Why should a father be charged for murdering a man who was raping his 2 year old daughter?

fouracesrwild

In all regards he also broke the law while protecting his daughter he should be given a medal , I would do whatever I had to do to protect my children just like him

Erica

I have not heard this story anywhere so I am voicing a jury type of opinion. You know not really knowing anything but from what you say.

First off rape is a far worse crime than justifiable murder in my eyes. I would send him on his way because he saved future children's lives.

Second, could you imagine your 2 year old being raped that would drive any man insane if he loved his child. That would drive any loving parent crazy to know that some filthy man was on their baby girl.

And third, can we really trust the court systems anymore. People get away with a lot more than rape.

I would have shot him and not blinked an eye while I did it. I would have felt no remorse whatsoever for the crime that I committed. I would not feel that it was a crime. It was justice served where it was due.

m-c

he did it the wrong way he got but i all for him --the people won't
speak up for him like thy do for rapist -and we all now why
but at lest maybe woman will --look at the man you now..are thy
any diffing than the rapist when it come to woman we need more woman in the law informant.that will help

osu2720@sbcglobal.net

As a parent I think that I would probably do the same thing, I don't think the medal is a good idea but I do think that this is a very brave man who deserves our grattitude and respect for doing something that our courts fail to do.
Our court system is too easy on criminals that attack our children maybe they should wake up and smell the coffee, or maybe they should have to explain to the little girl why the man who hurt her gets to go free and do it again in a couple of years, I'm sure it would cause them to think twice. The penalty in Turkey is death to anyone who rapes a child it's time to make that a law here.

autumnbrookblue

murder is murder no-one has the right to take a life. the only time anyone can legally murder anyone is in combat. sorry about his 2year old being raped I'd want to kill him too I think he deserved to loss his life however the father still comminted the crime and should be willing to do the time.

corvuequis

Yes he should be charged for in the very least manslaughter but no jury would ever convict him.

misspoetluver

well I can get why the did it but voilance never solves anything it just makes things worse and killing isn't good no matter the purpose

m b

b/c that is the way it always goes...

yahoo answers son of a gun

look at Locke's social contract and see that by using the government's services, you agree to abide by its laws and allow it to prosecute and punish crime. that right is given up when you are a part of society with a governemnt

answerer

Because he murdered someone. An "eye for an eye" mentality is not totally our legal system however if you believe in it, they still use it in the Middle East.

tnagew

Have you ever had an Adrenalin dump. You don't think, you don't reason, you just react, you're totally out of control. As far as the justice system, so many times it comes down to MONEY. Who's got the best attorney. And hell weren't the police terrified in New York a couple of years ago when they thought a man had a weapon and shot at him some 30 times hitting him 14 times while in an apartment complex. What happened to them. There's allot more out there!

fastily1

He really shouldn't go to jail. Anybody would be real pissed if they saw that happening to their child.

Legally if the father did not catch him in the act before or during
he can not be charged for defending his family. But if i would have caught him i would have F***** him up. and then turned him in.

breeze1

If the father caught the man raping his 2 year old daughter he has the right to protect her. That's not murder in my state. It comes under the right to protect yourself and others around you. It is reasonable to assume that a grown man would kill a two year old, or do serious bodily harm in that situation.

Hobo

He acted in the heat of the moment he didn't mean to kill him because he wasn't thinking straight and I think he shouldn't go to prison either...

misspipik

otherwise there would be anarchy in the streets

snizzleborfin

Because he got caught, not because he did it. If it had been me, they would have never found his body!!

baalberith11704

Because someone obviously committed a crime-murder. When a crime has been committed it is the prosecuter's duty to charge the suspect. It is then up to the grand jury and/or jurors at the trial to decide if he should be tried/convicted/punished.

mrklcoac2002

"dad" took the law into his own hands and didn't let the legal system handle him. i completely agree if he was convicted in court of his punishment but NO1 can take the law into their own hands

newyorkgal71

I agree!

Ice

He took a life. No justification. What if he believed the guy had or was raping his 2 year old, killed him, then found out he actually wasn't. OOOOPS! Oh well, he thought he was. This nonsense is just that, nonsense. If we extrapolate that kind of thinking depending on who is in charge then an animal rights activist could claim justification for cutting the head off of a child who happened to be pulling on a puppy's tail. We have laws and courts for a reason. We wouldn't be a civilized society if we didn't. No one should get a medal for intentionally taking another human life. We as a species need to grow up.

Mica

He should not be charged. He should be commended. He not only rid the world of slime but helped out the taxpayers by not forcing us to house this loser in prison and pay for his trial etc.

Lipstick

He shouldn't be...today if somebody comes into your home you can blow them away, you can blow away somebody in the street if you feel threatened....if dad's going to prison for protecting his child, that's just messed up.

smiling sam

Are you nuts? He heard a rumor and killed a man for it, that's why.

~EDIT~
Wacko, he didn't mean to kill him??? Did you read how many times he stabbed the guy in the chest?

Enter Your Message or Comment

User Name:
User Email:
Post a comment: