Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law & Ethics

What do you think of the Wal-Mart shoplifter's being made to wear a sign saying "I am a thief?"?
Find answers to your legal question.





What do you think of the Wal-Mart shoplifter's being made to wear a sign saying "I am a thief?"?

Details at http://www.msnbc.com/id/18533937


    




doublewidemama
Maybe they should be the greeter at Wal-mart with a blue vest that says, "Welcome to the Wal-Mart where I shoplifted."
with a Yellow Rollback Smiley on the back that says, "I thought 'Always low prices' meant to use the five finger discount."

"Steal here and replace an old fart saying,
Hello, How can I help you?"

It's interesting that a judge can use public humiliation in lieu of a jail sentence, but try to do that in public schools with students who do wrong, and you'll be sued by the parents.

Imagine if a student who cheated on a test had to wear a sign that said "I cheated on Ms. Smith's algebra exam" for a week. Or..."I got caught putting foul language up on the bathroom walls." Some people have no shame, so I'm not sure that attempts at public humiliation would be a deterrant, but why not try.

There must be consequences for misbehavior, that hits the offender where it hurts, and then there will be a decrease in crime.

I'm all for public stonings for convincted beyond the shadow of a doubt serial killers, rapists, child molesters, etc. Why not use the middle eastern version of chopping off hands that steal. Now there's a deterrant...Always!


Kevin
Rating
It can't be any worse than wearing a uniform that says "I'm employed at Wal-Mart".


Yahoo Nazi
Rating
1) It's pretty sad if one has to shoplift at Walmart
2) It's pretty sad the individual was caught.


OldGringo
Just about as good as one of the Walton's wearing one saying I am a greedy corporate raider taking money off main-street in small towns all over the US and other countries and am making myself filthy rich.


One Sexy Jeep Girl
I have a better idea. Let's tattoo the word thief in big black bold letters across the forehead of all thieves.


bigdonut72
how about walmart employees wear shirts that say " I ran the little guy out of business" or "I am the reason third world people make 12 cents per hour" or "I came to your community even though you dont want me here" or "buy our crap, there might be lead in the baby toys, but they are cheap and we dont care if your kids are poisoned" ?

Screw walmart


Liberals love America!
Best. Punishment. For thievery. Ever.


caring_funlovingteacher
I think it is okay since they had a choice. They could have taken the 60 days sentence and they prefered the sign, so it was really up to them.


ibattlerobots69
Sounds good to me.


..........................
I think it would be better if it said
" I'm an idiot for getting caught shopplifting!!!"


Kristin
Rating
haha. nice. maybe they should've gotten a job.


HopelesslyInLoveWithLove
Rating
hahahahahaha.............

I think it's a perfect punishment.

If you can't do the time.........don't do the crime.......LOL>


BostonSportsFan
I think it is a good tactic, but I don't think it will work because it is more of a joke than a punishment.


Aceman
Rating
sounds ok to me crime dose not pay


Brianne
Rating
Considering Wal-Mart was the easiest to rip off, ShopKo one of the hardest ones they should of took measures a long time ago to stop making it so easy! I stood there one night watching this young guy pull off a scam with a computer and the girl at the return desk never even questioned him!!! I think the theif deserves it but I think the store needs to step up to.


chelle
a great deterrent!


D.W.W.
perfect.
I think its great


Steve E
I love it. These people make prices higher for everyone. Shoplifting is not a victimless crime. We are all victims. Do you think Walmart is going to eat the loss...no way. You and I pay for it, and I think shoplifters should do a few weekends in jail.


surferchick
Rating
very appropriate, they deserve it


Richard F
This type of punishment seems to be effective. It is voluntary in lieu of other punishments.


beachloveric
Rating
Ha, I think it would become a status symbol for some people!


sengineer702
How big is the sign for wally mart? Any thief should wear the sign. Humiliation cured a lot of crime before big money and lots of new prisons come on the scene.


