Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law & Legal Jobs

Civil or criminal help please ?
Find answers to your legal question.





Civil or criminal help please ?

Mary Smith is a medical assistant who works for Dr. Jones. She receives a call from Trudy Hoover, a long-time patient of Dr. Jones who is complaining of pain. Trudy states that her pain began in her neck and is so severe that she cannot go to work, and is unable to care for her children. She further tells Mary that she’s miserable and is unable to get out of bed. Trudy asks for some pain medication to give her relief. Mary explains to Trudy that Dr. Jones is attending a medical conference and will not be in the office until later in the afternoon. Mary tells Trudy that she will page Dr. Jones and get back in touch with her as soon as possible.

Mary proceeds to page Dr. Jones, but is not able to get in touch with him after several attempts. Mary then reluctantly calls Trudy back to inform her that she couldn’t reach Dr. Jones. Trudy immediately starts crying and begins begging for pain medication, stating she simply “cannot suffer another minute” with the extreme pain. Since Trudy has been a patient of Dr. Jones for some time, Mary decides to call the pharmacy and order a new medication for her on behalf of Dr. Jones. She feels comfortable in doing this as it is the same medication and dose Dr. Jones has prescribed in the past for Trudy.

Later that day, Dr. Jones comes to Mary and demands to know what happened with Trudy Hoover as she’s been rushed to the ER after experiencing what appears to be an anaphylactic reaction.
After arriving at the ER, Trudy was found to be in respiratory failure and intubated. She was transferred to the ICU where she eventually died.




Explore this case further. What type of case is this: civil or criminal? Why?
If this is a civil case, what type of tort it is? Why?
If this is a criminal case, would it be a felony or a misdemeanor? Why?
Discuss the scope of practice issues involved with this case.
Discuss what actions Mary could have taken to avoid this situation.
Under the principle of Respondeat Superior, could Dr. Jones be held liable for Mary’s actions? Why or why not?
Would the Good Samaritan law apply here? Why or why not?


    




runescape nerdz
Rating
civil
Because she did not intend to kill her.


RWR
No, yes and no.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 What constitutes being "hired" in Missouri?
I was offered a job and given the companies packet of paperwork to fill out. Benefits, payroll, etc. The hiring manager said he would get backs with me regarding a drug test. When he called back, ...


 Appeal against dismissal. Job already filled!!?
I was dismissed from my job for gross misconduct on Tuesday 4 November. I have 7 days to appeal, so the time hasnt run out. I am going to appeal as I dont agree with the decision.

However I...


 Becoming a lawyer??????
how do i do it,
whats involved

what branches are there?

what do i need as a vce/hsc score

just tell me everything you know

please :)
Additional ...


 Are there any jobs out there that are similar to being a lawyer, but do not require obtaining a law degree?
I would love to be a lawyer, and I feel I would be good at it. The only thing is I do not have the time or money to go to school to get my law degree. I am planning on getting my masters and ...


 What do I do about this?
I was drug tested (passed) and given and employment packet to fill out, then the job was given to someone else. What are my options here? Legally of ...


 Polygraph question..A career im looking foward to trying out for requires a polygraph test i have no problem?
telling the truth but its not really the truth it monitors its like your heartbeat and stuff and sometimes im asked any normal question my heart beat goes faster and ive always had a fast paced ...


 Can I still sue? If so what kind of lawyer...To: Lawyers or law school students?
When I was working as a baker for a supermarket I burnt my chin and neck bad due to the unsafe work conditions I had to work with. Its been about 2months and since then I've quit fed up w/ their ...


 How do I start my medical law essay?
...


 What kind of job can I get with a ABAA?
What kind of job can I get with a Associates in Business Administration?
please help.
Additional Details
Just a brief list of the top jobs if you can....


 Law question....................
Involuntary dissolutions of a corporation may be initiated by the state where a corporation is incorporated. For what reasons would a state initiate dissolution and who else can initiate involuntary ...


 Help anybody know of a good criminal deffense lawyer ?
im in need of a lawyer asap. any suggestions in the 46201 area code or the surrounding area ...


 Burqaa in the UK why is it legal?

I am from a country which is considered Islamic and every time i visit the UK i see tons of women wearing Burqaa in the streets of England and I find that disgusting and insulting to the B...


 Career paths in law i need help?
what course do you start of to become a solicitor and what if you dont meet your colleges entry requirements on alevel law can you study law at a lower ...


 Is an LLM in Intellectual Property or Taxation more Useful if you want to work in international business law?
I'm considering completing an LLM after I finish my JD... thing is it takes time and money and I wonder which will make it easier to find a position? What type of work would I expect with each ...


 Legal writing help!!!?
i need to write a new client letter and i really need help getting started. Please help. I'm supposed to write to a highly educated woman nancy nelson who wants to deal with attorneys on a very ...


 Can an indian lawyer practice in australia?
what can he do so that his degree will be recognized in australia? are there any exams to take, like amc exams for doctors? will he need further study?...


 Need a legal opinion on this below letter.?
Application of dissolving Marraige:-

I advice that the registar has made an order dissolving your marriage in the court. The order does not come into the force until onemonth from the date ...


 Police officers and job outlook?
Thinking about switching careers and just wondering if any current or potentially new police officers have noticed any change in job demand because of the current recession we are in. Specifically, ...


 Is it legal for these people to hire me?
ok i am 13 i live in michigan and one of our good friends owns a bu and sell shop and i was wondering can i work heir legally and get paid i really need the money and they like us as friends alot
...


 Legal advise anyone or should i contact the post office?
after the lawyer says the checks in the mail from 2 cities away how long should i wait till i call him to say it never showed ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.014