Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law & Ethics

Three cops have just been killed by a gunman. Isn't it time we banned guns like the UK and other countries?
Find answers to your legal question.





Three cops have just been killed by a gunman. Isn't it time we banned guns like the UK and other countries?

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/americas/7983894.stm

WEEK OF SHOOTINGS
Sat 4 April: Gunman kills three policemen in Pittsburgh before being wounded and captured.
Fri 3 April: Gunman kills 13 people at an immigration centre in Binghamton, New York state, then apparently shoots himself.
Sun 29 March: Gunman kills seven elderly residents and a nurse at a nursing home in Carthage, North Carolina, then is shot and wounded himself.
Sun 29 March: Man kills five relatives and himself in Santa Clara, California.
Additional Details
Following the Dunblane massacre in the UK, there hasn't been a killing as worse since, is that just coincidence or something?!


    




Richard C
I understand your concern, sadness and frustration. But "bad guys" will find a way to acquire weapons and nobody can convince me otherwise. A ban would ultimately take a means for good people to protect themselves and their property from this unbridled evil.


Natasha B
Rating
No

Do you really think that guns would be gone?
The only people who would not have guns would be the law abiding citizens....all of the criminals will still have them.


adamgoldberg1337
No... I think it's time that we let everybody have a gun.

See how many people start shooting others when everybody else has a gun.


Tia
Rating
No, the people who are desperate to have them to do bad things with them would find ways anyways, duh. Don't compare the USA to the UK??? and other countires, really.


MUSCLES
If loonies want to kill people then they will use bombs or another method.


bkc99xx
Rating
No


nissanman678
Rating
Another crazy liberal


hazel eyes
Rating
why ban them! then only a criminal will have them..nobody can stop someone from getting a gun,if the really want one they would kill whom ever it is to take it.people like power and some will do anything to have it..


Jeff
I understand why you would ask that question, as there are so many people who believe that you can just wave a magic wand and make the problem go away, that others start to believe it is true.

But the fact is that banning guns would actually make things worse.

If you look at some of the US cities that have a handgun ban or other ownership-limiting laws, you will find is that they have some of the highest rates of violent crime in the country. Chicago, Washington DC, etc. have huge problems, because the criminals know that the law-abiding citizenry cannot carry a weapon, and that gives them the advantage. Laws only work when people obey them; criminals rarely obey laws.

Most of the incidents you cite are the result of people not getting the mental health help they need. In the Binghamton case, no one who knew the shooter was surprised, so why didn't this guy get help? That's the important question.


B G
Rating
if a lot more good guys had guns out there the problem would be much smaller


Micky....the resurrection
If we ban guns, criminals will still have them as they don't acquire them by legal means and good law abiding citizens will not be able to protect themselves. Guns don't kill people, people kill people. If someone wants to kill, they will with or without a gun. Look at all those poor people in Africa getting hacked up by machetes.


Buff
The only ones who would suffer would be the law abiding citizens who have a right to protect themselves and their families.

The ones doing the shooting would find an illegal way to get the guns anyway.

We have a constitutional right to bear arms.


pleasant
That's what the criminals want to happen then their jobs would be easier


roadhazzards
Nope, it's time we kick those who want to ban guns out of the United States.


Support
Rating
BANNING GUNS IS LIKE FINDING A NEEDLE IN A HAYSTACK.


mcherry362001
Rating
I say no fu***ng way. I have a concealed carry permit, and carry a pistol alot of places I go. One time in the park, later in the evening, a homeless guy tried to mug me with a knife. If I had not had that with me, and had not been able to protect myself, he would have had his way that night. Look up stories just like this one, they are all over the place. PEOPLE HAVE A RIGHT TO HAVE GUNS IN AMERICA. Anyone that doesnt like it is FREE to leave at any time.


Brown Eyed Deelite
Absolutely NOT!
Criminals would have weapons and the rest of us law abiding citizens would be left defenseless.
The problem isn't the guns, the problem is people with mental issues.
We should NEVER hand over our power and rights to the government to control.
We have a RIGHT to bear arms, it's our constitutional right.
Instead we need to fix our healthcare system and help these people with mental health issues before it gets to that point. THAT is the root of the problem, not the guns.


Mo Fayed
Whats so enjoyable about being killed by an unlicensed illegal gun, that people miss out on if they get shot by a legal one?


straydog
Rating
I know at least 7 ways to kill if that is what i was wanting to do, and none require a gun. But i like that option if necessary.


mnwomen
No people who want to get a gun for illegal use will get a gun. The people who follow the law will be left defenseless. And I have had a relative murdered so dont assume you know how I feel. If he had had a gun he might have been able to defend himself but he did not own one.


