Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law & Ethics

Why does the death penalty cost more than life in prison?
Find answers to your legal question.





Why does the death penalty cost more than life in prison?

i'm not asking which one you think is morally right; i'm just wondering why the death penalty costs more. it seems like life in prison would cost more because the prisoner needs to be paid for every year.

i hope i don't somehow offend anyone by this question!
thanks.
Additional Details
i got this information from UpFront magazine. it's a magazine for high school classes


    




Libraryanna
States have a requirement for automatic appeals for anyone getting the death penalty. So all those legal battles cost a bunch of money.

In addition, people on death row are separated from the rest of the prison population and treated differently, requiring more people to guard them.


Boozekiss B
All the appeals. (court costs)


Paladin
Rating
because death penalty lawyers charge the state a fortune at every appeal


Justin H
Rating
If it was simply a matter of convicting and executing, the costs for life in prison would be substantially higher. But the equation changes when you factor in all the legal costs associated with the various appeals and legal maneuvering.


Jessica P
It does? I have never heard that before.... where did you get your info? If it is true.... the only thing I could think of is maybe court costs... people on death row go through appeal after appeal.... so maybe that?


El Guapo
Rating
Excellent question. You are right, it's not even close - it costs WAY more to execute a prisoner than to keep him incarcerated for life.

The numbers differ by state, but the reason for the disparity is that the government wants to be as sure as possible that it does not execute an innocent person. Toward that end, much more is spent on pre-trial preparation (most DP cases take a year or more to come to trial), more pre-trial motions, more expert witnesses (on both sides), more attorneys (also on both sides), jury sequestration, security (needed because of more publicity in DP trials), an extra sentencing trial, and an exhaustive appeals process.

This disparity becomes even greater when you consider the time value of money. Most of the additional costs of capital punishment are up-front, occurring before and during the trial itself, whereas most of the costs of life imprisonment are spread over the term of incarceration. Any first-year finance student (or lottery official) can attest that a dollar up-front is WAY more burdensome than a dollar spread over 30-40 years.

Some think the high cost of capital punishment is why violent crime rates are HIGHER in death penalty jurisdictions - every extra dollar spent on capital punishment is one that's NOT going to police, education, drug treatment facilities, women’s shelters, and other government programs that help reduce crime.

Even with all of these precautions in place, innocent people STILL get sentenced to death pretty regularly. In the last 35 years in the U.S., 130 people have been released from death row because they were exonerated by DNA evidence. These are ALL people who were found guilty “beyond a reasonable doubt.” Unfortunately, DNA evidence is not available in most cases. So, as long as the death penalty is in place, you are pretty much GUARANTEED to occasionally execute an innocent person.

Many would argue that is the highest cost of all.


IceBreaker27
Rating
The required appeals process is pricey. Trials are very expensive! We take putting someone to death quite seriously in this country, which is why a death sentence is automatically appealed.

It doesn't really have anything to do with the chemicals used in lethal injections or paying someone to administer to the chemicals - the vast majority of the cost is in the trial.


MP US Army
Rating
Because of all the legal costs because someone on death row will appeal every chance he has and taxes pay for all of it.


jakflak
Rating
It's not the death penalty that costs money, it's the pointless appeals.


Steve
Rating
Because of the cost of death-penalty trials.


Canadian
Because hopefully you would live in a just society where the death sentence isn't handed out like candy.

As soon as someone is sentenced to death, they have the right to a number of appeals - which means hiring lawyers, court time and more hassle.

Its good, because it reduces the risk of someone being put to death and then the authorities turning around and saying "Oops! He was innocent after all!"


shorty
i think the death penalty is mainly for murders and stuff so they have taken a life so there's should be taken and life isnt enough for some ppls familys.


Elizabeth
Rating
It doesn't in some cases


Sarah P
Rating
Since you didn't say where the info comes from, I'm wondering where you heard that from? That doesn't sound true to me unless you look at it that the death penalty costs someone else their life and life doesn't...


t3hplatyz0rz
If you have life in prison, you have the chance to make up for your crimes by helping people who don't have life in prison rethink their lives. It is still possible to live for something in prison.

You cannot live for something once you have died. You cannot do anything involving living people once you have died.


oldschoolgamer98
Rating
I don't think it costs more at all, from what i've heard over the years a good estimate is each inmate costs an average of $30,000 a year.
But, if the death penalty is more expensive, i would think it would be because of all the research and work that goes on verifying it, court & lawyers, investigators, the EXECUTIONER!
But i highly doubt the death penalty is more expensive.


