Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law & Ethics

Why do they use alcohol swabs for lethal injections?
Find answers to your legal question.





Why do they use alcohol swabs for lethal injections?



    




30 Weeks
according to a spokesman for the Texas Department of Corrections, which has carried out many executions by lethal injection, the technician (it's never a doctor) is in fact supposed to swab the prisoner's arm first. One presumes other states employing this method do likewise.

There are several reasons for this. Apart from its usefulness as an antiseptic, alcohol causes blood vessels to rise to the surface, making it easier to insert the needle.

More important, there's a chance the prisoner's sentence might be delayed or commuted at the last minute.

It's happened before. In October, 1983 condemned murderer James Autry was strapped to a gurney for an hour in a Texas prison with saline solution dripping into his arm. (He was awake the whole time, incidentally.)

At about the time he was scheduled to die he was told he had received a stay of execution. He was returned to his cell and not executed until the following March. Whatever you think of the death penalty, you wouldn't want the guy to die of sheer carelessness.

Which brings us to what I think is the real reason for swabbing the arm--it allows the executioners to think of themselves as professionals doing a job rather than killers.

Interviews with members of execution teams reveal that they place great stock in following proper procedures. We may be certain that if the prisoner were to choke on a chicken bone during his last meal, the authorities would spare no effort to save his life an hour prior to ending it. Indeed, if you can believe Chuck Shepherd's News of the Weird column, that's already happened. "In Texas convicted murderer David Lee Herman slashed his throat on April 1 [1997], a day before his execution, but was patched up and given his lethal injection one day late," Shepherd writes.


jen
WOW
I never thought about that! Cannot answer! Weird.
WHY do they bother?
I think lethal injection is FAR too easy way out anyway.


Steven L
Rating
Pretty much the same reason why kamikaze pilots wear helmets. There is no reason


sgp714
Rating
Probably for legal reasons.


Rja
Pray tell we wouldn't want the gentleman to get an infection!


Wizzard2
Well, as silly as it souldns, they ave to follow medical proceedure. If a prisional is deathy ill on death row they try to cure him, to kill him.


Roxy
Rating
Because it is considered unethical not to kinda stupid huh? why do they even use clean needles


nat_00420
lol, good question!


Yahoo! Answers Chic
Rating
For legal reasons or else they do it to seem humane. Stupid policy and procedure bull s h i t. Love the question though.


Bones
The doctors oath says they will do no harm...wonder how they manage to follow that when they give em the needle...


legendary~cool
Rating
It is simply protocol....


dmgoldsbo7
Good question!!!!!!


barfly_z
Rating
Thats a good one!!!!! I would like to know that one myself!!!!That's a funny question!!!!!


Dave of the Hill People
Rating
It's all part of the meeting the requirements of the "cruel and unusual punishment" clause. The death penalty is on thin enough ice as it is re: that clause, and not practicing basic medical procedures when administering the death penalty could jeopardize its constitutionality.

That said, your question is amusing and ironic. :)


whenwhalesfly
Rating
I had no idea they used alcohol swabs !! How stupid. But my guess is, the family that is watching the lethal injection could no doubt sue the prison for not doing the procedure as any doctor would do it.

I have never gave this a thought. What a stupid thing to do. Their going to kill that person anyway. But oh well, whatever flips their cookie...


jhaejhae
Man I have been asking the same question for many years.

I hope someone anwsers this


wannamatch?
Rating
by law it is required or else the party of the one being injected could sue


NutstersChick
Rating
what a waste of alcohol.
:)


Franklin
Wouldn't want to send someone to hell and make them sick. It would take the sport out of the whole execution.


Mommymonster
Rating
Hahahaha

They don't want you to come back and sue due to infection of the injection.

Hahahahaha


cluelesskat maria
i guess its just a force of action,it just a natural thing to do


Mopar Muscle Gal
legality reasons


3D Farms
To clean the skin of germs


island3girl
Rating
because the prisoner could get a stay of execution after the IV is stated and you wouldn't want him to have an infection.

the lethatl part is put in through tubing and not directly from a needle into the body


NNY
they dont want to give the dude an infection that he could get ill from...


shy
SO THAT WHERE EVER THEY INJECT U IS CLEAN LESS CHANCE OF INFECTION


niwriffej
Rating
I think it is to avoid forcing foreign particles and bacteria from your skin into your bloodstream when they puncture you. Hygene is the magic wand that makes modern medicine work.

