Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Marriage & Divorce

Question for women...
Find answers to your legal question.





Question for women...

If your partner of 7 years punched you in the mouth, would you leave him immediately, no questions asked? Would it make a difference to you if he had never done it before & had had too much to drink (at a party, he's not an alcoholic or anything) before doing it?
Thoughts & opinions please :)
Thanks.


    




spanky <3
You need to talk to him and make sure he fully without question understands that you will leave him for good if he ever does it again. Be stern and make sure he gets that into his head that you will be GONE if he ever touches you again. Give him another chance but if he does it again GET THE HELL OUT OF THERE!


Mike
Rating
Nobody deserves to be punched or hit. Its immediate grounds for ending the relationship


brandi91082
Rating
Yep. Out the door. I will never be anyones punching bag. Not even once.


whisper
THIS IS HARD FOR ME TO ANSWER CAUSE MY DAUGHTER WOULD HAVE BEEN 34LAST MONTH HAD SHE SURIVED HER EXES BEATINGS,,BUT SHE DIDNT,,N IT STARTED OUT AS ONE TIME THEN A LOT OF TIMES I NEVER NEW ABOUT UNTIL AFTER THEY PRONOUNCED HER DEAD,,SO LETS JUST HOPE,HES REASONS MAKE SENCE TO YOU,,STAY SAFE ,,,,PEACE


melouofs
I don't honestly know how I'd react. My mother suffered physical abuse at the hands of my father, and there is no way I could tolerate that. However, knowing my husband, I'd be stunned beyond belief if he punched me in the face. So, the honest answer is that I really don't know how I would react.


tlkoons2000
Rating
Honey trust me, run fast!! If he does it once he will do it again and it might not be one punch next time. LOVE DOES NOT HURT!!!!!


Kathyrn F
Rating
Don't make excuses for a man that hits you. Leave. He'll do it again.


Queen of Beer
Rating
I'd be gone in a heartbeat - after I had his ace arrested.


Mrs. Heather Schabby
Rating
I know an awful lot of people on here are going to tell you to leave instantly, however I tend to disagree with them. You need to do what's right for you.

If I were you, I would look at the situation. It had never happened before in 7 years - which is a long period of time to be together. He'd been drinking, and had too much (not that this is an excuse.) I would not leave my husband if he hit me once, however a LOT of changes would need to happen. First off, I would let him know that if he ever did it again, EVER, I would be out the door, no questions asked. I would also say that the would have to never drink to that much excess again. Obviously drinking that much clouds his judgment and he cannot be trusted. He needs to decide what's most important, being able to drink himself stupid or keeping his significant other (I'm assuming you're not married) of 7 years. It should be you, hands down.

In the end, you need to do what's right for you. Do you feel you can trust him? Do you feel he is sincerely sorry and regrets what happened - or is he making excuses and shifting blame? Make your own choice, don't listen to everyone else.

Good luck.


Belinda28
Well, it is the first time but won't be the last. Some women are w/ men for 3 or 5 years before the abuse STARTS. It just doesn't happen once. Any woman that is not prone to seeking abusive partners would leave immediately. This is the test. If you stay, he will have more to give you...if you go, you are not right for him because you won't put up w/ it. If you are even questioning whether or not to stay, you need help. Love is not worth your life and that is what he will take away from you physically, emotionally and spiritually.


Baby Girl!
If he truely loved you he would never lay a finger on you. I would deff. leave my husband if he ever put a finger on me. Even grabbing me aggressively would draw the line for me.


Violet Pearl
Rating
define "partner'
Your boyfriend- leave
Your husband, no you get therapy to resolve the issue and prevent it from happening again.


Astral
Rating
I would have punched him straight back and had him arrested just to ruffle up his feathers a bit. As for hitting him back I would say it was self-defence. I might not then proceed with the charges but feel good in myself for having unnerved him a bit. He might think twice next time. However I do feel that he's done it once and there's never just a once - the instinct is in him now.


