Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law & Ethics

Will/Should I be charged for shoplifting?
Find answers to your legal question.





Will/Should I be charged for shoplifting?

Hypothetical: While shoplifting a $20 CD at Circuit City, the store got held up by three armed men and I was able to help the Security Guard along with another shopper to jump the three men.

While jumping the robbers, the CD fell out and fell to the floor which everyone saw, including the guard.

I didn't (or try to) leave the store as yet so will/should I be charged for shoplifting?
Additional Details
Mike M - Spoken like a TRUE defense attorney.


    




captainbluey
No. If you had not left the shop, then no crime had been committed. Intent to steal must be proved. You were still on the premises, and the potential to pay for the product is still aparent.


Mike M
Sounds like you had the CD in your hand when the incident occurred and you put the CD in your pocket to free up that hand to help the guard.


zipzeronada
No, you will not be charged because you didn't leave the store without paying for it,


Sweetharttt
Rating
No, you would not be charged. You did not walk out of the store with the CD.


mhmd
Rating
They can't prove that you intended to leave the store without paying for the CD unless you disabled the security feature on the CD for example.


Who holds up a Circuit City?

They do almost nothing in Cash Sales, which would be distributed in a10 registers in the store and all the inventory is in a stock room that's not easily accessible from the inside of the store.

All they would be able to get away with is some dummy cell phones and floor model TVs


Ami
No, for all they know, you were just holding it


Alex C
Technically not till you leave the store, but you'd probably be barred from the shop or reported


waitingand hopeing
No you can always say i am going to pay for it,,But once you leave the store you can be charged and you can also be arressted... I should know my ex is a cop...


That guy your mommy talks about.
yes.. u probably still willl even tho u never left the store... u still might.


INSOMNIAC
If you were not arrested at the time you will not be charged.~


Crystal E
yes


Ron R
legally you havn't attempted shoplifting untill you attempt to pass the check out....until that time you can put merchandise an bags, pockets, and even eat it in a grocery store,...just make sure to keep the sticker if you eat it though


AlexM
Rating
technically, if u didnt leave the store with the CD u shouldn't be charged, but if u did end up leving the store with the CD hidden, that would mean shoplifting. It's almost like if u walk around the store, with an item hidden attempting to shoplift but u decide on better judgement not to steal it and put it back, it wouldn't be considered shoplifting


Touch of Red
Rating
if you actually did help stop the place from being robbed i doubt they would turn around and charge you.


soccerstar2010
Prob not, but idk??


Danielle
Rating
Possibly. If they saw if fall out of your pocket or whichever, then yes they have a right to charge you. The fact of the mater is whether or not the will due to the hold up that they had. They simply may have forgotten or have too much to deal with the robbers already.


lildizzie
Thats like saying. I helped out a women who is about to get raped does that now give me right the right to rape her?

Answer is no.


Bina
Rating
No
Make your Favorite Answer Please!!!





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 I handed in my notice - which should be a week as stated on my contract and my employer asked me to help a lit
tle longer - four weeks - im now two weeks into my notice and my car breaks down. my employer calls me and says get a taxi - which i cant afford and tells me im not filling my contract and that im ...


 Is it legal if I'm getting a divorce that my wife changes the lock on the house...?
I was told I had to move out and find an apartment and she would pay the entire mortgage on the house. I signed the lease and then she changed her mind and said I had to pay half the mortgage ...


 Why does our court system allow so many frivolous lawsuits to be successful?
I can't believe so many people get away with suing over such petty stuff like emotional damages and punitive damages for the most absurd stuff like the lady that spilled hot coffee on her lap ...


 Is Nancy Pelosi guilty of sedition or treason, using these definitions:?
Treason. A breach of allegiance to one's government, usually committed through levying war against such government or by giving aid or comfort to the enemy. The offense of attempting by overt ...


 I have been sacked over an allegation that was not true, they had no proof if allegation is true but sacked me?
i was accused of smoking weed in my van, I smoke in own time but not my company's, I smoke nearly every day but only a little which i admitted to employer, They sent me to a medical doctor where ...


 The cat is mine and has accidentally been locked in. if i break in i may be in trouble or not i dont know?
...


 Is the Death Penalty more costly than life in prison?
Check the title....


 How many People No the Law other than smoking Pot,and speeding~?
...


 Have you ever been to Hell, Michigan?
I got lost yesterday going to my granddaughter's Cheerleading Invitational and drove thorugh Hell at 7:00 a.m. Let me tell you that the road to Hell is REALLY bumpy. For real....


 What if one half of Conjoined twins commits a murder?
If a conjoined twin was to pick up a knife and stab someone and there were witnesses present would the innocent twin be forced to go to prison, or would the guilty twin get away with it? - Are there ...


 How can you get the government (Homeland Security) to tap your telephone?
I have heard a tape running sound on my home telephone service many times. Sometimes I hear a clicking noise. I have even heard it sound like someone was hitting keys on another line when I KNEW no ...


 Why is alcohol legal but cocaine isn't?
One initially assumes its obvious why drugs are illegal - they are bad for you. But how is this any worse than alcohol?
Acohol and cocaine both have huge social impacts.
They both change ...


 Is it illegial to be at a party with underage drinking and drugs or just to participate in them?
please only for sure ...


 How do you opt OUT of being an organ donor?
...


 Would you support an alcohol crackdown?
Binge drinking is a major problem in the United Kingdom and I believe something should be being done about it...

#1 The minimum drinking age in the UK should be increased to 21 years.
...


 Should it be legal to schmack stupid people?
I say yes. Maybe if we hurt these cats enough... they'll either wise up, or shut up....


 Is It Legal and/or Ethical For an Employer to place Surveillance Cameras Inside Their Employee's "Breakroom"?
In this Employee Breakroom, no work is performed and there is no merchandise that can be stolen. This is where employees take their "10 minute breaks" and lunches.

I believe this ...


 If you are born in America from two American citizens are you a citizen at birth or you not till your 18.?
...


 Why didn't Reps out right banned abortion when they could?
They've never had more power than they did under Bush. If they didn't do it then, could they ever do it? or are they just being hypocritical about it....


 After my mother's death my brother claimed her house as his own [she died intestate]. Can he do this?
...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.014