Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Marriage & Divorce

Is it wrong that I told my husband that I don't want to have kids until he quits smoking?
Find answers to your legal question.





Is it wrong that I told my husband that I don't want to have kids until he quits smoking?

My husband and I have been married for one year. I told him from the beginning that I hate his smoking, but I kind of just let it go. Now, he's talking about wanting kids, but I said I don't want any until he quits. I just don't want my kids around cigarettes, especially from their father. He keeps saying he will quit once we have kids, but I don't believe him. Is it wrong for me to say this???


    




Laurie
Rating
Good for you! Your kids deserve a healthy smoke free life. If your husband can quit after having kids, why can't he quit now? Why procrastinate? He may think a few extra cigarettes don't matter, but every cigarette counts. Besides, the effects of secondhand smoke can be worse than those of the smoker him/herself. Be consistent. Tell him that you're sorry, but you feel very strongly about this and you are not willing to give in.

Congratulations on realizing that this is the best for your children. You will make a great mother.

XOXO,
Laurie


sanbox69
Rating
good for you!!


luvlisteningtomusic
Rating
You cannot change him and the kids will not change him it will be up to him to change himself. It is ok that you put your foot down and told him. Take it from a smoker it is so very hard to quit. He could quit and after you find out your pregnant he could start again. You should of thought about this before you married him.


Bassman58
It is not realistic. Your husband will quit when he sets his mind to it. Nicotine is like any other addiction, you can't make the person stop unless he or she wants too.


Coolio A
it's good and bad in some ways. it's good that you don't want him smoking around your kids, but that was kind of harsh. smoking is a very hard habit to quit and it's not a one time answer where you say no, and they will automatically stop. it takes time.


♥Ms. Heart♥
Rating
My man smokes too and I hate it! But as long as he doesn't smoke around me, I'm fine! He should respect you enough to at least not smoke with you around...


cope_acetic
It won't happen unless he is highly motivated.
If you are willing to wait forever, stick to your guns. But know also that you CAN keep his filthy habit out of the house and car!
I am an ex-smoker--tell him If I can quit a 3-pack-a-day Kool habit cold turkey after 27 YEARS, he is a sissy if he CAN'T quit!
This chick is 3 years smoke free!


luisamapacha
He won't quit once you have kids. They never do.

But you have to realize that you've always acted okay with his smoking. It's unfair to drop this on him now, when he thought everything was okay.

That being said, stand your ground without pressuring him. He has to quit on his own, because he wants to, not because you're forcing him to. (That just leads to a husband to smokes in secret.)

Make it clear you'd love to have kids but won't until he quits, then drop the subject.


Kris L
Rating
If you 'hate' his smoking, then you had better LEAVE him and find a 'non-smoker' to father your kids. If you LOVE HIM then ALL you can do is ASK him to 'smoke outside' when you are pregnant and after the children are born ... second hand smoke is 'dangerous' but you did MARRY a smoker, and that does IMPLY that it's 'okay to smoke around you' ... by 'just kind of letting it go' and marrying him when he obviously had NO INTENTION of quitting, you have put your 'seal of approval' on that behavior, and you now are fighting a losing battle to try to get him to quit smoking even BEFORE you get pregnant. YOU are at fault here for THINKING you can 'change his behavior after marriage' ... and YOU may have to 'pay the price' ...


Mommy of two beautiful ♂
No, you are doing right smoke are bad for kids or pregnancy!


spanky1492
Rating
You should take a stand but this is manipulation.


Matilda
i think it's great you told him that. second hand smoke can kill you too. . . good for you!!!!! don't back down!!!!


miss tennessee
Not only is it NOT wrong it is absolutely imparative that he quits Before you even get pregnant. The health of your children is #1 and it will be so much easier for him to quit before you have kids anyway!


mmm..whynot
Rating
as much as i am against cigarettes putting pressure on him will not make much difference.. he will quit when he is ready.. there are times when people quit when you east expect it. maybe the birth of his kid would make him quit.. mayb not!! .. he might quit for a bit then go back after child is born.. no guarantee.. you met him a smoker most likely. where i work there is a pulmonary doc who is amazing at helping others quit but you have to be willing .. find one in your area.. as long as your husband is open to it. the more pressure you put on him the worse it is..


Kayla J
Rating
UMMMM ...just tell him to cut down and smoke away from you and when you have kids to not smoke around them... that is all you really should have to say i mean telling your full grown husband that he cant do something and have children is like telling a diabetic that they cant have a diet pepsi because they are taking insulin... it is just a way to start a fight and if you want kids you will overlook it more... why did you marry a man? to change him? you fell in love with the one who smokes and should cherish him whether he smokes or not... it is not right to take away his fatherhood just because he is a smoker.... it is morally wrong


answer
Smoking around kids raises chances for learning disabilities. It's not wrong for you to want him to be healthy for your families sake. Smoking is terrible, and may leave his kids fatherless. My dad died of lung cancer because of smoking and his dying words were how he ruined his life and wished he hadn't smoked. Does your husband want to see your kids graduate or get married? My dad didn't get to.


wendileen
Rating
It's a good idea, but it probably won't work. If he's a hard-core smoker, he might just prefer smoking to fatherhood. Then what? You give up having kids? It would probably be more effective to discuss with him that you insist that he stop once you have a child, and then just make it a goal at that point. Don't let him smoke anywhere near you, or in the house or car, and that will get him started on quitting. You shouldn't be around second hand smoke if you're planning on getting pregnant, or are pregnant anyway. And obviously, children shouldn't. He might feel more motivation to quit once he's responsible for another person.


