the person who has committed the crime, murder more often than not, will have to deal with his conscience ...


 Is it legal to burn the U.S. flag?
...


 Should we abolish Hospital parking charges?
Do you think there are any positive reasons for charging people to park their vehicles within a hospital car park?

If you believe we should pay parking charges, do you think they should be ...


 Should prisoners be able to get out during the day to do work or training?
I am being sentenced next month for GBH. I am an apprentice electrician and doing the NVQ. If I was able to continue the apprentiship would it not be better than having to give it up because of ...


 If I were to wear an American flag as a cape, would I get in trouble?
It would be short enough so that it wouldn't touch the ground and I wouldn't be burning it or anything. The law does say that putting the flag on any article of clothing, etc. is illegal, ...


 Can a woman legally be found guilty of raping a man?
...


 Is it legal for my boss to take £20 out of my wages to cover the cost of a training course i didnt sign up for
...


 Are you against it or Not?
Against Or Not???

1.Gay Marriage?
2.Smoking?
3.Racisim?
4.George Bush?
5.Products etc. Being tested on animals?
6.Drinking? (Constantly)

*Give me your ...


 Which would you rather have....?
Christian based monogamy, and it is christian based despite the Mormans, or poligamy based on secularism or Islam?
Additional Details
I Timothy 3:2...


 When someone breaks in to your house,?
Do you have the right to shoot them? Didn't they set the value of their life at the value of your tv or whatever else they were looking to steal, or do you just run out and hide and call the ...


 Is it illegal to record someones voice?
i was scammed but i recorded her voice.is it illegal to record voice? if so whats the penalty for it?or can i submit the recorded voice to the court ?would it be admisseble to the court?...


 Can he stop me parking outside his restaurant?
I have a pest control van with a big sign on it
REDUCING RATS IN RESTAURANTS the manager gets upset at me parking outside his restaurant but surely I can park wherever I want as long as it is ...


 How do I sue a person who owes me money?
...


 How much could I sue Burger King for finding a condom in one of their Whoppers?
And what's the best way to sneak one in without the staff seeing?

And before you all start SHOUTING at me, which I know you will, can I point out that I happen to be a single mother ...


 What are my "smokers rights" when my workplace bans smoking and will not, in the future, hire smokers?
...


 What is the wage differince between peaple who graduate then peaple who don't?
the differince in money you make when you graduate then when you don'...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.054