♥Trinity♥
Rating
I think it's funny.


olivia3684
Haha sounds better than jail!


yesyes251
i think it totally rocks!!!!!!!!!


rougerocker
Rating
HA! they should make him/her round up carts for a month !


susie
Rating
Nothing wrong with that provided that the person that had to wear it was embarrassed enough to have learned that stealing is not good.


Singing on the Shore
Rating
A good old-fashioned way of punishment. Bravo!


Egal
no one ever still because they want to, they still because they have to. i realy think its sad.


Princess Tigerlilly Dâ„¢
Priceless...


SuzyBelle04
Rating
hmm, if it will deter shoplifters in the future and esp those wearing the signs, then that is good............if they were innocent and wrongly convicted, then the judge truly overstepped his boundaries and humiliated them without cause





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 I just did 20 years in prison for killing someone, I found out that person isn't really dead, can I kill him?
I was convicted of killing a man that was tortured and burned to death. To make a long story short I was innocent. My wife has been working for 2 decades trying to prove I didn't do it. C...


 Would it be racist to say this?
Why can't we send back the families of these terrorists who terroise us to their country of origin as a punishment when the terorists are caught and convicted of their crimes. If the ...


 How do you feel about Death Penality?
This Stems From Questioning The Way I feel About The Death Penalty, A Mother Allegedly Killed Her Two Kids And Put The In A Trash Bag And Put The Under The Sink...

"Do You Believe In T...


 Why do white people always feel like black people are angry when we ask questions?
Why do you think blacks are looking for hand-outs because we ask for reperations for treating of black ancestors like crap? Why should we put in under a rug and forget about it? White people, if ...


 Can I press charges?
I have a neighbor who has called my landlord making false accusations. She is claiming that my oldest daughter is uncontrollable, my wife and I are never home, the cops are at our house 2-3 times a ...


 How can you pass a polygraph test.(lie Detector teat) If you are lying?
...


 Will there ever be a drinking or alcohol ban in this country?
how many people have you heard of, in the media or anywhere else for that matter, who have caused accidents to people or even death to people by drink driving. do you think a ban on alcohol should be ...


 Would you be obligated to turn in a child molester? read the details B4 answering?
If you were a cop, and you caught some guy molesting a 12 year old girl, and the guy beat the daylight out of you and the guy could have easily killed you and gotten away with it, if he wanted to, ...


 Do you think abortion should be a individual decision?

Additional Details
For everyone's information I am not pregnant I was just curios to see how the majority ...


 If guns should be made illegal because they are used to kill, then shouldn't knives be made illegal too?
... and hammers, and poison, and cars, and cancer, and aids, and rocks, and sticks, and .........


 Should teachers be paid as least as much as lawyers, doctors, or business leaders are paid? ?
...


 Do you think abortion should be illegal in the US?
...


 Can I sue M&M's (Candy). They have destroyed my life. How can I do this?
This is not a Joke post

I have been eating their M&M candy for over 14 years. I really like the candy. I usually grab a bunch of them in my right hand and eat them.

Well I ...


 If it was in the middle of the night, and a stranger was banging on your door screaming to let them in?
because a maniac killer was after that person, but you didn't know that. Would you let them in....


 Should a father who signs his parental rights away be held responsible 10 years later?
I had a child in 1983...after a long battle I got custody...on her first visit she took off with him and was not found for just over 5 years. The Court would not give him back to me as he had no idea ...


 Should I sue Yahoo???
For allowing so many people on here with no sense of humor????...


 American is NOT the best country in this world!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!?
Whoever thought that America is the best country in the world, screw them!!!! America is a stupid country because you must be 21 to drink. In other countries you can be 18.Why did they enforce the ...


 Should we remove "in god we trust" from our quarters?
...


 Do bike riders have to stop at stop signs?
i ride my bike to the library every day (about a mile away). for stop signs, i don't stop unless there is a car coming. i usually just roll slowly through them. our neighborhood has police all ...


 If cannibalism became legal in the UK, should we eat the poor?
Rather than have them sit around idle?...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.074