chmar11
Sounds pretty smart to me. I grew up with a step dad who
smoked and it bothered me. No matter where I would move
to in a room the smoke always seemed to drift my way.
Sometimes I would go outside it bothered me so much.
He recently passed away with lung cancer. (I'm sure it
was due to smoking since he was 19). He was only in
his early 60's. Maybe you could show him statistics of
smokers dying from cancer or something that would
scare him into stopping? Good luck.


sexi in pink!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
no thats totally right!!!!!!!!go girl


guardianangel2008
Rating
The question is are you ready to have kids? If your husband's habit is smoking than thats better than other habits. But its your decision if you want kids with your husband if he plans to quit I think you should believe him since you know him well enough. However, if you plan to have a baby he must not smoke around you at all and to take it outside at all times. Just try encourage him to quit.


dizzygrltoo
Rating
Nope it's not wrong. I told my hubby the same thing.


Steph
When you are pregnant your baby will suffer from your husbands second hand smoke as will as you. Very UN-safe for you and especially the baby!!!!


Poppet
Rating
No, you have must do what you feel is in the best interests of your children's (even if still unborn) health.

Still, when you put ultimatums out there be prepared for the consequences. If he never stops smoking then you will never have children. Are you okay with that?


David H
Rating
No, this isn't wrong. It is sensible. I'm a smoker and I'm saying this. I don't think caring for a newborn is very compatible with quiting smoking. Now would be a better time. I think you should make it clear that you want him to quit whether or not you have kids.


•·.·´¯`·.·• xVIcTorIAx •·.·´¯`·.
Rating
no its not wrong, smoking is very bad for a pregnant woman and even worse for a little baby stick to what you say its for yours and unborn childs sake


remlap47
Rating
I totally agree w/you also. Stand your ground. It's not just the 2nd hand smoke issue which of course is a real concern. It's also the fact that kids that grow up around a "daddy" who's a smoker want to emulate what "daddy" does, and that sort of thing. Just hang in there++++


Icewomanblockstheshot
Rating
you are not wrong in the least bit; just be sure he is committed to quitting forever, he cannot smoke around children...at all


Hey Hey Hottie
i think that's a good thing so then he would be more healthy when the kids are older





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 HOW DO I TELL MY WIFE THAT I'VE BEEN SEEING ANOTHER WOMAn?
I THINK IT MUST HAVE BEEN A MISTAKE...


 Gay Marriage? Yes or No??
With all of the talk about gay marriages and constitutional amendments to prevent them... What is your opinion on Gay Marriage? Should they be legalized? Why or why not??...


 Is it proper for a husband to purchase a high priced item without his wife knowing?
...


 Poll: Married or Single?
...


 HELP...My husband wont leave me alone!?
My husband and i have been together for 5 years,and married for 1 1/2 years.I have been so unhappy for the past year or so.He tells me where and what to do,and he doesnt let me go anywhere without ...


 My wife is texting another man at least 400 to 600 times a month said there just frineds?
tell me ladies the must be something going ...


 My wife told me that she is not happy and needs "space" to have an affair. What should I do?

Additional Details
There follows a question where the roles are reversed a bit.

Its funny that the majority of answers here say leave her and do not attack her.
Yet when ...


 Do you believe once a cheater, always a cheater?
My ex husb just cheated on his current girlfreind and its all my friends talk about....


 My husband always says "I love you" everytime right before we hang up the phone or leave each other.?
I know its a good thing, but can you say "I love you" too much, to where there is really not a lot of meaning behind it anymore? Please answer!! T...


 He hit me back!?
I had a big arguement with my boyfriend and i got so angry that I punched him in the face. i didnt think he would do anything back but then he swung his arm round and struck me on the top of my arm ...


 I'm getting married next saturday, any words of wisdom????
...


 My boyfriend punched me last night and broke my nose?
he was drunk, and he has apologised about it this morning, he has broke my nose before, should i forgive him again this time?????????????????????...


 Should I feel guilty making $100K a year?
own my own home, have a pretty nice stock portfolio and have no debt and no kids or wife to worry about WHEN my sister is dead broke, keeps having kids and picking losers for boyfriends?...


 Can you advice me please?
My husband who cheated on me said that either we move forward or go our separate way. He made a new commitment by saying that he has stopped all communication with the other women and will not ...


 My husband has not touched me for 10 years. Is it still wrong for me to look for someone else?
10 years ago he asked if I minded if he had an affair. I told him I did mind, but I know he had the affair anyway and has had several since. He hasn't touched me since, we live as flat mates. He ...


 How many times should I tell my wife that I love her?
...


 Is it wrong to let my fiance go to strip clubs?
My fiance and I beed together 7 years. When he goes partying with his friends he somtimes goes to strip clubs. He lets me know when ever he goes and I dont get bothered by it. I even go with him ...


 I dont want to be divorced twice but my hubby is lazy lies and always tries to make me miserable..what do i do
he can do really mean hings but he always turns it around on me and says im the bad guy.... Like he went out one night and never came home.then got mad at me because i was upset about it.....he ...


 Interracial marriage?
I am a white guy and in love with a Kenyan girl 10 years younger. My grandmother hates "*******". What should I do?
Additional Details
me 34
her 24...


 Should i cheat?
my husband cheated on me for a whole year with another woman. i have suggested counseling to get help us move on, but he refuses to go, saying that he does not want to re-live the experience. i am ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.074