Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law & Ethics

Should waterboarding-which isn't torture after all-be used to get info from criminals to keep us safe?
Find answers to your legal question.





Should waterboarding-which isn't torture after all-be used to get info from criminals to keep us safe?


Additional Details
Mutt-- Would it still be "unusual" if it was done all the time? "Cruel" is a matter of opinion isn't it?


    




Sfancik
Rating
If waterboarding isn't torture then you are absolutely right. We could use this enhanced technique in lot's of situations. On kids in school who won't "tattle" on bullies/cheaters etc. On employees to find out if they are stealing or just being lazy. We could even use it on people who get traffic tickets in traffic court....you know, find out if they really DID have an emergency or were they just speeding cause they like to go fast.

Oh...and use it on the cops too. Sometimes cops aren't 100% truthful I bet and we could waterboard them and find out if they really crashed their car cause they were pursuing a call....or was it really because they didn't want to wait for the light!

If it's just akin to a "college prank" then I don't see why we can't make it as useful as possible. It makes me laugh as well at the sissy terrorists who give up information just cause someone is playing a prank on them!

Good question! I probably wouldn't have considered all these possibilities if I hadn't seen it. I may waterboard my wife tonight....you know, "Was that rug REALLY on sale????"


jake
Rating
Candy and ice cream.
Works every time.

Worked with my two year old.


Adam B
Water torture is torture.

Torture is illegal, and cannot be used on anyone.

Torturing people doesn't keep us safe, and even if it did it's barbaric. We don't resort to barbarism out of fear.


Mutt
Rating
Whether or not it is torture will be debated between people for some time. But, no matter if it is or not torture, it would still be considered "cruel and unusual punishment". In the U.S., we have a little thing called the Bill of Rights that this would violate. Get the 8th Amendment repealed, and you may stand of chance of having more support for this.


wizjp
Rating
If you can find a situation where a criminal can provide information that will keep us safe, feel free.


MrNiceGuy
No
Cause it is torture.
Torture is an ineffective means of gathering information
And it's barbaric and evil.

That about covers it.


Shovel Ready
Let's restrict it to illegal combatants who are highly likely to have information about plans for future attacks.


Mr. X
Rating
It is considered as torture in every civilized country.


Handey Randy
Rating
Waterboarding is seen as torture by every civilized country in the world. (except your little world.)


panurge2
Rating
Can I water board your dog?


20090120!
Good question! Lets water board child abusers and rapists and murderers. After all this "brings results" and we Americans take our queues from tv series like 24 , as oppose to laws and moral standards! Results justify the means. Lets think in terms of "Criminal intent" now!


Pollywog!
Rating
Absolutely! Waterboarding is actually quite harmless. It's just another form of propaganda to diminish the reputation of the Bush administration. Dunking someone's head in the water causes almost no physical harm and if you can perform this and get information to save millions of American lives it's worth it. Unfortunately, we have liberals to deal with in this country. If given the choice between saving a million innocent citizen lives and going against their code of strict morals to waterboard a terrorist they would choose killing the citizens everytime. It's a screwed up view on life that they have. Maybe we'll survive with them in power but I imagine the next attack isn't far away.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Do you think politicians should submit to a polygraph test periodical?
like some employs have to do in the privet sector in order to maintain their jobs or positions?
Additional Details
i knew some smarty pants would spot the misspelling and commit on that ...


 What if someone abuses a civil protection order to get the other jailed?
What happens if a woman places a CPO order against a guy then chases him down to insure that he has violated the order and places him in jail? He is unable to get a restraining order against her ...


 Can some1 tell me what if a Personal Protection Order is not serve on the other person what happens after that?
Does it just expires?
Additional Details
Good answer Ditka because I know that a PPO is only good for one year and you only have one year to serve it upon a person....


 What would the punishment be for physically assaulting someone without causing any critical injuries?
...


 What to do when a "handyman" threatens with a mechanic's lien?
Reasking this question because I just found out that the guy I hired is a handyman, not a licenced contractor.

I hired a handyman to fix up my house. We agreed on a list of items to fix ...


 Hold old do you have to be to get a Drivers License in Washington Sate?
...


 If i got my first ticket today and have to apper in court could i lose my license or go to traffic school?
I was in a small bumper collision where the other car knocked my bumper off..but i was charged with a ticket & have to appear in court..Will i lose my license or have 2 go 2 traffic school?
...


 How many legal secretaries would one expect for a 3 partner, 3 associate firm?
...


 Made a gym contract over the phone but they changed it before I got my membership card?
So I went to LA fitness and haggled a deal where I would pay 3 years upfront at $20 a month and then after that I would pay $195 per year for my lifetime. After I signed, my friend told me about 24 ...


 Can a worker at a store in the mall legally take your purse and go through it if she THINKS?
You stole something.

if she didn't see with her own eyes, but thought you were could she take it and go though it.

And can she detain you until a cop comes?...


 What would you consider would be an incident of "ethical misconduct" if you were an Executive Assistant?
I am also looking for news and/or articles that list or tell of events dealing with ethical misconduct and Executive Assistants/ Administrative Assistants?

(I have reviewed The I...


 If I call 911 after an emergency?
How do I know I am calling my local 911 office? Afterall, I live in CA but people nationwide call 911 for help, does it go my area code? What if I am in New Jersey on a business trip and call 911 on ...


 Who here wants marijuana to be legalized?
...


 If marijuana were to be legalized what jobs would it create?
...


 Is nuclear testing actually allowed?
Like. Is it considered internationally unlawful? Or do people still do it to this very day, without the consulting of government? Or could it be done in secrecy?

I need to know for my ...


 I need Texas Legal Help!?
O.K. this is a little long so bear with me. About 6 weeks ago the sewage from another unit flooded into the townhouse that I am renting. Since this has occurred the landlord has made ME cut the ...


 Please explain Judicial activism and Judicial restraint?
in the simplist terms possible. Please use Roe V wade or bowers v hardwick to describe what Justices are using to form their opinions.
Thank u!...


 Ever think forensic/law shows actually encourage criminal behavior?
I mean think about it. CSI, Law and Order, Cold Case...these shows not only tell you what the cops are looking for, they tell you how to beat technology most local law enforcement agencies don't ...


 Is it legal to ship a knife from the US to the UK ?
I want to buy a knife over the internet from a US seller but i don't know if is legal or not and don't really want to risk it.

this is the knife :
http://www.teraasekeskus...


 IN US...if you are homeless and no job,, and have filled out the form for financial assessment...how PUSHY is.?
the p.o. usually about finding a job?

have met with one and she gave me a "financial assesment" form to fill out and bring in next week.

she told me that unless you ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.024