Marina
Rating
First, I would knock him on his azz and then he would get a letter from my attorney the next day. I told my husband when I first met him that the first time he puts his hands on me in that manner, it will be the last time he sees me. I mean it. I was in an abusive relationship in my past, and will not tolerate any of it. Do not use alcohol as an excuse. He knew what he was doing.


bobohead
Rating
i would leave no questions asked, there is no reason to hit anyone, not just women, but children and men too.


Red Rose
One punch is all it would take for me to leave.


Shelley L
There is no excuse for a man to PUNCH his wife/girlfriend!! Drunk or not - NO excuse is valid. I'd be SO out of there. He would have to come crawling back to me, promising it would never happen again, that he would never drink again and that he would seek counseling. DO NOT let him off easy. This is totally unacceptable!!


Heather
he wouldnt live to tell the tale.


Bam Bam
Leave him, there's no excuse. It may have been a one time thing, but then again, it may have been the start of an on-going abusive relationship.
If you are really that curious, get some one you trust to come with you to ask him why he did it. If he cant explain it, then leave.


Leena
Rating
A few years ago I would have said yes. But life isn't always that simple.

When I was 18 I moved in with a guy who ended up beating me. The first time he really hurt me, I grabbed a bag and left. Ended up spending the night in the homeless shelter because he put a padlock on the door to our apartment. And that was the end of our relationship.

I'm in my 30's now. And my husband has hit me a couple of times in the past 2 years. And each time he did it I wasn't in a position to leave. The first time he did it I ran out with my baby and called the police. We were poor and the police were lazy and corrupt, they wouldn't even file a report. They even warned me not to call them again. I left for a few days and stayed with my parents, but they are almost as horrible in their own way, so I ended up back with him. On his terms.

My advice to you is, anytime someone you're in a relationship gets violent with you, you leave immediately and then decide if you will continue being with them. If you do come back, don't do it until the details are worked out to your satisfaction and he knows not to do it again. If you stay and work it out he's just learning he can treat you that way and get away with it.

The key here is to never let yourself get into a position where you're unable to pick up and leave at a moment's notice. That's where I went wrong.


Anie
Rating
I don't think I would be able to leave my husband immediately, no questions asked. It would make a difference to me if he had to much to drink at a party. Alcohol does factor in here in this situation. If he'd never done it before that would also factor in. Everybody is entitiled to one "F-up." I would certainly address it once he's sober and the shock of it all goes away. Personally, I think I would say this will be the first and last time you ever lay a hand on me. If you do it again, I won't be as understanding, no matter what the reason behind the punch is.


yelles
I would leave and suggest he get counseling -no matter what- you never hit another person. It's rude and cruel. No excuses or justifications! Drinking does not give you the right to hit someone regardless. If you hit others and get violent while drunk -the solution is very simple-DON'T DRINK!


Sharelle
long story short i was with my ex for 8 years he was never aggressive or violent but one night after a party when we got home he started mouthing off and i said i was going to bed cos i didn't want a row and i got a smack in the mouth for walking away from him..next day he said sorry and cried and i stayed cos he had never raised his hand before that night......2 months later after a night out with the boys he accused me of having a guy over when he was out and he put me in hospital for 6 weeks - i would say leave him cos once they hit you in my opinion they are more likely to do it again - he may never do it but i would never take that chance again


TINK
Rating
ID LEAVE HIM RIGHT AWAY BECAUSE ONCE THEY HAVE HIT YOU THEY WILL DO IT AGAIN AND COME OUT WITH ALL THE CRAP SAYING HOW SORRY THEY ARE AND IT WONT HAPPEN AGAIN AND BELIEVE ME IT DOES HAPPEN AGAIN I HAVE A FRIEND IN THE SAME SITUATION


Sesoid
It is a difficult one, because once there is violence (of any sort) in the relationship, the respect is lost. As long as you keep an eye on the way he behaves from now on, and if you notice just the littlest of things, walk away!

