Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law & Ethics

YES OR NO Should the Patriot Act finally be abolished?
Find answers to your legal question.





YES OR NO Should the Patriot Act finally be abolished?

When will the American people be given back there rights?


    




iiidontknowdoyou
Absolutely with out a doubt YES!!!


fairly smart
Yes, it should. I wish I knew when, somen has to have the balls to get rid of it. If it has to be a woman to do it then that is okay too.


N. Cognito
Yes, it should be rescinded and those who passed it should be tried for treason.


mirozel17
YES!


john_holliday_1876
Rating
It should never have been passed in the first place. Abolish it NOW!


smedrik
Yes, what disturbs me the most is that the majority of the people who passed the aforementioned wretched piece of legislation didn't even have the decency to read it.

And for Rick K, you have lost the right to due process. Which is the most important right we can have. Without the right to due process you have no fair and balanced means of defending your other rights. The patriot act, allows the entire judicial system to be circumvented, rendering it entirely useless.


John C
Rating
YES,

To the guy that wants to know what rights we have lost try the right against illegal search and seizure for one.

I have the right to not have anyone spy on me without probable cause. This peice of legislation opened the door for the government to spy on its own people. They barely used it to find terrorists. Over time people have found more evidence that the government was spying on its own citizens more that diligently searching for terrorists.


chris37mtx
Yes it should be but the goverment and the people who work for the state and goverment will never let it be abolished because it lets them spy on anyone that they want and it lets them do whatever they want without any worry about peoples rights or if they are right or wrong it gives them complete control over you and everyone that you know.


Cre-Ve
Rating
Definitely. I'm tired of the government infringing upon the rights of Americans as a whole. Someone previously asked to name ONE right that we have been taken away from us. Well the people whos right has been taken away from them can't be here on the internet to write about it. They are being locked up in prisons without cause, they don't have the right to a trial, they are being tortured without cause. Just because some people don't see those happening to them or their family doesn't mean that its not happening to honest citizens of this country.

Check out the link i have below.

" In the six-month report of December 16th to June 15th there were 1,076 reported claims of civil liberty or civil rights complaints related to the US Patriot Act. Thirty-four were deemed credible according to the Inspector General's office and would be examined.

Some of the abuses included, abusive language, cruel and unusual behavior, and abusive treatment. One detainee had a loaded gun held to his head while being transported, another was forced to remove his shirt and ordered to shine his guard's shoes. Sleep deprivation, torture, and beatings were also reported. "


Mo
Rating
Yes, we did just fine under our original bill of rights and Constitution. This other hocus pocus was drafted simply as a way to scare us into letting the Bush Administration do as they please with our Money. Remember, code Red? Still laughing over that.


Bog-man
Rating
Well, I say yes too;

Now look at all these answers and ask yourself whether we are truly living in a DEMOCRACY!


iakonapa
Rating
As a Republican who believes in less gov't control, yes it should.


redbeardthegiant
It should have been named The Facist Enabling Act !

When Asscroft, Gonzalez, and Shrub say that they can grab a US citizen in the US, with no warrant or charge, deny them all contact with lawyers or courts, and take them out of the country, it is time to change that miserable excuse for a law.

H. Beam Piper wrote a book, Lone Star Planet, which is very well worth reading.....

Wake up people ! Himmler would have thought he had gone to heaven if he were given such powers.

Even if you think Shrub in an honorable man [and if so, I have some property (note I do not say "land") in Florida to sell you], there is absolutely NO guarantee that in future we will have only moral and ethical people in power.
Does nobody remember just how far over the line J. Edgar Hoover went ? Do people think we will NEVER again have such swine in a position of power ?

Had Hoover had the Putrid Act with which to work, MLK2 would surely have been hauled off somewhere and disposed of quietly, or simply kept incommunicado until he died. Does anyone think that would have been a good idea ?
What would Nixon have done with it ? Would Sam Irvin have gone off for a nice long Gitmo vacation ?

How about Richard J. Daley [the Elder] ? Think Chicago '68. Huey Long ?

What is REALLY scary about the Putrid Act is that they had it ready to go when 9/11 happened; this is not a law put together in a hurry.
Someone wrote it and had it in the file waiting for some excuse to enact it. That should scare the Hell out of us all. Someone was looking forward to gutting the Constitution. Someone in government.

Canada is too cold for me, but Australia is pretty nice. I love my country, but divorce does happen.

Next, let's talk about RICO....


Muledancer
Yes, it should be abolished. Additional rights have not yet been taken away, but that law certainly provides for that very action.