Joy
Only if the cops give up their guns too, like in the UK. Sometimes innocent people are killed by cops; it goes both ways. I feel for all the lives that have been lost on both sides.


Mercer Devil
I would like to say no, but it is getting harder to defend the right to bear arms when gun nuts keep using their guns on people.


Dabalina
Rating
It's horrible but it's a supply demand thing. If we don't have guns and other countries do were weaker. If we get our law enforcement stronger guns the criminals get some better than those.


1st Earl Jellicoe
Rating
Since the firearms amendment act in 1997, gun homicides have averaged approx. 60 a year in the UK.
In the USA that figure is closer to 8,000 a year.
Even taking into account the larger US population, there is still way more gun homicides in the US than the UK. Conclusion: place tighter restrictions on the sale of guns in the US.


Magic M
Rating
we need to hurry up and make robot gods to tell us what to do before we screw everything up.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 What is your take on the death penalty?
Should it be legal? If so, why? If not, why?
Additional Details
[EDIT]so it seems most of you guys are for the death penalty. but take the following into consideration. something to ...


 Whose fed up with too many immigrants coming over to the UK?
We're over- populated as it is. They take our jobs// problems are caused/ we have poor policy's. they sponge off the goverment. It's terrible. I know it's not all of them but we ...


 Can anything be done about a support order that leaves the father only $900 per month to live on?
The mother is on walfare, has a live in boyfriend, food stamps, a new pick up truck and they rent a Harley on weekends to joy ride. Meanwhile, I am having to support my boyfriend (the father) and MY ...


 What is your opinion on Alcohol?
I'm writing an argumentive essay on alcohol, its harmful effects, and why it should be banned from consumption. I would like to hear viewpoints from both sides of the issue. So, basically, if ...


 How can employers justify denying someone a position for being overqualified?
Someone works hard for years of their life to get a good education only to be turned down for being 'overqualified' for a position they had their heart set on.

I don't think ...


 Is growing marijuana legal in your state/country?
It is legal ito grow 2 plants where i live but only for personal use, if you get caught trying to sell it or with it packed in bags for sale you get fined....


 Do you think we have freedom of speech now?
...


 How can smokers complain about the new ban to be introduced?
There is proof that passive smoking is harmful so surely it is a basic human right not to be poisoned by other peoples smoke so how can they(smokers) moan about having their human rights infringed? ...


 In your opinion whats the worst crime ever committed?
what happened?...


 Bring back the death penalty?!?!!!!?
Have you seen the news about the baby(baby P) who died a horriffic death in the hands of his brutal mother and her nazi obssesed boyfriend? The death penalty should be brought back in cuz sending ...


 An argument against the death penalty.?
I think we shouldn't have the death penalty because,
1. Statistically It does not prevent or deter serious crime.
2. We abolished it in this country because we decided the state ...


 If you'd secretly filmed the police beating up a black man, would you release it knowing it could cause a riot
A race riot in which hundreds of people could be injured or killed just like what happened with the L.A. riots after the Rodney King film was seen.
Additional Details
Yes, I know that ...


 Hasn't Maxine Carr suffered enough?
She has served her sentence in prison. Shouldn't she be allowed to try and rebuild her life?
Additional Details
I'm not really surprised by many of the answers here.
But ...


 Immigrants come here for a better life, Shall we insist on lawbreakers being returned to their own country?
I believe that if they come here for a better life and integrate then such is life. What I object to, is many of them coming here for a better life and making ours worse. I believe that any who ...


 Why is it illegal to have an unlicensed gun if the bill of rights says you have he right to bare arms?????
...


 Why is it a law that you have to wear your seatbelt?
I think this law is ********! I mean children and babies should be buckled up, but isn't it your own personal decision to wear a seatbelt? I think it's just an excuse for pigs with nothing ...


 Can you sue someone with just an verbal contract?
...


 If you found out that you lived next door to an illegal immigrant...would you turn them in ?
Let's just say they were like every other neighbor on your block. They kept their yards neat, they maintained their property, they were friendly and cordial. If you found out they were not U.S....


 Is jack straw right in asking muslem women to remove there veils?
i think with no disrespect to there religion they ...


 Demanding money - do we have to pay her ?
hired a childminder 3 days a week for after school care, paid 1 month in advance, after 3 days i found out that this women was leaving my 4yr old in a locked car & going into schools to get other ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.084