Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Marriage & Divorce

Should my brother and his wife stay married, they just found out they are father and daughter??
Find answers to your legal question.





Should my brother and his wife stay married, they just found out they are father and daughter??

My brother and his wife have been married for 5 years now. They are very much in love. My brother is 45 and his wife is 25. At the time that they met, my brother was going through a depression. He found comfort in this young woman and quickly fell in love. They have been together ever since.
Just yesterday after going through some old papers my brother and his wife found out that they are actually father and daughter. They were both outraged. They both called her mother to verify and she confirmed it.
She said that she though that my brother looked familiar, but wasn't sure if he was indeed the man that she had slept with on a bet over 25 years ago.
Now that my brother and his wife know that they are father and daughter they are devistated. Should they stay married or get a divorce?


    




Mum3grls
Rating
you have to have the best made up questions on all of yahoo.......a delight to read.......you always cheer up my day


piepiepie
Watching Maury Povich reruns are you?


nic h
lol
Your q's always make my day. If ever I need a laugh, I know to come to Y!A and look up your recent uncanny q's.


OustFantastic
Rating
Where do you come up with this stuff!?! LMBO! Oh, my sides hurt!


2Beagles
Rating
I know this stupid question was on here before. This sounds like the work of a woman who makes up stories under a different screen name.


╚§█Äô☻qσT├
its illegal to marry your daughter. definitely divorce.


Joy
Rating
I can not even believe you asked that question!!!!!


Ed I
Rating
no they should not we had a similar happening round here I say that they agreed for better or worse they have had the better now they can have the worse


*i ♥ vans*
Rating
yeah because that's just weird and there is probably a law against it.


Emerald Jones
OMG, ARE YOU SERIOUS!!!!


Doc Phil
Rating
They sure shouldn't have any babies


awjandbjj
Rating
Divorce definately. There are even states that will allow them to annul the marriage, which would be better. They can't and should not want to stay married now.


bunny h
Rating
get dna first if her mom slept with a man on a bet she probably slept with a lot more men and he might not be her father


Common Sense
They should stay married..


Miki
Rating
well, they should just stay married. why should your brother have to go throught the depression again.

marriage is a sacred thing.


Mocha Chocolate
OMG *smh* IF you are serious, they need to consider that any children they have could have serious health complications. They should divorce and accept that they are father and daughter.


cgagnon32
Rating
if they want too


benita g
i remember seeing this on a talk show episode and i agreed to the decision made on that show the and i still do now. i think the best thing to do is for them to get a divorce, unfortunately. if they have kids, birth defects can occur as well.


Derek
get an anolment becuase that is just disgusting. a father slept with his daughter that is just ******* wrong.


Leroy
Rating
Good one, Butterscare! lol


bluemist
Hey why not stay married they love each other right? that's the argument the gays and gays supporters use right? If two people are in love they should have all the same rights as others no matter how immoral and disgusting right?


Haylebird
OMG. Seriously? For real? Um, ya, wouldn't their marriage be null and void anyway? It's not legal to marry your father/daughter.


♥ Mae ♥
Unless They Want To Be Known For Incest They Should Immediately Get Divorced


habibi
get divorce......
no need to explain why????


bocasbeachbum
This is about 9.5 on the weird meter. Besides being weird it is illelgal in most countries and cultures. Just don't plan on having kids.


kheserthorpe
Seems like a troll, but whatever.

Its a bit late to back off and have a normal father-daughter relationship. I would imagine if they get a divorce, they'll basically cut off all contact with each other.

While I _strongly_ urge people NOT to enter incestuous relationships, this one is a done deal. If they are happy together, might as well stay married at this point. There's no way of undoing it now.


[ K R i S t E N]
GET A DiVORCE!