Barry C
Sometime after the first Tuesday in November of this year you can start planning on it :)


james k
i don't like the dept of homeland security. i would like to see that part of the patriot act, (if it was a part of it), re done.

you never approach a problem by building bigger more intrusive government. the dept of homeland security is going to create more problems than it solves.


FRAGINAL-NOYPI
Rating
The Patriot Act can only be abolished if it is proven that it is unconstitutional and against public order.


Alan S
Rating
YES in big red letters. The ACLU is slowly picking away at it to re-coup what was taken, there are several legal actions in the works right now. Anyone that contends that we haven't lost any rights has there head as far up their butt as GWB.


PAYAK
I don't think they should even let the Patriot's play anymore. It's just not fair! But Congress should not be the one's deciding that.


outlaw64
Rating
no its there for a darn good reason


smiley_face_boxers
NO, Welfare and medicaid should be abolished. Jesus Christ it is 2008 and how long ago was welfare created?

Was it Hoover, Truman, or Roosevelt?

Work or die you poor, uneducated, @#$%'s!!!


Rick K
Rating
No, it should not be abolished.

And we have not lost any of our rights!

Name me one right which you have lost?

Just one?

If you can.

EDIT: smedrik said that we have "have lost the right to due process."

There is actually a hint of truth to that, as derived from the Padilla case.

But that was corrected, albeit too slowly, by the courts. There was one similar case, I believe, but both have been corrected, and it has not happened again.

So that right, while, briefly endangered, has been restored in full.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Do narcs have to tell you they are narcs if asked?
hey i was wondering is a (marijuana) narc required to tell you that they are associated with law enforcement if asked....my friend says they have to but i think hes full of shi t....anyone know? ...


 Should there be a pedophile register?
yes or no?...


 Is limewire illegal?..........?

Additional Details
i just want to know b4 i do it.
what if i check that box that says only allow me to download music the copyright holder will allow me to?...


 What are your views on abortion?
Do you believe it to be wrong or right. When do you think it should be allowed if at ...


 What would you do?
what would you do if you saw a friend stealing something off a mutual friend? neither the victim of the perpetrator know that I saw this, but I feel he shouldn't get away with what he's ...


 If I live with some, do i have rights to their property?
My friends dad has some woman living with him (g/f). What rights does she have to the house he shared with his deceased wife??
Additional Details
Hi, UK & no my friends not a ...


 .I have made a will leaving my house and money to my lover will my wife and daughter have any claims?
...


 Are you required by the Constitution to have a driver's license in order to drive on public roads?
I have wondered before if you really need the approval/permission of the government/state in order to drive a privately owned vehicle on public roadways. I have found several references both in S...


 "If" the Government banned guns would you turn yours over?
...


 Do you think the Americans have the right to jail a harmless UK computer nerd Gary McKinnon?
Gary McKinnon was arrested in 2002 following charges by U.S. prosecutors that he illegally accessed 97 government computers -- including Pentagon, U.S. army, navy and NASA systems --I do not believe ...


 Should the gov't legalize marijuana?
With the US economy in a recession, do you think it's a good idea for the gov't to legalize marijuana? I can see pros and cons of legalizing, but do you think taxing it will benefit the ...


 Vick made a plea bargain with federal prosecutors, now county prosecutors want him. Is it double jeopardy?
...


 What is the law regarding pay when working christmas eve?
am sure if u work christmas eve past a certain time u are supposed to be paid more?
Additional Details
i know its not a bank hol - just thought u got paid extra if u worked past a ...


 Can I sue my Husband's parents for having him?
Get me my attorney....


 Why do grocery stores throw out old food and not give it to the poor?

Additional Details
The food is not spoiled people. My sister worked in a grocrey store and she told me that even non perishable goods are thrown out after 3 months cuz the companies ...


 I got a ticket and...?
well its been about 6 months since i got this ticket and it didnt have a fine to pay it just said court it was for driving trough someones yard ( didn't even leave a mark just flattened grass) ...


 Do you believe there should ever be times when Freedom of Expression should be limited?
What do you think?...


 Is the death penalty society's correct response to murder?
Society lives by symbols.
The money in your pocket has no real value, it is a symbol of value.
The death penalty is a symbol of society's values. It says there are some crimes so ...


 Are the names Hitler and Hussein synonyms with evil?
If yes, why are children taken from parents for naming their children after Adolf Hitler, but okay to elect a person as a President of a country with the name Hussein?

http://www.nj.com/...


 I know someone who is working here illegally, whats worse is that his son is a right crook/thug.?
Would u report them and anyone got any clues as to how i report them?...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.024