Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Marriage & Divorce

Would you pass up the chance of having children, for a man?
Find answers to your legal question.





Would you pass up the chance of having children, for a man?

What is stronger - the compulsion to have children or the desire to stay with someone you are in love with? Would you sacrifice the chance to have children for a partner that didn't want kids? And would you settle for less with somebody else, because they want children as much as you?


    




Jasmine
I would think it would be a lot for a man to ask of the woman he loves. If he truly loved her, he wouldnt expect this huge sacrifice which would probably affect the relationship in the long term anyway. I think this question is a very hard one to answer really. How can you settle for less after you have loved someone else so much?
Is this just a question or is it what you are going through?

No matter what, something would be missing wouldnt it? To have children, you would have to sacrifice your love and to be with the one you loved, you have to sacrifice having children?

No, i think you would need to shake this man up, if you truly love each other then he should reconsider!


JillPinky
Rating
I definitely wouldn't settle for less. I would just find a man who I could love and who would want children. You may feel that you could sacrifice having children and stay with the man you are in love with now, but a few more years down the line and I'm guessing you will regret that decision.


Phils fan ~ 2008 WS CHAMPS!
Rating
i would never give up a future family for a man. i may be in love, but i want kids and i'm not letting a man take that away from me


bonstermonster20
Two words: Hell no. You have to decide what you are willing to live with. Your heart will tell you the answer. You don't have to settle for one or the other. You can be with someone who loves you for you who wants to have kids too. Good luck!


deborah_012003
Why would you have to sacrifice unless he is unable to have children. Kind of selfish, don't you think?? On his part that is..


I_Love_McRedneck
Love is about compromise, not necessarily about sacrifice. You should respect what's important to each other. If you can't do that, you can't be together and be truly HAPPY.


Brandie H
I would have kids. I luckily have a husband who loves children but I could not have been with him if he didnt.


mark
If you want kids, then find a man that wants them too. Yes, he might change his mind - but you'll always feel like there's something missing and eventually you leave him, but it could be too late by then...


Blondie
I wonder why you got to the point of being in love when this issue wasn't resolved
If you don't give each other all that you BOTH desire then it isn't really love ....it is selfishness and there is NO love in that


BabeHeart
I've always been very pleased to be with guys who didn't want children (I never have). When my first husband and I divorced, the reason he gave for not wanting to be with me anymore was because I didn't want kids (and after being together 7 yrs and knowing my mind on that issue since we were dating, he decided it was no longer acceptable).

I could've had a kid to try to save my marriage, but I didn't want children and wasn't going to do that for anyone...love or no love. If our desires in that area didn't match, then we weren't a good match for each other.

I've never regretted choosing to be childfree and I'm 42 yrs old.


fire_side_2003
Rating
There are a few things that I consider important when deciding on who to choose for a life mate. Not someone too spend the next couple years with but someone I would want to committ my life too.
1. Religion
2. Family
3. Politics

When I married my husband he wanted children but due to fertility problems he was unable to have them. Although he was open to the thought of adoption. A year into our marriage after a lot of prayer we conceived our son who is now almost 4 years old. We share the same faith, the same belief in the importance of family and the political affiliation, which no matter how some people might think it's odd a Republican and a Democrat do make odd bed fellows. Anyway, what I am trying to say is this, you need to sit down and think about the three things in your life that are most important too you. Have him do the same, if your points don't match or if neither of you are willing to compromise on anything than I would move on. Not trying to be crass but think about it when you are sitting alone at Christmas when you are in your 60's with no children and no grandchildren just an old man that you love sitting in the rocking chair beside you. Picture that, and think about how it makes you feel. Is he going to be enough for you, if he completes you than go for it. If he doesn't, reflect and think hard about it, and consider moving on. No I would not sacrafice my happiness for someone who would not do the same for me. Who knows if you would be settling for less.


Mystery
Rating
it depends entirely on the individual. i'm a woman who does not want children and have had to let men go who did although it hurt. love and partnership are not just about the heart, they are a combination of head and heart. the head part is the practical stuff...ie you want the same things from life. children is a big part of the practical side. you don't have to settle for less with someone else, you will eventually fall in love again tho it may take time. don't give up the desire to have children for a man or you may resent him for it and your relationship may well break down anyway.then you would have wasted your chance.


