Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law & Ethics

Why is it wrong to use abortion as a method of birth control?
Find answers to your legal question.





Why is it wrong to use abortion as a method of birth control?

In a recent survey at California State University at Northridge, 96.1% said they think it is wrong to use abortion as a method of birth control.

http://str.typepad.com/weblog/files/ywam_csun_survey_071024d.pdf

I found that curious because there are so many people who are pro-choice. Apparently, there must be a lot of pro-choice people who think it's wrong to use abortion as a method of birth control. So I'm curious why the pro-choice people think that would be wrong.

Let me explain why this is a puzzle to me so you can better address my question. It seems to me that the only reason an abortion for any reason could be wrong is if the unborn is a human being with a right to life. If it's just a blog of tissue, I don't see why any justification for abortion would even be necessary, so a person ought to be able to have an abortion for any reason. It's no more immoral than having a bunyon removed. But if it is a human being with a right to life, then why be pro-choice?


    




chanel
As a method of birth control, it is wrong. Not only because no one will ever learn responsibility if that is the case.. but (from experience) and from other cases I have heard about it is emotionally damaging. But that aside, sometimes in the case of accidents or rape etc etc abortion is a better alternative than most for in Australian alone 1 in 10 children is being abused and that is worse if you ask me. Better to not give life than to give a life of hell.


Horcasitas
Why would you do something so wrong as a method as birth control when you can just use birth control pills? or condoms?


grumpyoldman
Most people are not pro abortion, even if they are pro choice. Got it?


MohawkPrincess
Rating
If its murder, then when a woman has an accidental miscarriage, is it Unintentional Manslaughter?

The baby doesn't NOT become aware of the implements being used to abort it. It has no way to see, hear, or feel at the point in gestation which abortion occurs.

I love how many people are anti-abortion, yet they can eat animals, or watch horror movies, or watch a police officer shoot someone.


ohhhdan
Rating
Being pro-choice does not mean you are pro-abortion. Pro-choice is about not letting the government decide what a woman can do with her body.

You can be pro-choice and anti-abortion. They are not mutually exclusive.


msylvester227
Okay let's see here...the question....through me way off course. I am for choice, option, it's my body, what ever is the newest, hippest, am I saying it legally politically correct for abortion. Why is my question back to you and I know you are not to answer a question with an answer but why would anyone intentionally get pregnant so they may have the option of abortion?

I am not educated past high school. I have some college credit hours but that was almost 40 years ago. Where the heck are people coming from when abortion becomes birth control?

Like I said, I am for abortion. There are alot of battered children out there alot of hungry children out there who should of never been bought into this world. The people that fathered them and gave birth to them could care less except on the 3rd of every month.


poison_my_loli_pop
Rating
Just because a person is pro-choice doesn't mean they do not have an appreciation for human life.
I am pro-choice, because I realize life is not black and white.
On the other hand, I could never imagine myself going through with an abortion, because that is just me, personally. It would be something very hard for me to deal with.

Sometimes people decide to have an abortion because they do not feel they would be bringing a baby into a safe and loving environment, and that is actually a very responsible choice. True, they could send them to an adoption agency, but that *still* does not completely ensure a child's safety physically and mentally.

When a person has a child, they had better be prepared to dedicate the rest of their life to it.

I'd like to hope that the majority of pro-choicers do not consider having an abortion so lightly as a cosmetic operation like having a bunion removed O_o

Basically the best way I can depict this sentiment is a pregnant woman wearing a shirt that says "My Choice".

I'm sure most women would try their hardest to avoid the entire ordeal of getting pregnant altogether by other means, rather than regularly having abortions.

Plus....I highly doubt that's safe, and could probably do some major damage in the long run, preventing them from having children in the future.

The majority of pro-lifers tend to be driven by concrete religious ideology...but if you'd like to do your research, *living* babies and children used to be sacrificed for strictly religious purposes, as well.
And ultimate sacrifice to prove their faith to their God.

So...I don't think it would hurt people to be a little more open minded about certain practices and the reasoning behind them.

