Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law & Ethics

Why is Marijiuana illegal but alcohol is legal?
Find answers to your legal question.





Why is Marijiuana illegal but alcohol is legal?

I read on a site that made really interesting points about this question.

"Logically speaking, it should be the other way around. Alcohol tends to make many people aggressive, leading to a variety of violent crimes, while marijuana does not. Alcohol is a central nervous system depressant, and leads to a serious loss of
coordination and motor skills. At larger doses, alcohol renders one completely unconscious. Drunk drivers cause enormous numbers of automobile accidents and deaths. Marijuana is not a central nervous system depressant, and while one probably shouldn't drive while intoxicated on anything, it simply does not cause anywhere near the loss of motor control that alcohol does, and is only a fraction as dangerous as alcohol in terms of driving. And, a large enough dose of alcohol can and will kill you, while the same is not true of marijuana."

Your thoughts?


    




♥LA♥ Royalty
You don't pay taxes on MJ and you do on alchohol.


rainnew_tractyear3rd
Rating
Both should be illegal.


dogger
marijuana is perfectly legal - in India.

A little morning cup of bhang lasse and you are good to go!

Marijuana in India and alcohol in the US and Russia are examples of mood altering substances that are wide spread in the culture for hundreds of years. Prohibition caused a backlash in the US. Try banning mj in India, or chewing coca leaves in south america, or betel nuts in some pacific rim areas. Or tobacco.

Cultural acceptance is your answer.


honeybeejim
Rating
In America everything is about money and power


George P
i agree with you... well, slightly, i think they should both be legal, and rather than making alcohol or dope illigal, make it so if some one does somethink irrisponsible, then they should be temporerorly band from drinking alcohol or smokeing the herb.

that would be grand


Bingo
Rating
I don't smoke, but I agree.
I'd feel safer with a smoker than I would with a drinker, especially in a car!
A drunk driver can kill you.
A smoker? IF you can get him behind the wheel (not likely),
they'd probably get a ticket for going too slow!


Jerkwithhotsauce
It has to do with taxation, young sir/madam. There is already a system in place to tax alcohol. Taxing marijuana would create such a change in the system of monies that anarchy might result. It has nothing to do with the effect on the human body, but everything to do with the flow of currency. Thank you for asking.


"That One"
Because the alcohol and tobacco industries are paying our politicians a great deal of money to keep it that way.


k.beebe
Becaues everyone acts funny on marajuana and you know it, while everyone acts funny while your drunk and your completely oblivious.. make sense.. a little? I understand it is definitally more dangerous to drink than smoke, but if you were to compare the two, HEAVY drinking and HEAVY smoking, one you would pass out; the other you would most likely end up sitting in the car, trying to figure out how to turn it on, forget you were supposed to be turning it on then say forget it and get a beer.


mike p
Rating
its simple tax, not everyone can brew their own drink but any joe blow can throw some seeds in the ground and grow their own smoke


A Peter
That is depending upon the law makers.
Both are not good for the person and the society


xcorevip
Rating
I find this completely and utterly true.

I am also against the fact that Alcohol is legal while MJ is not.

Really the society needs to get their heads out of their ***'s and figure there **** out!


joemj413
Rating
Drugs are for the weak! Why not get high on knowledge and wisdom instead?


N. Cognito
It has nothing to do with the properties of either substances, or the welfare of the public. The 'illegality' of marijuana and other substances ('illegality' placed in quotes because the federal government was never granted the power to prohibit the private possession or use of ANY substance), is based in racism and corporate greed. Simply use any internet search engine to find "Anslinger Hearst DuPont Marijuana" and you should be able to easily find the whole story.


msprettyoneandonly
that's a good question


Grey Man
Well I agree with you there, but alcohol is already legal, and marijuana is not. Try making alcohol illegal, ever heard of the prohibition? Didn't work out too well. Just because one of the two evils is legal does not justify making both of them legal.


j w
Rating
i thinks its because more people drink alcohol rather then smoke weed so the government keeps alcohol legal so they can get the tax from it


????i?
From my understanding, in the USA, these rules where decided by religious groups. Christianity itself was to blame in part for advocating alcohol consumption in the for of wine. And in doing so help to generate a world wide drinking problem. This(not wanting to make the this mistake again), I believe to be part of their reason for their strong stance against any other habitually addictive substance.

P.S.Long term abuse of Marijuana has lead to deaths as well; a man in the UK this year died from this & it says so on his death certificate.


G m
Rating
It doesnt make sense.


tiger lily
Rating
its because our politicians are alchoholics.and marijiuana is legal here in cali under mecical terms only.
18 amendment didnt workout so theres your answer.