AUNTY EM
I would hope that all things were up for discussion and compromise. So no, I wouldn't stay with a man who refused point blank on anything I wanted.


hogsnotbubbles
How can you "settle for less"? Wouldn't it be fair to say that the man who wants children as much as you do would be "MORE" of a man, not "less"?

Being a mom of 4 grown children, and rasing them pretty much alone, I feel I did just fine, and to now turn around and say a man was more important, I'd be a low life from hell!

Children to me are always more welcome than a selfish man!!


iwondersoiask
Rating
i'd say the compulsion to have children is more i compelling. for me, a man has been replaced several times, but my children are with me for life, no matter what, unconditionally. no comparison. children.


Lovely
You have to satisfy your own desires before you can satisfy anyone else's. And apparently you already settling becuase you two do not desire the same things in life.


Qyllix
This is a tough question, about 3 years ago my wife and I learned that she cant have kids. It was pretty rough on both of us. We leaned on each other and are doing well. The real question is what do you feel that you need?


homert1
Rating
Maybe you need to keep shopping for a more compatible mate(someone who is interested in having children as well). Otherwise, you're not being true to yourself and will wind up unhappy and a single mother.


anica2831
Rating
i wouldnt settle for less..thats forsure...before i had kids i would have said id rather have the man..but now that i have kids and the love that i feel for my babies is a love that you never thought possible..i would take the kids over the man any day


♂♥♀Lesley♂♥♀
Rating
well..... u need to set up ur priorities.
if ur willing to sacrifice( which i doubt the motherly instinct is way too powerful!) then go for it!

but before u get into a deeper realtionship u have to let him know how strongly u feel about this.


ophirhodji
No, any time you have to give up something as important as having children for a relationship, that relationship is doomed to fail. Eventually this will cause resentment and ruin things. You need to find someone who wants the same things you do.


MEGative
i would much rather have both....possibly the children becuase they have your loved one's blood running through them so you have a bit of your loved one if you know what i mean....


brownskin
Rating
thats a hard question. i would be with the person who you would you would be entirely happy with. I think that you would be more happy with the one who does want kids.


Jorge Washington
It's all in the person. Ask yourself what is important to you. You would be selfish to your self if you didn't give yourself the opportunity to be happy


vengence
Rating
I did for a woman


Sexy Wife
If he is truely the man for me and I wanted kids then he would have to bend for me.


good_but_naughty
to be with the one I love.. I would not worry about kids I do not have yet..

I choose the one I love over having kids because eventually he might come around and have kids..BTW: not every wants kids.


LuvMy2Kids
I would have kids. There's nothing like it! I'm lucky to have married someone who loves kids as much as I do.

How could you marry someone who has such a divided interest with you on such a huge matter? To me, even if you married him, you'd eventually part. Why? B/c you would be starting off a marriage with a divide already in place. You'd end up blaming him for not 'fulfilling' needs- kids and all!


serephinadragon
My mom settled for my dad cause she wanted kids. I swore I would never do that. So I followed my heart and was with one of my high school sweethearts for 7 years and I thought I loved him, well birth control didn't work and he took a hike. So much for love or so I thought. Then my first love from high school came into the picture. He told me he was searching for me for over 10 years and his 1st 2 ex wives even told me how they were always being compared to me. So I assumed he was being truthful when he said we were in love and were to be married when once again birth control didn't work. He was still saying we were going to be married and I was still in love with him while he went off to fight in Iraq. But while he was there he was cheating on me. So much for my second relationship.

So I was going to swear off men and just be a single mom. But then I thought I needed a social life. Hey I'm fixed now so at least there won't be anymore surprised babies in my future. I went to friendfinder.com found a guy and thought he was good for at least a date. He saw my profile and thought I was cute and good for at least a date. We got married on June 11th, 2005 and we couldn't be happier. He didn't want any biological children of his own cause his grandmother died of cancer and both he and his mother are cancer survivors so there is something in his genes that lets them get cancer and he never wanted to torture a child with that pain. He only wanted to have 2 kids and I already had 2 kids and he plans to adopt both my children.