I wish you all the luck!


huny
I would have head butted him in the mouth and asked him how he liked it.
Only you can answer this question. You are the only person who knows your relationship well enough.
Personally, I wouldn't want to be with someone who disrespected me enough to hit me in the first place no matter how long I had been with him.


bartliddy
Yes. Leave him. Punching leads to other bad things!


Tough Guy
Rating
Thank goodness he's not an alcoholic.


Ozzy
Rating
Yes - prob just the start - no excuse.


tigerprincess_bee
What gives him the right to punch you in the mouth. No man should hit a lady for any reason!! You should leave. B/c he will do it again. Drinking is not an excuse to hit anybody. You should have called the police and let him think about what he did in jail!!





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 I dont love my wife?
i am really not in love with my wife anymore. She is very selfish and overall we have nothing in common. Now I will not divorce her so please dont give me that answer. We have a baby due very soon ...


 My husband didn't get me anything for mothers day?
I was joking around with my husband and said that not only should the baby get me a present, but the dogs too. Again, this was a joke. My husband turned around and said, "YOU EXPECT A GIFT!"...


 If you could cheat on your spouse and your spouse not find out would you?
I'm not asking this to justify anything. Because if were able to cheat on her, and her not find out, I still wouldn't cheat on her, because I know that I would have to carry that guilt ...


 Is it ok for my husband to go to lunch with a former co-worker?
He says he's going to talk gossip with her , he's going to taco bell its just going to be them two, am I being too jealous?...


 Are you having an affair? Did you have an affair? Would you have an affair?
...


 How do you get revenge?
i know my husband as cheated on me,more than once,he dos`nt know i have found out.it hurts but i want him to think he is so clever.i have had enough now,i want him to hurt as much as he has hurt me,...


 I have been cheated on! I cant get over it! Should i say my goodbys to him! hes really a good father and mate?
...


 Hi , I just got married and I don't ever want to work!! I have not worked for 5 years and don't want to
How can I get my husband to agree. I just finished school and now he wants me to work. I don't want get pregnant anytime soon either. He makes more than enough to support us....


 Do you regret being married?
I have seen many failed marriages and kind of lost my faith in the whole concept
Please do share your experiences :)
Additional Details
if you are unmarried, do you want to get ...


 My boyfriend of 3 years still does not get along with my 10 year old daughter What should I do?
I just went back to my boyfriend and father of my 4 year old son after being separated for one year. He is being good to me.But I have a big problem .I have a daughter from a previous relationship ...


 Married people only?
be honest are there times when you wish you where still single??
Additional Details
and no av not had an affair or would i!!!...


 HUSBAND, being a ******.. please help?
My husband is angry with me and we are not talking becasue he said I talk too much, saying things that makes him angry. Now i have apologized and tried talking to him but he ignores me and it really ...


 What if I secretly caught my husband cheating...I dont know what to tell him, Im So Devastated?
...


 Im turning 19 next month, can i get married without my parents' consent?

Additional Details
yep, i have a baby of almost 2 years, we dont live together because my parents practically loathe him. we've been together for 5 years.he's stable now, a ...


 Why women have to change their name after they get married?
Don't women have their own recogniation? Why do women have to change their name after they get married? Why not men change their name after they get married?...


 My BF leaves the room to talk whenever his cell phone rings.?
But sometimes if it's his parents or sister he sits and talks in front of me. I have confronted him about it and he says he is just used to doing that and he's done it since before he met ...


 Why are a substancial amout of marriages falling apart.?
It is really sweet to see people that have had a 10-20-30+ years of marriage. but why are alot of marriages falling apart because of infidelity and may other reasons i know. Do you think marriages ...


 To those who have been in an abusive relationship...????
I have been married for almost a year now and for about the past 5 months my husband has been very verbally abusive. On July 2 we were arguing about something and he started shoving me into the ...


 Ladies.. keep the gray or color it?
The men in my family have always had a full head of hair, but we go gray early in life. I’ve escaped it for much of my life, but now it’s starting to take over. What do you think? Should I invest in ...


 I want my partner to do things in bed that she is not comfortable with.How can i persuade her to be dirtier?
...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.094