Bashar Y
Rating
Hey Listen The Both Are Bad Becuse Every One Of It Give A Big Dangrous And Always Make A Bad Men And Make A
Big Crimes And Above All Of This It Will Kill You Becuse The Most Dangrous Disease Came From It .


Adryan W
Rating
that is a good question. like andre 3000 of outkast says in one of his songs, "marijuana illegal, but cigarettes cool? i might look kinda funny, but i ain't no fool." personally, i think it's the government trying to dumb us down. marijuana, like bob marley said, makes you meditate. "it make ya rebel", he said. alcohol just makes you impared. incapacitated, unable to function. marijuana makes you feel good. the last thing the government wants us to be is under our own control. hey. think about it.


crew_fantastico
We've gotten to the point where we can't criminalize alcohol, because it's been legally accepted in our society for so long. Having said that, the last thing we need to do is to add another "legal" drug to the list.


aida
because the amount of alcohol that you take is important.but even if you use marijuana once it may cause some serious problems.but a little amount of alcohol wont hurt and i heard it good for your health even!


roze
Rating
bcoz goverment is partial


Bad bus driving wolf
I suggest you discuss this with your local policemen.
One possible reason is the ease of addictiveness of the substance, which they don't make any mention of in the passage.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Do you think capital punishment is good or bad?
...


 My mom hits me with the belt, and im 13 years old in the 8th grade...is this against the law?
She hits me on my arms, my legs, she hits me for stupid stuff too....


 How can you pass a polygraph?
Or at least make it unconclusive? Need to pass it!!!!
Additional Details
Hey Crackheads, I did not ask for judgements, just an answer, that is what this website is for right? Also do ...


 Is someone that wont take a polygraph or testify under oath guilty?
GW for example doesnt want his fellow comrads to have to testify under oath....Isnt this just admitting to guilt?
Additional Details
Polygraphs are accurate just for your information. T...


 If I saw Osama Bin Laden outside my house could I shoot him and kill him with no repercussions?
...


 If a neighbor puts up a new fence and never told you he was going to and he left some open spaces and my dog..
My dog can now get out of the yard because of what the neighbor did.What can I do that is not illegal??
Additional Details
The old fence was more on my side then his now he moved it back ...


 Do u agree with euthanasia?
Saw a program on TV on the other day about a woman that had to travel to Switzerland to a clinic to pay for her death. Do you think euthanasia should be approved in the UK?...


 Guns legal in the U.S? OUTRAGEOUS!?
We here in Australia are reading up on multitude of shooting sprees. It's unbelievably horrifying and traumatic. This can't go on. Why on earth is owning a firearm legal? It's ...


 Considering the scary random shooting in nebraska yeterday, whats keeping our govt from banning guns?
the news article about that crazy man in nebraska shooting people so that he cud be famous really scares me. i'm afraid for myself and my family cos this cud happen anywhere in the us..

...


 Punched in the face, and knocked down by drunk patient in hospital?
Just over a week ago i was just finishing my shift in work at my local hospital when i went over to use the cash machine,while i was there a drunk man came out of the A&E and walked over to me, ...


 Im a blackman i feel repressed because i cant goto the kkk meeting should i call the naacp and sue ?
...


 Who thinks Clarkson was right taking the law into his hands..I do and wish others would to.?
For too long have we had to put up with these hooligans..If the police cant deal with them WE should..
Give em a slap and send them crying to there teenage parents..
I back Jeremy clarkson 1...


 Do you think its fair?
i was in a fight with a guy from a near by school and i had a good reason to fight him......awhile back he beat up a friend of mine just because he was look at him. so fought and in the end i kicked ...


 Have you ever done something illegal without getting caught?
what do you feel about it?...


 A teacher and two students held down my son, and took his knife. Can we sue?
...


 Is it assault to burn someone with a flatiron?
I've always wondered...
Additional Details
I never burned anyone! I was just flat ironing my hair and the question came to me! G...


 Do anti-abortionists eat eggs for breakfast?
...


 Why is it illegal in Kentucky to carry an ice cream cone in your back pocket?
...


 A fitting punishment for my servant?
One of my footmen had the audacity to serve me tea with sugar in it. He is aware that I drink tea with sugar, but require the sugar bowl to be provided to me so that I can put the cubes in myself. He ...


 Why won't the goverment legalize marijuana?
It has been proved to help azthma and multiple deseases.
I still don't understand why it is illegal.
It has just about the same effects as alcohol and alcohol is legal.
Hmmmm.... ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.084