So you never know...


burninup
Having children is not the most important thing in life. If we are fortunate we may find someone to spend our lives with, but if we are truly lucky we will find someone to spend our love with. Children are not always the answer, and if you think they are, then you should think again?


Hoping he will bless me with #1
Rating
If you REALLY want kids then find somebody that wants kids too. It's not settling for less. It's having a common interest with somebody. If a person has flat out told you they don't want kids, then I would think you should move on. But that's just my opinion.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Gettin marry at age 17??? to young??
im 17, my bf 21 proposed to me. i said yes. my mom thinks im too young n told me i should finish college first. both me n my bf work n go to college. at times i think im too young but im sure i luv ...


 Does his wife know? Should he leave her for me?
I have been seeing this married guy for 7 months now, he has introduced me to all his friends, we go out together, we see each other everyday and took a few weekend trips too. He spends as much time ...


 How do you get your wife to loose weight with cussing at her?

Additional Details
I cant help but cuss...she eats all day. When I come home from work she usually already had 4 meals and snacks. I get angry because she used to be thin now she is ...


 My wife's birthday is coming up. I want buy her a car which one should I buy.?
I want to buy her a nice car. I don't care about the ...


 How can I cope with my sister getting married?
My sister eloped at the beginning of this month and I have been having a lot of trouble coping. I know marriage is supposed to be a happy thing, but this came as a complete shock and now everything ...


 Will you cheat on your partner if you know you will never get caught?
Why and why not....


 Can two people born on same day get married?
...


 Me and my boyfriend want to get marrid...were 21&24 and myparents dont agree what would you do?
...were 21&24 and myparents dont agree what would you do?...


 When someone you don't know tells you to SHUT UP. What would be your response?
...


 Why can't things be the way they used to be? Why is there change?
I think of lot's of good memories, and I wish I could go back in time to those days and just stay there forever. But which one do I choose?

WHY WHY WHY is life so strange?...


 My husband just doesn't get it.?
If I am feeling sad or down and need some compassion or someone just to look me in the eyes and make me feel like he cares, he thinks all I want him to do is fix it. He gets frustrated and doesnt ...


 Does my husband really love me or the other woman? A couple of months ago, I discovered that my husband had?
been having an affair with a woman from another country that he had met online. Through his emails, I discovered he fell in love with her. I forgave him and gave him a choice either me or her. He ...


 My boyfriend ended our 5year relationship 3weeks after i gave birth to our son. what did i overlooked in 5yrs?
my boyfriend and i dated for 5 years and i have just recently given birth to our son who is now 3months old. three weeks after he was born my boyfriend ended our relationship saying the "love is ...


 How long should you date before proposing marriage?
Everyone always tells me.."Take it slow!!!!", so I am. However how long should a guy wait? If you ask too soon, everyone will say "They rushed into it..the marriage won't make it&...


 Can a man love two women at once?
...


 I love this person but he is married we both like each other what may happen, he can't leave his wife too?
He loves me for over two months but he is married person I don't want to hurt his wife what should I do?...


 Mother in law from hell?
My mother in law has had it in for me since day one. Last week she ripped into me, and has poisoned her daughters against me too. There was absolutely no reason for the ripping, my husband and father-...


 Can a man truly love his wife and still cheat on her?
So can a person cheat on their spouse even though they love them. Or do you think they have to stop loving them to do it...My husband cheated on me while he was stationed in germany (we were ...


 Honest answers please. my husband hit me, I'm leaving, is it ever ok?
Has anyone ever been with someone that hit them, and they went to counseling, and were able to stop?

I know that I have to leave, and I don't want to talk to my friends because it�...


 I'm so worried, please i need your help!?
Before me and my husband got married, there was a lady who use to call at home to speak to my husband. So one day i asked my husband jokingly if he has ever dated the lady, he refused and said she ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.084