It's a depressing sentiment, but people do die every day.


Darla
Rating
I suppose that is a bit of a conundrum, but in my opinion, an abortion is a last resort for an unwanted pregancy and should be used only as such. At the risk of sounding callous, think of it in terms of driving a car and preventing a crash....If your brakes fail, or if you're somehow distracted while driving and suddenly you're just about to crash and your brakes lock, you might pull the emergency brake.....The E brake, in that respect, is there just in case you need it....it's not an excuse not to drive safely, wear your seat belt, and maintain your car properly....again, I'm not making a moral comparison, it's just an analogy. Legal abortions are safe(r) abortions, period. Making them illegal won't stop women from getting them, it will just make them sketchy and financially unattainable for the women who probably "need" them the most. That fact is the way I (and I imagine, most rational and reasonably educated pro-choice individuals) justify my stance on that issue. I'm very fortunate that a safe, legal abortion was available for me when I was 16 and got pregnant when my boyfriend's condom broke....after my parents confiscated my birth control pills. That being said, I respect pro-life individuals....especially the ones who, coming from a "religious" or spiritual perspective, don't rush to judge and condemn others for their decisions, but rather recognize this issue, ultimately, as a personal one. No one but God knows when "life" really begins.. with a "blob of tissue" or the birth of a baby......but as a Catholic, I do believe that God is the only true judge of what is sinful or "wrong."

Bottom line..... continued, early birth control education and availability is the key, people.


cynical
I'm pro-choice. Is not the embryo I'm worry about is the woman. One, two abortions won't cause her any health injuries as long as the procedure was done by a physician. However, 5 or 7 abortions could cause severe scarring of uterine tissue. It could cause hemorrhages and cause infertility so when she does want to have a family she wouldn't. In worst cases it could cause death. Having a lot of abortions increases the possibility of health hazards. This is why planned parenthood emphasizes birth control and responsibility. Is always about the health of the woman.


A
You might also want to read up on controversial theory that legalized abortion has reduced crime rate in US. Crime rate dropped sharply in the early ninties (about 20 years after Roe vs Wade). And states that legalized abortion earlier saw more reduction in their crime rate.


Valley R
I was thinking about that. My dog is pregnant and I think I'm going to abort the unborn mass of cells. They are not puppies until they are born. And besides, it was an accident that she got pregnant anyway.


MCRisforeversavingme
Rating
because its killing someone who is inoccent and didnt do anything to deserve such a violent death. and if they r rly young, they should put them up for adoption. but u should never kill a baby.ever.


Ava
People that are pro-choice don't want to admit that it is a real human being. All they have to do is look at the pictures of what the baby looks like in the womb at the different ages. It is murder. Straight and simple.


britbrat76
THE PREGNANCY COULD BE PREVENTED WITH ANOTHER FORM OF BIRTH CONTROL. WHY WOULD ANYONE TAKE THE RISK! AN ABORTION IS NOT GOOD ON YOUR BODY. YOU MAY RUN THE RISK OF NOT BEING ABLE TO HAVE CHILDREN WHEN YOU WANT THEM LATER. ABORTIONS SHOULD BE LEFT FOR HAVE TO CASES.....THINK. HALF THE BABY BOOMERS WOULDN'T BE HERE IF ABORTION WAS BIRTH CONTROL!


Jake
I saw a video of an abortion once... the baby was backing away from the needle. He knew it was there. That doctor quit after he watched it.


Don't Taze Me Bro
Rating
98% of all scientists agree the fetus is life, thus a unbourn baby. Murder is never a justafiable fourm of birth control. NO ONE, NO WOMAN has the right to murder.


Rob in NY
Rating
At what point does the unborn child change from a "blog of tissue" as you put it, to a recognizable life? Did you know that at five weeks, a sonogram can pick up the heartbeat of the unborn child? At eight weeks, appendages such as feet and hands are noticeable. To have an abortion at these points seems to be a termination of a potential life.

