Would i get in trouble if i stabbed somebody who was trying to break into my house?

Michelle

If you used excessive force to defend yourself from the burglar, you could be charged with assault or attempted murder. Or a few other things. But, yes, you could face criminal prosecution for hurting someone disproportionate to how much they could hurt you. It would be up to what a DA would be willing to charge you with and what a jury is going to swallow in terms of culpability and just cause.

Legend

If someone is trespassing, you are allowed to defend yourself and your property. This does not mean chase him down the street with a shotgun or "finish him" when the trespasser is down.

helper

what you do cant has to be less then what they do. If they have a gun then you can stab. You cant shoot unless they have a gernade and so forth.

hispanicboi415

I dont think you would, because he would be breaking and entering and once they are in a private property like your house you are pretty much free to do anything to them i think. As long as they are the ones breaking in and you are defending yourself or trying to protect your house. not sure tho.

conspiracy_secrets_coverups

Ok in the STUPID LAW COUNTRY, UNITED KINGDOM...

If you stabbed someone with the knife they were planning to stab you to death with so they can steal your stuff, and they live, you will get sued for damages.
If you Killed them in self defence you would prob have a worse prison sentence than they would have had.

I have figured out a way of killing off all criminals, it is to be taken on as Dictator of a country, and then just kill them off. No one will dare to say anything against.... If they do, they are next!

You have to remember this is california, and you could get into trouble. Now Texas, that's a whole different story. I wish we had the Castle law here.

The castle law â€“ gives people the right to use whatever means necessary to protect themselves and their property without fear of civil liability. In other words it protects you from being sued.

"You hear someone stealing something off your front porch. You come out there with a gun, and they're running off. It's nighttime. The law in Texas allows you to shoot them," said former Dallas County prosecutor Toby Shook.

"In 25 years, I've never known a Harris County court to prosecute a homeowner or businessman for killing a burglar or robber," Harris County Assistant District Attorney Bill Delmore told legislators. "We don't do that."

Don't you wish you lived in Texas?

yakitismak

well if someone was trying to break in your house and you stabbed them while they were trying. no you probably will not get into trouble. now it is better if it happened while in your house. the fact that they are outside brings many more problems into the equation. as long as it is reasonable, for the most part I is rare to see any one indicted on this issue. again as long as it is reasonable. like if you dont chase them down then stabb them..

Samara H

cant do it in his back. if he's in front of you , and your protecting yourself then yes. but if you see someone walking OUT of your house and your not in danger, then you'll get in trouble

chris

Yes, you would get busted if you did that in Australia.
As for the rest of the world, I'm not sure.

lizette o

I do not think you would but it would be better to be informed by your local Police Department. Some states have different city ordenances that can differ. Honestly a gated community does not really gives you more security. It could be an advantage if it is used properly but does not mean your safety. Once is never safe enough, using adequated security measures are always a plus.
Having a good door and window locking system and an alarm system may deter someone to tresspass your area. I personally, would defend myself and my family regardless of the outcome. I would not use a knife since I own firearms. Remember, better judged by 12 than carried by 6

Noelle

If the person is actually inside your property, you can act in self-defense. On the front porch, in the yard, while at a window, that is probably going to get you into trouble somehow.

They can sue you for damages, even if they were trespassing. If they die, their relatives can sue you. If that happens, it's up to the court who gets into trouble.

If someone was trying to get in who lives with you, and you locked them out, yeah, you can get in trouble for that. If law enforcement is breaking in, yes, you can get in big trouble for that.

squaregraysmilingfaceyadefault

If they broke into your house it's okay to defend yourself by stabbing or shooting them. However, if you only THOUGHT they were trying to break into your house and you hurt them like that, you better drag their sorry butt inside after you do that to them so it would seem justified...
Not really....I'm so bad.
Why are you asking this?

T S

now adays you could get sued by the criminal even when the best of evidence shows you had every right to protect yourself....use judgement for these type of decisions,is it worth it,reprocussions,after affects like emotional trauma.

joshdubie

it depends on where u live
i live im mass its filled with ******* who think common sense should come after being nice to everyone.

my cuzins in texas say if someone goes on ur property after dark u can shoot them dead. mainly because Texas is a mans state not run by *******

DaveNCUSA

It really depends on the laws of your state. In some states, you could shoot to kill if he makes entry.

wannagodaty

If you think you are in danger then it's not your fault since you are only defending yourself from a criminal. But try to scare him off first. If it did not worked or he tries to attack you, then you have all the right to use deadly force.

nallworth

it depends on some things..if the person was smaller than you an not armed and you shot him then I would suggest you might get into trouble..also it depends on what country you live in and the laws that govern your state..perhaps ring legal aid and ask them for free legal advice..

BeauBiker

I think if it's a liberal Democrat breaking into your house and you stab him you get a reward! If a Democrat broke into my house he would not have to worry about being stabbed he would be blown away!

timetraveller2000

This is commonly known as the 'Make My Day' law and several states within the US have this on the books. Colorado and Oklahoma come to mind.

However, it is your duty to protect you home and family. Regardless of what the law or police say. If you're not willing to do what is necessary, then of what good are you?

I don't know. Stabbing is a bit too violent for self-defence, I'd just knock him out.
I think it can still be considered a crime, because how do you know the burglar is going to harm you like that?

Enter Your Message or Comment

User Name:
User Email:
Post a comment: