Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law & Ethics

Would you sacrifice your life for 10 random strangers?
Find answers to your legal question.





Would you sacrifice your life for 10 random strangers?

you're in a burning building in which 10 people are trapped; you have the opportunity to put it out but it will cost you your life. would you do it? you don't know these people and have no idea of their ages or life history or anything, all you know is that they don't want to die. is your life worth 10 people's you'll never meet?


    




Sarah S
yes I would do it for that reason but not for the reasons will smith had in seven pounds


Ryan
Rating
Right now, yes. I think all lives are precious. I'd put my life on the line even for an innocent animal. Now knowing them is a good thing in fact, cause it makes me not judge them.

The reason I said right now yes, is cause right now I'm single and no family to speak of really. If in years to come, I do have responsibility on my shoulders I doubt I'd be bold enough to do it. But as humans, we are supposed to be humane to each other, thats what a civilization is all about. So maybe if I do it today, some else will do it tomorrow.

:)


IgnoranceIsYou
Tough question. Maybe is the best I can do. I'd like to think I'd do the noble thing, but if none of the ten were competing with me to do it, I'd have to think about it.


Taylor C
No. My evolutionary instincts are not overwhelmed by socialistic thinking.


iQ
Rating
One time, a person did the same thing on 9/11they were running up, saving people while he was giving up his life and knew it.

I would do that because to sacrifice one life, to save ten. That is just worth it.
"i'm not doing this to be a hero, but because peoples lives are at stake. And if one person can give up their life to save more, then thank God for them. They can live a longer life.".

-Firefighter from 9/11


Shay L
Rating
I would not do that....


THUG LIFE
Rating
No, I'd sacrifice 10 random strangers for myself...unless one of them was a hot chick.


taniaess
That's Jesus' job..... ~_~


somathus
I would like to think so, but no one REALLY knows how they will act until they are actually in that situation. Everyone else is either lying or selling themselves short.


cmdrbnd007
Rating
Self-preservation is a powerful thing. It takes a special kind of person to run into a burning building. I don't think I could do it. However, if it was my family then I think I could.


thebigm57
Rating
I would have a moral obligation to save them, however ethically speaking I wouldn't as per the other answer: I d/k who the folks are and d/k weather they're worthy of being saved/rescued or not. If the people I save turn out worthless dregs upon society than am I better off being burned by saving them?


Tam
Rating
Probably not, I mean why is their life more important. What if a person in there is a serial killer, a stupid person who then goes drunk driving and kills a family, etc. No way, not worth it. I don't wanna save the lives of someone who could be a rapist, torture animals, ruin peoples lives.


lantern swinger
Is my life worth those 10? Depends on who you ask. Ask my mother, and the answer is pretty obvious.

Would I do it? Only if I knew I would be able to save them, and not just be number 11. But who really knows until the time comes. I'd probably sit there and analyze how to "best" go about it for so long that it would be too late.


roflcopter
Rating
yes


Bobby B
Rating
If i was a fireman yes because i would have probably signed a contract saying i would do so

but since i`m more of a water guy **** that


understanding12
yes, but it'll probably be more instinct.


beth l
Rating
No. What would my children do without a mother? That affect 3 ppl I do know and love. Not to mention my husband, parents, students and friends.


darth8hayabusa
Rating
No, sorry burning people. From a utilitarian view, its the right choice. But from an independent will to survive perspective, I won't do it if my loss of life is PROMISED.


daniellejaramillo@ymail.com
Umm let me think about........NO





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Is it legal for someone in your home to throw away your things?
i am 20 years old and i live with my parents. i have moved back with my parents and things have been really rocky. i never really had a good relationship with them. i came home one night with a lot ...


 How much does it cost to bribe a police officer in the UK?
...


 If my friend killed someone by accident,and I didnt turn him to police,What is my penalty?

Additional Details
this is for my business ethics class.it is about the movie "end game".thanks to everyone who responded...some of u should calm down......


 I shot my neighbors car?
I was trying to kill this stray dog in my neighborhood but I shot my neighbors car instead. I don't really have enough money to pay for it. He doesn't know it was me as he is at work and I ...


 If someone does not pay child support what is going likely happen to him?
...


 Drink driving law change, anyone agree?
I think that drinking and driving should be made illeagal alltogether. Why when it is so obvious that alchohol affects some people sooner than others and vice versa, don't they just say no one ...


 If it is all about women's choice, why do they come after men for child support?
They freely gave up the booty, they get to decided (despite what the man might want) to either have or murder the unborn child. IMHO, if that is the way it is, men should not be liable for child ...


 Oh my God What do you think???Why do men lie so much?
i was just reversing my 26 ft camper into my father in laws front garden while my husband directed me in.Everything was fine i had it backed in nice and straight and my husband was at the back of it ...


 Is Punching a girl in the ovaries essentially equal to kicking a guy in the balls?

Additional Details
But what if I punch really hard? If a guy getskicked in the balls his babies are KILLED! So wouldn't it be reasonable to kills some of her babies in response?...


 Would you move into a house where a murder happened?
...


 Should I represent myself in my DUI case?
I got a dui in California and blew .11 on the breathalizer. Blood was also drawn when I got to the station. I went to court today and the judge URGED me to get a laywer or represent myself since my ...


 Police wont do anything about neighbours blocking my drive with drop kerb access what can i do next???????????
two doors down is creating problems for me to have access to my drive way. she pulls so close to my neighbours drive my neighbour ends up half way over mine. i have asked her to pull her car back but ...


 This person has been harassing me for months...? any advice?
he slashed the tires on my car and threatened to kill me and my kids. he missed court cause he went to the state hospital. I am still turning in evidence on him. no court date yet. he is trying to ...


 Noisy neighbors?
I have noisy neighbors over me, and I have talk to them about it, but it keeps happening. Noise all day and night long. I especially have an issue with the running child, now 2 running kids. They ...


 How can you tell the difference between a good person and a bad person?
www.yahoo....


 If someone dies or gets murdered in a home does the owner have to tell a buyer?
if i bought a house that i knew that someone died in from getting killed would I have to tell the prospective buyer this and if so why?

And also what if i bought it and rented it out, ...


 If you could change 1 law (or a series of related laws) what would it be?
I would change every age thing (drinking, smoking, voting) to 21. except keep driving and joining the military at same age.
Additional Details
I would especially change the voting age ...


 Legal to kick out a 18 year old girl?
I've been forced to live with her and her mother due to our having only this apartment.
Anyways, thanks God, she got into a car accident and died, and the house is under her and my name, ...


 Should smoking marijuana be illegal?
alcohol has worse effects on your body than pot does, but it's legal. i don't get it.......


 Is this illegal??????? please help?
Is it illegal for a cop to give someone a BAC test (blood alcohol consumption test) 3 1/2 hours after observing the person drive, and then trying to accuse the of DUI.

i live in PA if that ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.044