Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Marriage & Divorce

Make or break decision- totally heartbroken- can you help me?
Find answers to your legal question.





Make or break decision- totally heartbroken- can you help me?

if you love someone enough, can you overcome a huge problem in the relationship?

today i have to decide if i want to leave my boyfriend of 18 months, we live together. he suffers from great great depression that stems back to when his parents abandoned him and he never got over it- he is 42 now. i am 28. i give him so much love and offer help and try to sit and talk to him about how he feels.

now, i feel as though some sort of barrier has come down over me and i am so sad. its like i cant help any further, i dont know what to do.

last night i stayed at a friends and did not answer his calls etc so i could think. today i went home and he is devastated and doesnt want to loose me.

he admitted that he thought i would always be there, to accept how he is sometimes. i think he got a shock.

he says that the thought of loosing me is toomuch to bear, he tried to hold me but i moved away. i guess i am just hurt about things.

but inside, my heart is screaming out to stay. but my head says i have to show him i wont be treated badly.

its tearing me up, how can we work it out?

how can i help him? could our relationship become stronger if we tried to get through this bad time?

need some help! xx


    




jude
Rating
if u really love him and he loves u, and the problems don't stem from a betrayal, there is always a way to work it out. if he is depressed he should go to the dr's, he could have a chemical imbalance and antidepressants could be the answer. if he is worried he may loose u, he might be open to some therapy along with something for his depression. lots of people suffer from depression and medication is the answer.


Starliquid
Rating
I am struggling with a similar situation myself with a boyfriend struggling with alcoholism. I am guessing you will get a bunch of answers saying "leave him" or "move on". Obviously that is not the answer you are looking to hear. I am finally coming to terms with the decision I do not want a life where I am treated poorly. Its not the sort of decision all people can make in a night or two. If you believe he is the man that can support you and bring you joy 5, 10 yrs from now - go to counseling with him. If deep down you are staying because of a fear of starting over or being alone start re-evaluating your life, read a new earth by ekart tolles (sp?), write a list of the things you want out of life (family, success etc.) and get some distance from the situation. Sometimes in long term relationships we put up with things we would never put up with had he shown that behavior in the first few months.
Sadly I don"t think you can fix him, he needs to work on himself and the best you can do is be supportive.
Good Luck
p.s. until you have worked this out make sure you are vigilant about using birth control.


drjaycat
Rating
Depression is a medical condition, not caused by his parents abandoning him and equally not fixable by counselling. If he really HAS depression then presumeably it was professionally diagnosed and is being treated with appropriate medication. If it has NOT been diagnosed then he may well be using it as an excuse for his behaviour. If it has been diagnosed but he refuses to take medication then he must accept responsibility for that.
If he can't, then I think you should probably leave as nothing will improve.


Katrina
It's hard to be with someone who is depressed. He needs to be in counseling to help him resolve his issues. It will take a long time and you must be willing to be patient with him.
For you, you must decide weither you want to stay with him because you still love him, not because you are afraid of how he going to take it.
I don't have enough information as to what things are making you hurt and how he's treating you badly. You didn't expand on that. It would depend on those things as to weither you stay or leave also.
Good luck.


♥The Mrs.♥
Rating
Leave. Love worth staying for suits your head first then your heart.


candi redd
Rating
If he refuse to let his past go even w/ counseling that you are 28 and life is too short to concern yourself with a man who may not change.


marriedandamom
Rating
Being with a depressed person will bring you down, as you have discovered.
He has to take responsibility and want to try to get well. There is counseling (church or secular). There are many medications and activities and support groups.
It is unrealistic to expect that you can be his cure. It is unfair that he depends on you for some level of happiness.
This relationship is unhealthy and you both need some help to get through the rough times.
If you love him, can get some healthy support and a break once in awhile, sure - you can make it work but you have to work together. The burden must not rest solely on your shoulders or it will burn you out.


honest girl!
It seems that your partner is depending on you solely to get him through his depression, when really the only way he can get through this is by him seeking the right professional help.

