Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Law & Legal Jobs

Is this overreacting....?
Find answers to your legal question.





Is this overreacting....?

Apparently somone's lunch at work was taken from fridge and this person has made a big deal out of it taking it to HR requesting either the quilty contractor be fired or employee be written up. HR condones of it. Is it overreaction or normal to fire or write up? It was just lunch.

Rumors are quite abit is being stolen.
Additional Details
I didnot steal. I do not eat other's people's cooked food as I am a veg. Meat was stolen.


    




michr
Rating
if someone will steal a lunch what won't they steal?

over-reacting? probably but HR has to take it seriously it is their job to deal with issues that affect the "human resources" (employees)


crazyme
Rating
if they know who stole the lunch then yes fire them sorry but a thief is an thief and maybe that's all they had to eat for that day. if you don't want to loose your job then don't steal from someone plain and simple

in saying if you dont want to get fired i was not talking about you it was just in general who ever steals period.


tkquestion
That's not an over-reaction. Lunch or otherwise, a personal item that was CLEARLY known it wasn't his/hers was taken. If it was done by an outside person, such as a contractor, such a dishonest and socially unacceptable person should be banned from having a business with the company. If it was an inside person, he/she should be penalized.

Yes, the cost of lunch was perhaps 5 dollars or less. What it signifies is a lot more. Lack of common sense, distraction to a work place, a hugely bad sense of humor (at best)

Would you be saying "just lunch" if your lunch was stolen 5 times in few weeks? I don't think so.


Colanth
Theft, no matter how petty, is grounds for dismissal. An accident (the bags looked similar, and the guy didn't know what his wife gave him for lunch) isn't.


...
yes bcuz hes stealin n its food n food costs money n he probaly didnt feel like goin to buy some food bcuz wen ur linch all u want to do is chill n eat not movin aroun lookin for food or he probaly didnt have money to go buy food lol im jk i think he is over reactin


Buddy
I worked with a woman who stole lunches, she got caught and fired. You bring a lunch to work to save money because the machines are expensive. Two with a person like myself who has to eat at certain time due to and illness, it's not funny when you go to get your lunch and some stupid, worthless person has stolen it. Yes, it is a big deal!


ralphie may ate my family
If you didn't steal it, why do you care?


P.S If someone stole my lunch, heads would roll.




Carl P
Rating
There may be more to this then written up.
Is it a reoccurring issue, perhaps someone is ragging on another employee on purpose.
Also did the person who lost their lunch, lose anything in the lunchbag like medications, or personal property?

Theft is not to considered over-reacting to HR. If it is someones lunch today it could be office equipment tomorrow. At least a write up is proper for the first time.


Bertsta
Rating
It is theft.
Yes, it's a disciplinary matter.
Stealing a colleague's lunch is as low as it gets.


Stephen M
If I were hungry and found my lunch, which I prepared and paid for, stolen, I would be angry. It's a betrayal of trust, no matter the monetary value. He was standing up to a bully.
Firing would be extreme, but to be written up would be just.


Mike
Rating
No, it was theft. The culprit should be found, and asked to account for what he did. He never it will be found. I know this because it happened to me. Not once but several times. Couldn't catch the SOB. The lunch hijacks finally stopped. Mike


Heather V
Rating
It would be normal to write some up for this type of action, unless the person has other write ups firing would be a little extreme.


Crazy P
Rating
it is overrating i would just tell him or her to shut up and get something else to eat


sheidu5
Rating
overreacting.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Can an employer change an employee's job title?
Job role and responsiblities remain exactly the same.
Additional Details
What if the employee objects. If they see it as a step down....


 I have been signed off work by my doctor but work have ordered me back, what is the legal stance? ?
...


 Is it legal to recieve a 7 day notice of layoff?
...


 Gift for my boss?
I work in a small law firm. 2 attorneys and 1 paralegal and me. There is a surprise party for my boss's 60th birthday. I don't know what to get him. He always dresses real nice. He drives a ...


 What are the consequences of me leaving my job without giving the contracted notice?

Additional Details
I'm working in the U.K...


 Can you be fired being off work with a doctors note?
If you are off work with depression and its proven by a doctor with a doctors note can your work place fire you?...


 This is the 4th time I've been on an interview (legal) where an employer is annoyed over questions. Why?
I've always read it's great to ask questions at the end (or when appropriate, during an interview). I've asked 3 or 4 of the common questions (Why is the position open? Any plans for ...


 My employee rang in sick but later i found out he went on a night out i questioned him and he lied ?
he rang in sick the day after vi received proof he went on a night out he has been questioned and told he did not go ...


 If i apply for a job am i entitled to a letter to say if i have got it or not?
i applied for a job in my company, i went for an interview but as yet i have not recieved offical notice that i have not been given the post. Am i entitled to some form of correspondance?...


 A "3'rd interview with a law firm,"?
I had a second interview yesterday for a TC, i've now been told that I may have to have another interview???

It is for a small high street firm ,

I'm getting fed ...


 Could i get fired?;p
All i do is sit around on yahoo myspace imeem at work. My boss isnt here half the time and when she is here she dosent notice. I have work but i can multitask so can i get fired from using the ...


 I was FIRED help.?
I worked in a hospital in Texas but was fired yesterday for what my supervisor called insubordination. To make this as short as possible a patient over heard me complaining about working every ...


 Can they Really sack me like this?
told on friday that there was not enough work left to keep me on . it was a permenent position. Now im liiking for something else but dont they have to give me notice or pay me notice?...


 I am OFF sick for a month, can my job call me everyday to check up on me?
( UK ANSWERS ONLY PLEASE)

I am off sick for depression and my manager calls me everyday or so. Lately he called me and asked me to call him once a week to let him know about my progress. <...


 Should I send out a mass email to humiliate this man?
Several months ago I was working for a company in sales. Another representative had to split his commission with me because he sold a deal to one of my clients. When he found out he had to split it, ...


 Can my employer (a local goverment) really tell me who i can talk to in my own time?
Just before Christmas 3 of my colleagues were suspended from their posts. They were not told why, just that investigations were being made and that they would be called in for diciplinary action ...


 Wrongly accused for misconduct at work. How can I still collect unemployment?
Hey everyone,

I was recently laid off my job along with 5 other people. We were given no papers etc. about our termination. They just said they were downsizing for the new year and asked ...


 I prank called my teacher and he got me should i egg his car?
...


 Overpayment of wages by employer?
A question for all you employment law specialists- my work has been overpaying me for the past 4 months to the tune of 500 quid a month, they now want it back at the same rate, am I entitled to ask ...


 Can i resign without notice?
I have been off ill over about 8 occasions but have been booked off for most of those. My employer is now doing a formal investigation and say that i can only have a union rep or collegue present. I ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.024