Oh...lethal injections! Just SOP with injections of all kinds, maybe it's kind of gallows humor, "wouldn't want you to get sick, now!"


lawzlaw
Rating
Because if they didn't it would give the anti-death penalty folks a reason to argue that it is cruel and unusual.


Luv79t
Rating
I think it is just routine, that's just the way it's done.


Cruella DeVil
Maybe to protect the seringe...!

Good question!


cute1-4u
good question, i think it is because of hygenic reasons, maybe it is so that the needle won't hurt so bad when it goes to kill. I don't think that sounds right. hell i don't know?





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 To those who are pro-choice...?
I am wondering what you think a fetus is before it is born. Obviously it is a living thing, I think we can all agree on that, right? I mean, if you take it out of its' environment, it will ...


 Would this be considered breaking the law, or is it okay?
Building a catapult on the roof of my apartment complex and lobbing bags of my feces at other buildings, cars, bikers and pedestrians....


 How can I complain about someone who works for the job centre plus?
well while I was on the job seekers allowance, Theys was a lady while I went to sign on , and she would give me such a horrible stare , and star for long at me really horribly , because they was ...


 Obama wants to force you to pay for health care,Can you afford it and the co-pay ?
...


 Do I have a case for complaint?
I recently had my three year old nephew Justin to visit. The little chap got very upset when cook refused to give him a fourth portion of cake, and had a tantrum. I suddenly remembered a miracle ...


 How do you stop a pedophile that is using this service?
An individual that goes byt he name of Chester the Molester has been using this service to ask questions about becoming a Big Brother,his attraction to a 14 year old when he usually likes 6 year olds,...


 Do you think killing an endangered species for hunt should be punished by the death penalty?
Humans shouldn't be dumb enough to want to exterminate a species for money. We should just start killing these hunters off.

http://news.yahoo.com/s/...


 If I am a minor, but I am with my parents at a restaurant, can I order alcohol in the State of Texas?
The law makes reference to minors being allowed to consume alcohol when in the direct supervision of their parents, but does this only allow them to drink alcohol in their parents' home or can ...


 Why do people believe Marijuana is a horrible "gateway" drug?
I smoke Marijuana myself, have for many years. I havn't become this drug hungry junkie living on the streets, as so many believe it leads to. It is souly a recreational drug for me and the main ...


 Is whistleblowing ethical?

Additional Details
Sorry for asking so many business questions, but I often find people have really formidable opinions and aid my understanding....


 If marijuana was legal for recreational use would you smoke it?
even if no won would ever know it

no won had od from smokeing weed to my knoledge

most people who smoke or drink would even if they wont admit it
Additional Details<...


 Do you agree with these people who say that our Immigration Laws are too strict?
http://www.socialistwork...


 If an employee has been in a current job for 4 months. Can an employer give them one months notice without sta
If an employee has been in a current job for 4 months. Can an employer give them one months notice without stating why? The employee is not guilty of any gross misconduct. Doesn't the employer ...


 Is there any way homemakers could get paid?
I dont know much about state law, government, and all that. I was just wondering if I could actually get paid for all the hard work I do. I work just as hard as my salaried husband. AND I dont get ...


 Can men do anything by themselves? In 2007?
Or do they need help with everything ?...


 Does anyone believe that smoking marijuana is immoral or wrong?
Does anyone believe that because you are breaking the law means you are doing something wrong? What makes smoking marijuana wrong?
Additional Details
No i am conservative but just ...


 Whats people's views on the 12yr old girl wh died from a gunshot to the head by her brother?
The "powerful" firearm was in their house, to me it was an accident waiting to happen
Additional Details
Sorry yes think he is being questioned, even if he did do it I don'...


 Are we living in a namby pamby nation?
Here are a few examples of sheer stupidity i come across.

Under the Gambling Act, children are no longer able to win soft toys over the value of £5.Not only could "too cuddly" ...


 Do you think Gay Marriage should be allowed? Why do you think this way?
I think it should stay the way it is now!!!!!!!...


 Fat people discrimination law?
The news was talking about a state (Mass.) who wants to pass a law that states, fat people can sue for discrimination in a workplace if they feel they were discriminated against because they are ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.074