Cheryl J
It should be annulled
what papers you are suppose to say who your parents are on the wedding license and did they have a blood test to see if this is true
how do you feel about your sister in law being your niece
please get a blood test
if it comes out to be true
annulment is needed


naj3032
sad story...but they should get a divorce....


bankeybiharimehrotra
Rating
Don't divorce
change their resident
they will them self become father/daughter
god bless them both will get patience to realise the truth


Yalonda F
Rating
I would definitely get a divorce.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 How can I get revenge on my cheating wife?
I think this should be done eye for an eye, but I do not know anyone willing. Any other ideas?...


 Should I call the other woman?
The woman my husband had an affair with is still sniffing around. He tells me that she has called him at work to tell him she misses him and wants him back. She has sent a letter to my house (which I ...


 Have you or would you ever cheat on your spouse?
I am conducting a survey on how many people have cheated on their spouses without them knowing. Please be honest! Thanks
Additional Details
And NO i dont plan on cheating on my husband ...


 My wife wants me to make a Choose that will devastate our 4yr old or she will leave me HELP?
while i was at work my 4 year old Daughter was bit by our(my wife and I)beloved 5yr old St Bernard dog Chris the bite was not severe but required stitches.The question is that my daughter has hit/...


 What do you love the most about your mate?
...


 I live with my boyfriend, the mortgage is in his name, am i entilted to anything?
we have been together nearly 3 years, i give him money for bits, i buy all the food, and i buy things for the house. the only thing he does is pay the morgage and a few bills. am i entilted to ...


 He hit me. Was I wrong in breaking up? I feel bad.
I'm divorced and dating again. My boyfriend has a bad temper. Usually he will swear and yell. Last night he punched me in the face. I saw the mad expression on his face. There was blind rage. I ...


 My Husband Is Asking Me WAy too Much, What Should I About It?
My husband wants me to brow money against my small business to send his 19yr daughter to college which is ridicules 'cause of the way the economy is and also to the fact that him and his ex ...


 I'm a newlywed,but my husband's in Iraq & I am now having an affair& want to leave him,How do I tell him?
...


 He feels Ripped Off?
It's my partners birthday tomorrow, I took him to Tunisia for a weeks holiday. 5 star the lot right, so then when we returned the other day, I took the money what it cost for the holiday from ...


 Do the tears stop fallling ever after a relationship ends?
I have been with my husband for nine years (5 of this married to him). He turned round and told me a month ago that the feelings he felt werent strong enough to sustain a marriage, we have a three ...


 Do you panic when you can't get ahold of your spouse?
My husband is always off work at 4:30 and always calls me after. He is working on a constrcution job out of town right but still gets off at 4:30. Its 5:15 and I haven't heard from him and he ...


 I met my girlfriend 4 days ago and I want to marry her. Is it too soon to ask?
She is 25 and I'm 18. I know I want to spend the rest of my life with her. She's perfect in my eyes. She told me she wanted to get married someday. I want to be married by the end of this ...


 Do you think you should always test drive a partner before you decide to marry him or her??
I had a good friend of mine tell me that she would not get married to someone that isn't good in bed. Just curious?...


 Ex-husband shows no interest in his kids?
My ex shows very little interest in our 6-year-old twin sons. He pays his child support and sees them on Saturdays for a few hours, but only if I drop them off and pick them back up. He had agreed ...


 Found out some bad things about my new hubby?
and I have been at wits end should I leave him or not. He didn't cheat. What he did do was offer drugs to my at the time 18 year old son. Thank God he was smart to say no. We just got married S...


 Should I tell his wife???
I dated this guy for three years, he's married. He's only been married three years. I got a divorce over him because he said he would do the same thing. Obviously he has not. We broke up ...


 How can I break up with my gf without her posting our nude pics on the net? Seems I can't leave her?
We were a bit drunk when they were taken & she has all the digital photos with her. She said I have to stay for 6 months before she'll hand them back to me. What should I do?...


 .If your friend was cheating on their spouse, do you think you should tell their partner?
...


 How old do you think a person should be to get married???
me and my boyfriend have been going out for a year now and we love each other and he bought a ring for me and i just happend to see it and i think he could be perposing... the only problem is that im ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.014