Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law & Ethics

Should women be identified.?
Find answers to your legal question.





Should women be identified.?

There was a case the other day of a woman who cvlaimed she was raped. after the guy did three years inside it turns out that she lied . It also turns out she has claimed this six times. Yet her ID is kept secret. Should she not be named as the poor blokes life has been ruined.


    




kel
Rating
Should go further she should be identified. She should be put on trial for perjury, wasting police time, perverting the course of justice.


FIONA S
Rating
yes if we want equality we should be named. at least the jury should have known about her history.


kitty-mama
Rating
Yes, she should be identified by name, location and a recent photo. She is NOT a victim, her identity needing to be kept secret. She is a CRIMINAL for destroying the lives of men innocent of the crime she accused them of. Her face should be all over the news just like any criminal. Not only has this sicko ruined the lives of these men and their families, but she made it that much harder for a TRUE victim to come forward for fear of not being believed.


Diane
Yes she should


Steven S
I do think she should be identified! She shouldn't be allowed to do this!


Mike Cameron
Rating
Yes


paulisfree04
Rating
yes she should be in a civil law suit for false inprisonment and she should have to serve 6 years


killerlegend2u
Rating
she should be indentified to keep ppl safe from those acusation.


Chuck M
Rating
Given the facts, as you stated them, with no other factors to consider.....Yes. She is a criminal, and criminals should be identified for the general public.


This, That & such
Yes !


Mizz B
Rating
Yes she should, and she should serve double the time he did.

Them women f*ck it up for the real victims of rape and it's about time they were punished properly for it.


Princess415
Of course she should be named, the lying little b*tch. She should not only be named but she should be put away for the same amount of time that the poor innocent guy had to languish in prison. An eye for an eye!


kezz
YES!YES!YES!


KU
Rating
yes she should be named and imprisoned and serve the same sentence.


guernsey_donkey2
Rating
Too true. Nasty crime, but just being accused can ruin a fella.

Lying about such a crime is nasty and vicious.


Psycho Dave
Rating
yes and no she should be shamed stoned but it isn't the way here in England the person in the wrong has all the rights the rules stink but does any one do any thing about it no look at who you vote for and study carefully there is a party moving fast up the ladder and guess who _ _ _ Dave


rowdy
Yes, yes, a thousand times yes. Also, men accused of rape should not be named until convicted.


melas
Rating
NAMED AND SHAMED


lisa h
yes definetly


CHRIS S
Rating
yes she should be named


davespnr
Rating
If she was named and then really raped, no-one would believe her. I agree that it is diabolical what she did though.


michael k
Women who are raped should not be named.Women who make false accusations should.Simple.


Effie
Rating
no, but she should be thorwn in jail for 30 years, ten year for each year that guy had to suffer in there


Danger Mouse
If they name her then she will instantly become a target of a REAL rapist.
What she has done is very wrong and I feel for the men she accused.
However, she needs psychiatric help, not actually raping, which may well happen if you name her.


Dry Dreamer
If, as you say she has done this six time's then she is in need of urgent psychiatric treatment and as such is entitled to anonymity


?
Tough to answer. But yes she should be identified in a case of repeated claims. Protecting rape victims from character assasination is important too.


mikefitzhistorian
This is a very difficult question to answer. In principle I feel that the real crime was the incompetence of the police and the courts in not realising that the woman concerned was a serial liar. It is difficult enough to get women to come forward after they have been raped and also very hard to secure a conviction in court. Rape is a traumatic experience for women and I lean, with extreme reluctance, to the view that anonymity should still be preserved as the lesser of two evils.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 What can I do about CPS wrongfully accusing me of striking my child?
Crrently involved in CPS case, which all began because my ex & his mother have been coaching my sons to call CPS whenever I do/do not do something out of revenge, all because my ex has to pay ...


 Why do you think violence has been on such a rise with teenagers in the 21st century?
...


 If a man rapes a woman, would u give him death penalty or a sentence?
Thank you all fo answering my last question.

I am a muslim and in islam if a man rapes a woman we would kill him, give him death penalty. i would like to say what do you think of that?...


 Should marijuana be legalized, yes or no?
...


 My hobby and how the goverment affects it?
I have to write a paper about my hobby and how the government affects it. My hobby is going camping at the beach w/ my friends. i mean i know it effects it by i have to obey laws of the road on my ...


 I sent some boots back, for exchange they refunded my card, they then sent the boots as well. Can I keep them?
...


 Capital PUNISHMENT!!?
How much Prison Space would we FREE up if we brought back the death penalty...i mean 'an eye for and eye' situation?...


 Where can a 15 year old work legally for good pay?
I need to get a job to start saving for a car.
Where can I work?...


 I got a fake £1 coin in my change. Should I take it to the police station and report it as counterfeit money.
It would kill half an hour I suppose....


 If somebody suddenly made you King of the World, what changes would you make?
Would you make new laws or revoke some old ones? Would you intervene in human follies? How would you deal with conflicting opinions? Where would you stand on personal responsibility?...


 Is abortion ethical ?
I am undecided on this issue but id like to hear your arguement of why it should/shouldn't be banned?
Additional Details
By arguement i also mean it should be backed by reason and ...


 My husband is filing for divorce. How can I postpone it?
I need time to think it over and think about my interests. My husband is rushing me. He's already filed for divorce but I was not served with papers yet. Does anybody knows any loophole in such ...


 Is there any subject that's too taboo to discuss in public?
What I'm asking here is whether in a public place you can actually have complete freedom of speech to discuss hard, sensitive or difficult subjects taking into account that there are no children ...


 If you are for the death penalty?
are you also in favour of euthanasia and if not why....


 Why haven't they made a law that you must be an organ Donner when you die.?
Or even that everyone is on the organ doner list and if you dont want to donate then you have to apply not to instead of leaving it up to people to carry a doner card or leave it to their family to ...


 Why is marijuanna illegal?
If we want to play the health card then fine ill play it. In the history of man There has not been 1 case of someone getting high on pot then beating their family. Or a pot related death. If weed is ...


 You find an attache case full of money.?
Imagine you are in Central London or any major city in the U.K. You hail a taxi. As you are settling down in the back of the taxi you see a smart leather attache case on the floor. Surreptitiously, ...


 Should Abortion be legal in the United States?
In over 90% of the world, abortion is illegal....


 AM I RELATED TO THIS GIRLLLLl??
i get weird answers , am i related or not , if so please explain

im thinking of marrying this girl , will it be weirf

this is how me and he are related

my dads ...


 If a man says "I wouldn't cheat on you, but if I did, you wouldn't know about it".?
What does this really mean?
The man is my husband....




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.034