Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law & Ethics

Why don't they use lie detectors in court to settle disputes.?
Find answers to your legal question.





Why don't they use lie detectors in court to settle disputes.?

I like creamy foods


    




Fly girl
Rating
I don't think lie detectors are 100% accurate.


lunatic
Justice is about reviewing verifiable facts and testimony, not what the two parties believe is or is not true.

Watch your cholesterol.

.


Miguel H
Because anyone who knows how they work can defeat them.


Scourge_of_Fascism
Rating
It's easy to fool a lie detector. Remember what George Costanza said, "It's not a lie if you believe it." A good motto for the right wing when they make excuses for the Bush Iraq fiasco.


sensible_man
Rating
They are not foolproof. Too many ways to defeat them. I like peanut butter.


Hockeyfan
Because they have been proven to be unreliable. Innocent people can fail them and guilty people can pass them.

Creamy as in cheesy or rich or as in texture like creamy peanut butter?

EDIT: is there any question that someone won't use to make a reference to Bush?


goz1111
while lie detectors are a good measure if a person is telling the truth they are not full proof, as such can not with stand a doubert test for the admission of scientific evidence into a court of law,


roklan2000
Rating
becuase lie detectors are not 100%


:]
because some people can train themselves to trick the lie detector


Big Dave
It is not 100% reliable at this time.


Pfo
Polygraphs are not absolute, sometimes they get false readings, plus it's time consuming.


Annie Oakley
Rating
Because lie detectors are not 100% accurate.
I like creamy foods too.


~Papi™Chulo E8© izza lucky dawg~
Lie detectors are not reliable.
I like spicy foods.


luv them horse's
Rating
Well you have enough right answers
But to reply to the one about why every time a question comes up bush is mentioned ,, well to answer you , is because everytime some one says words like> lie ,steal cheat, greed, > they are all related to bush ,, so what! you like bush ,, it just can;t be TRUE!! LOL
ICE CREAM UMM


carrie
Rating
becuase ther are not 100%


subwlimnuflik
Lie detectors are notoriously unreliable. If a person believes they are telling the truth it will not register as a lie. Also some people are pathological liars and a polygraph will never be able to distinguish the truth from a lie with these people. For some people a polygraph will indicate a lie even when they are tell the truth. For these and many other reasons polygraphs have never been used in a court of law.


fangtaiyang
The results of ploygraph exams are not accurate enough to serve as proof in legal matters.


acct10132002
Rating
Twinkies are "creamy foods"...
Wal-Greens has some nifty $1 wafers that are fat free! And somewhat creamy!
Lie detectors can be fooled if the person "gets his mind right".
Mental reservations are another factor. A nervous tic or jittery-ness can nulify a test. Michael J Fox could abstain from medication and shake off all the sensors!


P.I. Staker
Rating
Judges are trusted to make the careful and educated decision of whether a type of science is proven enough to be allowed as evidence in the courtroom. In the case of lie-detector tests, there is sufficient doubt as to the accuracy such that judges have decided that the results cannot be allowed in as proof.


shoshu80
Because you cannot force someone to take one uless they have done a hell of a lot of wrong, and then it's very hard, so people aren't willing lots of times and two, some can pass even when lieing.


Lynda
Rating
A lie detector test results can be altered by the subject or the person administering the test. I have personally convinced a lie detector test that I was a mass murderer. I can't even step on a bug but I beat the test to prove a point. I like BBQ.


Illinois-Lawyer
Rating
A lie detector is not always accurate. There are many ways to beat a lie detector. It can be used as a tool to try to guide an investigation in the right direction. However, if we relied on lie detectors we would not need a legal system and it would be very flawed. Sometimes even the meaning of a question can be interpreted differently by the person asking the question versus the person asking the question. It is a lot more unreliable than people think.


Stunner
I like creamy food too!


Rana
Rating
so that justice is given to the parties


katie d
Because they are not completely reliable.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 When are people going to stand up and say enough is enough?
the law in this country stinks its not law its tax collection the driver pays all the time for gods sake people stand up for yourselfs its our country not the goverments or the police they are there ...


 How do you feel about separation of church and state?
Personally I support it because if you look to the middle east you can see that theocracies do not work and are riddled with sectarian violence.

Please, no rambling about how it's not ...


 During a job interview today I was asked if I have or want children, is it legal?
One of the questions from the interviewer was 'how old are you? Do you have children? Do you plan to have?'

Is this legal? If not, what should I do?
It sounds so unfair, I ...


 Does capital punishment actually work?
or is it revenge not ...


 My cow called me an attorney?
Can I sue for slander?...


 Can you tell me why these people are asking me to receive money for free from over seas. Is it a scam?
St. Vincent de Paul,
Ozaman House, 11 celestial Avenue,
Agidingbi, Lagos.

Dear Beloved in Christ,

It is a privileged to here from God and it gives me joy to relate ...


 The smoking ban is unworkable?
What do you think? Do you think choice can be taken away so easily?

Should a more moderate legislation have been brought in?

Is this the result of a governmant that panders to ...


 Hai suppose God comes before you and grants you 3 wishes-?
-what would you ask for?...


 Im thinking of committing a crime.....any ideas?
i dont think i could bring myself to murder someone but i could probably handle pushing someone over or stealing an animal or two.

Anyone got any other suggestions? ....dont worry i'...


 Can a school legally with hold a students cell phone?
When you get your cell phone taken up at my high school, your parents have to come and get it for you. Now that I am 18, can they legally keep me from claiming my property? (not that age has ...


 Did You Hear About The Wheelchair Bound Man Who Is Making His Living Off Of Lawsuits?
This man is getting huge amounts of praise and criticism.
He goes around to business places daily and looks for violations against the disabled. When he sues he either goes to court or gets out ...


 I must be lost on the second amendment?
How does "A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed."

The way I see it ...


 Freedom of speech on Yahoo Answers what do you think?
Two days ago i posted a serious sensible question on Law crime and Punishment on Yahoo Answers?
I mentioned the word vigilante to which Yahoo removed my question from the board.
Is this PC ...


 Would you support the legalization of ferrets as pets in California?
Why or why not?
Additional Details
The law is based on a faulty claim of ferrets being able to form feral colonies. When in fact, most ferrets being sold are already spayed/neutered. M...


 Should the no-spanking law in california be passed?
I personally believe thats theres a fine line between a well deserved spanking and abuse. In the proposed law they state that even swatting your child under 3's hand would be illegal and could ...


 Why is abortion deemed...?
ok if a doctor does it, but murder if it's the result of violence to a pregnant woman who loses her fetus as a result?
Additional Details
So, it seems it'a merely according to ...


 Why are gas prices falling?
I don't want to think it's possible but I can't help but think it has to do with the upcoming election. This seems so far-fetched to me yet I can't think of anything else. Someone ...


 Should a Mother who Aborts her Baby, be allowed to sell the Baby Parts on the open Market?
Selling the parts is much less a sin than the actual abortion, so why not?
Additional Details
Hey guys, just trying to make a point. It's hypocritical to allow the abortion and not ...


 Is it wrong to 'steal' back stuff that was stolen from you?
...


 Will you be my neighbor? Could you be my neighbor? Can I borrow your ladder and lawn mower?
...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.044