J L
Rating
because they have a hard time hiring someone who is a doctor and willing to kill someone... weird to me vets seem to have no issue killing a vicious dog then why should people have a hard time killing a vicious person?


jenisisgrafix
Rating
i don't see how that makes sense either! c'mon how much electricity do they use?!


Bryan D
Rating
Gotta be some damn good chemical used to kill the people...


nykia9
you have to pay for the electricity and the equitment





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Why is gay marriage not legal?
isnt it illegal to involve religion into politics? and why would religious groups be involved in ...


 What kind of trouble can a person be in if they break 2 small glass windows on a vaccant house in texas?
I am 19 and I've never done anything wrong before I just decided to be stupid and broke some windows(2, very small like letter paper size) on a house, I regret it and am wondering what kind of ...


 My boyfriend got charged with tampering with/ fabricating evidene.. how much time can he face?
He has a record.. but hes a clean guy now.. he just got charged with tampering/ fabricating with evidence. I dont know how much jail time he can do.. if any. his bong is at 15,000. can anyone give me ...


 An 85 year old woman has been living in the same apartment for 40 years and her hands shake like crazy.......?
She lives in a building under the rent stabilized law. She requested a dishwasher last year because she was having trouble standing for long periods of time as well as hold the dishes. First the ...


 Marijuana legalization?
i know its a silly question but there are so many different points of view and facts and opinions and what not etc. why is Marijuana ...


 I was involved in an alcohol sting..the girl came through my line and i asked for her date of birth..i don't ?
know why i thought she would tell the truth..and i could tell something wasn't right the way she was looking..anyway was she suppose to lie about her age ..i got fired and received a ticket none ...


 What are the arguements i can make for capital punishment being legalised in the UK?
...


 Can a fathers parental rights be removed
my 14 month old old son hasnt seen his father in almost a year and hasnt payed a penny towards him. he takes drugs and drinks most weekends and can be ...


 Does anyone know if it is illegal to be asked to have your drivers licence scanned upon entering a niteclub?
...


 What qualifies for wrongful imprisonment?
I was arrested for a violation of a law in which one of the subsections clearly exempts members of the military (which I am). Does the time I spent in jail (7 hours) and the fact that my name and ...


 Is This Considered A Crime And If So What Would It Fall Under?
Please Excuse All Spelling Mistakes Im In A Hurry To Type This !

I have a family member that has worked for the same company for 20 years as the Manager. Throughout that 20 years he/she ...


 Can your father emancipate you if you are 18, and do not have a job, But starting college in the fall?
I am 18, received my high school equivalent diploma in February 2008, My dad yells at me all the time about not having a job. I have really bad anxiety and have problems going into places and getting ...


 Broke persons camera accidentally because I tried taking it away cuz they took a photo of me without permision?
Am I legally responsible to pay them back, after all they took a picture of me without my consent and it was an accident.
Additional Details
Can someone give me proof of this with a ...


 Is it legal to drive with an open container of alcohol in your vehicle?
A.No, there are no exceptions
B. Yes, if the container is in the trunk
C. Yes, if the container is in the trunk and someone in the vehicle is over 21
D. Yes, if the container is locked ...


 What is the major problem for and against abortion?
thank you for all who are answering. you guys are a great help. :)...


 Do you feel that the death penalty is justice, or justified vengeance?
I feel that it is the latter because it is using the "eye for an eye" rule. I also add that that rule was made in an age many now consider barbaric and primitive. I find the fact that we ...


 PLEASE HELP HELP HELP?
2 DAYS AGO MY HUSBAND AND I WERE FIGHTING PUSHING AND SHOVING EACH OTHER HE PULLED ME AND LEFT A SCRATCH ON ME BUT IT WAS MUTUAL I SCRATCH HIM TO HE CALLED THE POLICE AND THEY END UP TAKING HIM TO JAI...


 Why is the government involved in gay marriage? Why do liberals feel an unnatural act is OK?
Why are we taking the low road and not looking to build a higher standard for the future....


 When will martial law hit the street in america ?
when will martial law hit the street in america
im guessing end 2009 beginning 2010...


 How to legally evict my girl friend from my aqpartment?
...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.044