Does life begin at conception? That seems to be the debate. But with this in mind, there are still state-sanctioned abortions all the way through the first trimester (12 weeks) and it does seem reckless to use this as birth control. In a manner of speaking, it isn't just control, it's total birth cessation. A bunyon is not something that has the potential to become a living creature with a will and a conscience, so that analogy leaves much to be desired.

The pro-choice argument is weak only because it denies the right to life (and the right to choose) by the unborn child.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Who else other than me thinks that everyone should be entitled to free healthcare?
I'm just absolutely enraged how much healthcare is in the US. My mother can't get essential surgery she needs because it isn't deemed necessary by her insurer. My father can't ...


 Who should pay for the damaged laptop?
I am the deputy editor of a small magazine and last week I had a shoot with a photographer, my sister and her 3 year-old daughter who was modelling a little girl's cardi for the mag. Afterwards, ...


 After asking a question about saying thank you to the USA on this site why are people ignorant to the truth?
I asked a question about the USA and thanks to their might and power the world has been a safer place for 60yrs dettering us form nazisism and communism (Both of which are doomed to corruption and ...


 Is this illegal? shredding someone else's mail?
Is this illegal? shredding someone else's mail?
i recently moved out of a house. i didn't get my adress changed yet and was still recieving mail there. the lady that rents the place ...


 Isn't it legal too... drop a baby on government property (doorstep)...?
Lets say maybe I was going to have a girl...maybe...and just maybe the "mother" does not want to have this "kid". Can’t I drop the baby on the front steps of a hospital and leave?...


 OMG WHY DOESNT DORA JUST SUE SWIPER?
If I was being stalked like Dora, I would sue. Why doesn't she? She gets stalked A LOT by him. I think he's a molester....


 How can you start a petition to keep paris hilton in jail?I'd sign it!?
...


 Is it allowed to date your sister in laws nephew?
...


 Where are my rights as a non-smoker?
I used to like restaurants but having a non-smoking section in a bar is like a no peeing section in a pool. Walking past people smoking in a building entrance, baseball games and the list goes on. I...


 Do you think abortion should be made legal?
okay arguments i've heard:
1. The preborn baby is not a living human being yet.
wrong. basic biology shows a fetus is a human being. if it's not a living human, why do 37 states ...


 Under age at a bar and was sent to the hospital for 37 stitches in my arm can i sue?
i was hit in the head with a beer bottle and sliced with the glass... can i sue... cause i heard that i can but i am affraid that it will come back on me becuse i am under age... and if i did sue ...


 Supreme Court upheld ban on partial-birth abortion. Is ban on all abortions on its way?
Just want to see what you guys think is coming next to the ballot as the slightly-conservatite court takes its next steps...
Additional Details
Note to contributor Pepper:
all those ...


 I am 37 years age and has 14 years age son. Is it wrong for me to have attraction with 16 year old girl?
I love her and want to be with her always but she is 2 years age above my son and I feel guilty. Is this wrongful?
Additional Details
also my wife is gone (she is dead) so is not ...


 Is it legal to throw the ashes of a loved one into sea without permission?
...


 Reckless driving ticket in Virginia, should i hire a lawyer?
I recently got a ticket for reckless driving by way of speeding (81/55 in Fairfax County Virginia. This is my first traffic violation but am otherwise a good driver. Should i hire a lawyer or ...


 Do you think there should be severe punishment for those men who cheat their wife?
Those men who cheat their wife and do not remain loyal to them and keep a mistress and show in front of the world that they are very good. Is there a severe punishment under Indian Law for them? What ...


 Should racism be a capital offense?
i think it should be....


 Is it legal for a police officer/detective to trick you like saying your partner already gave you up?
Is it legal for a detective to trick you like that in order to get a confession/information?...


 Is this entrapment?
Me and my co-workers are having a discussion on this: If a cop gives you a ticket for speeding and it's impossible for you to see him (he's behind a wall with his lights off, etc) then ...


 Who agrees that my method of eliminating serious crime is best?
A man's first offence, cut his John Thomas off.

A man's second offence, cut his head off.

Crime would cease to exist overnight.
Additional Details
O...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.034