Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law & Ethics

Vick made a plea bargain with federal prosecutors, now county prosecutors want him. Is it double jeopardy?
Find answers to your legal question.





Vick made a plea bargain with federal prosecutors, now county prosecutors want him. Is it double jeopardy?



    




Deep Thought
The state gets a bite at the apple too, but it is piling on.


pixy_stix
No, I think they have different charges against him. They may be only slightly different, but different enough to prosecute.


bic
nope.


jurydoc
No, these are two different jurisdictions, each with an interest in and separate charges for the offenses involved. Same with military and civil jurisdictions.


Kevy
Rating
no.


beardog4314
Nope, he broke more than one law at a time, and can be tried for any of them.


bark
Rating
Nope.
He violated state and federal laws.
He can be charged with both.


Michael C
Nope. Double jeopardy means you can't be tried twice for the same crime. However, one action can break multiple laws. In this case, Vick broke both Federal and local laws and can be prosecuted for both.


Jason
No. Two different charges.


i pack a 44
no it is not...........he may be charged with local crimes............


lametorg
Rating
No. Double jeopardy means you cannot be tried more than once for breaking the same law. He plead guilty to federal law, and is now facing State law. Different laws = not double jeopardy.


jxr182
It is not double jeopardy. As long as different levels of government all have jurisdiction over the crime, they can all go after him. Double jeopardy would be if he went to court, was found not guilty, so the prosecution either found new evidence or just changed the case around in a manner to make it more likely for a guilty verdict.


hazeltine4
No. He broke both Federal Laws and County Laws. It is sort of similar to OJ. He "won" his murder case, but was then tried and lost the Civil case, which said he was "responsible" for their deaths.

Vick could (and should) go to jail for up to 40 years -- 5 years for each of the 8 dogs he killed. The testimony of his accomplices will be used in the county trial.


Kel
Rating
Double jeopardy is being charged with the same crime twice.....it isn't done....if you're taking about a soap opera, then they do whatever the writers come up with.


johnny cee
Rating
No. The lawyers are not going to let him have any loose rope at all.
I Cr 13;8a


UriK
No he broke both federal and state laws. Just when I thought he got lucky, because the Feds didn't go after him for RICO charges, the state of Virginia comes through to hopefully put him away for a more suitable length of time.


coragryph
Rating
No it is not double jeopardy -- it just looks like it.

One of the particular rules about double jeopardy is that it only applies to the same govt instituting the same charges twice -- in this case, state and federal courts are independent -- different "sovereigns" in legal parlance -- meaning that they can both independently prosecute -- one for state crimes, one for federal crimes.


Anton
No. It is not.
Double Jeopardy is when a person has been "declared innocent" and the whole process done with it. Now, if someone tries to prosecute again, to the same person, and with the same crime, that is "Double Jeopardy". Nothing can be done now after the person was declared innocent for the crime.
What's happening right now is:
He made a deal with the federal government. Federal laws means they rule equal throughout the country for all of us.
Now he has to respond to the county where he lived at he time when this happened. Every state has it's own laws (beside the federal ones), and so that's why he has to go through this as all of us would if braking the law.

I hope I clarified it better for you... I know, the law could be very confusing at times...


bennypin
It is NOT double jeopardy because they are DIFFERENT sovereigns. OJ Simpson got acquitted for a double homicide in LA some time ago. Now, he writes a book detailing exactly how he committed the crimes. Can the State of California now charge him with murder based on his published confession? NO! That would be double jeopardy.


judgmentknight
No. A person can be charged on a federal and state level. The state charges are going to be different from the federal charges anyway.


raichasays
No, they are two different sets of charges made by two different governmental structures.

Double jeopardy is when you are charged twice for the same crime. It is not the same crime if the "elements" that must be proved are different. For example, conspiracy to commit murder is not the same as attempted murder, because the "elements" that make up the definition of the crime are not the same.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 The right to discriminate or the right to religious faith ---- gay adoption !!!?
who is right about the issue of gay adoption ? the british government or the Catholic Church.
Additional Details
for people who quoted from the bible , in GENESIS 9:3 Everything that ...


 What Do You Guys Think Of Guantanamo Bay? Should It Be Closed Down?
Former U.S. Secretary of State Colin Powell said on Sunday the U.S. military prison at Guantanamo Bay for foreign terrorism suspects should be immediately closed and its inmates moved to the United S...


 What are your thoughts on "separation of church and state"?
Notice I haven't given you mine so don't assume to know anything about how I think .
Additional Details
I never mentioned the constitution....


 I have no idea why anybody is worried about Sharia law in Britain?
http://www.dailymail.co.
see its all sorted
what do you think can this only be good in the long run?
A...


 Is the real reason for NOT posting the 10 Commandments at our court house's because?
Thou shalt Not Lie
Thou shalt Not Steal
Thou shalt Not Commit Adultery

Would make a hostile work environment for Lawyers, Judges and Politicians?...


 One of my girlfriends friends put salt in my sugar bowl, can i get her done with attempted murder ?
...


 Is it true you can be arrested for buying an OXO cube, if you believe it is Cannabis resin?

Additional Details
This is not from personal experience but just something I've heard over the years!...


 Is paris Hilton getting to harsh of treatment?
I have a friend that got caught about 3 times with a suspended license and never had to do any jail time....they only revoked his license for 3 years.....why is she getting such harsh treatment?Is ...


 What qualifications do you need to be a lawyer?
I am thinking of becoming a lawyer and i would like to know what qualifications you need.
please help
lol
:)
...


 Break time in 12 hour shift??
my work is starting on a 12 hour shift basis which is fine but im not sure if the breaks are very fair, the manager has stated that we will be able to take 4 15 min breaks throughout the day so in ...


 Gun Control?
What are your thoughts on gun control and the seemingly endless school shootings? Would have gun control make a difference?...


 Should there be a return to corporal punishment in schools and the birch for young offenders?
The youth of today have no respect for anything or anybody and I think it is because they fear no punishment in a country ruined by 50 years of liberalism.
I also think the police should also be ...


 Legalise Drugs say the police?
What is he smoking? Now if he said outlaw drugs and seriously cracks down on hard drugs he would get my vote

This idiot even wants Herion on the NHS, where will he stop? will you be able ...


 Do you think Hitler had a few good ideas? Or was he really such a wicked dude as peeps kepp saying?
...


 Should Incest be legally allowed?

Additional Details
I AM AGAINST IT, JUST WONDERED WHETHER ANYONE THINK ITS OK BECAUSE A LOT OF COUNTRY'S ARE LEGALIZING IT...


 Do you think that President Bush and his war planners should be put up on war crime charges, and jailed?
...


 In the UK: What will happen if you don't pay your water rates?
Will they cut off your water supply? as water is necessary for hygiene purpose.(toilet...)...


 Is it morally/ethnically wrong to date someone who shares your last name?
Say you don't think that they have close family ties to you, or maybe they do. Would society look down, condemn you for wanting to date that person? If you were to marry, it would be like ...


 Have you ever broken the law?
...


 Pro-Choice and Pro-Life?
Someone posted a question earlier stating that conservatives were hypocritical b/c they were Pro-Life but Pro-War. Well, I've always thought it was hypocritical for liberals to fight harder for ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.044