If he does love you he would then make every effort to sort himself out, and it is not fair on you to take on his burden. Be firm with him and tell him what he needs to do..





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Are man from alexdania allowed to marry a american women?
...


 How can I deal with being short, and having two tall parents and two tall siblings?
I am now in college, fully grown, but I am only 4' 9''. I am also redheaded and covered with freckles. And another problem is being with my family. They are all tall and beautiful. My ...


 Problem with wife and mother-in-law?
my mother-in-law gets upset at me for a number of differant things small things like blinking and then will yell at me and then when shes done with me shell yell at her daughter for being married to ...


 My wife thinks we change from the first time we met each other. She thinks we r more just friends than anythin?
I leave to go to work at 6 in the morning and dont get back until 4-5. She goes to work at 4-10. By the time she gets home i am ready for bed and i cant stay up because my body is so used to going to ...


 Need help altering this fun invite? CREATIVE PEOPLE, where are you?? =) ?
The invite for my gilligans party is almost done, but I thought maybe I should alter a few parts the "[---]" AREAS are the sections where if you could fill in something better than what I ...


 I think spouse is cheating!?
So i've really just had a very upsetting week-my husband and i have been working out some trust issues for a couple of years now-i almost divorced him after i found he had been text messaging ...


 Would you marry someone who had a lot of bad debt?
...


 If your husband pranced out wearing your polka dot two piece bathing suit and suggested?
might need to lose some weight, how would you have reacted ?

Is there something clever I can do or say an hour ...


 Please help..What causes one to judge their live-in partner or begin to nitpick on little things?
Dating nearly 2 years,We live together,and are inseparable 90% of the time besides work.We're best friends.But at the same time,I was raised highly disciplined;routine housechores,made bed every ...


 Why cant I just leave?
My husband and I have really been struggling for a while. He works very hard... and I stay home with our four children. They are 13,11,3 and 1. Our one year old is registered disabled, so he is like ...


 Would you consider a person to be lucky or unlucky to be single?
I have not dated in about two years and have no intention of doing so again. I am not very attractive and those feelings have only been exacerbated by the calibre of girls I was able to attract: in ...


 A suspicious husband for 19 yrs.?
Hi I have been married for the past 19 years. When I newly got married, I had a male friend. just a friend that my best friend at that time liked...but it didn't work out for them. On one ...


 Would it be a good or bad idea marrying an older man?
I'm under 20 and I would like to marry an older man like 10-15 years older. So I don't have to worry about a man my age dumping me for a younger women and for the maturity but would it be a ...


 How do you separate loving someone so much from becoming their doormat?
I cant accept that i was stupid and used my ex dumped me after he got engaged (arranged marriage); he mentally abused me ; u name it , he ended up laughing at me for all the things i have done for ...


 How and/or when does a man know when it's the right time in a relationship to purpose for marriage?

Additional Details
opps. It's propose not purpose....


 Please help serious answers only?
I have always felt like my kids come first and still do. I am faced with the fact that I will lose my son if I don't leave my fiance who I love. My kids come first but he is awesome as a step ...


 Is he cheating or no?
My husband moved off cause he has a new job. I am still down here because I am going to graduate high school first before I move...I only have 4 days left...but I found a text to his ex that said &...


 If you are a baptist is it wrong to make out until you are married?
My friend is a baptist and she made out with a guy . I wanted to know if it is bad if you make out with someone before your married ?...


 Is this normal and would you stay in this relationshit?
Well first off I'm engaged and my fiance is bugging me to set a date since its already been a year engagement. Besides being scared shitless to get married (which is a whole different story)...I...


 Help Me With This Marriage Complication!?
Hi my name is ashley. Im almost 22 years old i have been married to my husband for only 6 months but been with him for 3 years. Let me start from the day of meet. Tony and i met one day and i knew ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.024