Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Military

A friend's boyfriend joined the marines without telling her, is that his way of breaking up with her?
Find answers to your legal question.





A friend's boyfriend joined the marines without telling her, is that his way of breaking up with her?

I even use the term 'boyfriend' lightly. He refused to give her the title 'girlfriend' but they're always together. She is mad at the whole no 'girlfriend' title thing for a long time now(2-3years). And I think he's aware she's a prime candidate for chasing jodies.

What do you think?
Additional Details
it is to pursue a certain future in the state police but she had no idea this was part of his plans


    




Sally
As Dr. Phil would say, "move on." You can stay as friends, but you can't "claim" him as a boyfriend. You hang out together out of convenience. There is already two strikes. Spending 2 years of your life together is a long time. Joining the marines is a private thing and a brave thing. It's always hard to say good-bye, but he is really not saying good-bye. He needs to do what he thinks is best for him. He maybe is afraid to hear the "unwarranted" advice. Support him or leave him. Support your friend through this.


Sean the Holy Pirate AM
He probably was already planning on it and didn't wanna go out with her if he is joining the army. He probably didn't tell her about it so she wouldn't have a chance to talk him out of it.


TheFasm4
Rating
I think he just want to join the corps...whats wrong about it?
That doesnt mean he is breaking up or anything!


Marine5
Rating
Guess she just likes being used...????

Doesn't sound like there is any relationship
there and he has told her as much...


papaw
Rating
That's exactly what my son did. He was dating this girl (she was very pushy) She had declared them engaged,bought the ring, and was busy with her wedding plans. Upon his graduation, I was informed, along with my wife and Alisha (his Girlfriend) that he had jouned the Air Force and would be shipping out in 3 wks. Anyway, she bugged him every way she could while he was in basic, and even had planned to go down there (Lackland AFB) and get a quickie marriage done. He finally told her why he joined and it finally got thru to her.

(He said he met several other guys duromt the course of his enlistment that had jouned for the same reason...so it's not uncommon.)

By the way, he became career AF,and will retire in 2 years with 21 years of service, two trips to Bosnia, 2 to Iraq and 4 yrs in England.
He married a girl he met in Flolrida at his first permanent assignment, and they have 4 kids, age 9 - 16.


~Unpredictable~
Rating
No, i think this was something he wanted to do and he was scared of what she would say and if she was mad .


Kelly J
Rating
that dont mean that hes goin to fight for our freedom has nothin to do or he might go fight for his freedom and if shes like you selfissh and self centered sounds like i dont blame him grow up


buck
joined the Marines to get away from a women????? she must have been some uh, mmm, well, you know....something special. Probably it was a decision he was going to make anyway. You would have to be a little girl to think she was the reason a man would make a life time decision of joining the Marines.


miss macy zane
Rating
i don't think you can break up if you didn't have a real commitment. he sounds not good.


neil
Rating
I find it highly unlikely that he joined the marines just to get away from her. It probably had nothing to do with her and everything to do with pursuing a certain future. Someone would have to be a complete dumb@ss to join the military and endure what marines go through just to get rid of some chick. There are easier ways to break up.


private
Rating
Once he is in. Have her write out a letter to him, and have his
parents send it, unless she knows his military address.
It is (unofficially) known as a "Dear John" letter saying,
"Good-by," in so many terms.
If you are her friend. Please help her find another friend.<}:-})


leo a
Rating
It does appear to be as you said.


2Cute2B4Got
Can't break up what never was.


Sasha
Rating
I wouldn't have even stuck around for the 2-3 years I wasn't his 'girlfriend'. Who cares if he's gone. It's better for her anyways.


343 Remember
Rating
Choosing to enlist in any military branch is a personal commitment. It sounds as if this young man was not committed to your friend. Hanging out with someone a great deal does not automatically denote relationship status. If he chose not to tell her, that is his choice.

It sounds as if she wants to have say on something or someone that she does not have a commitment from and vice versa.

I know a lot of Marines, many of which are recruiters.. no one told him NOT to check with her; however they probably did not tell him to check with her either.

As far as chasing 'jodies' I am sure she can chase away.. he is on his own path to further play out his future and she herself should find her own path.

As far as breaking up with her.. were they actually going together in the first place and if he did join without even talking to her about it.. then it is a crystal clear indicator that he did not feel that there was a connection. Intimacy and hanging out do not autotmatically require conversation about life choices.

If you should happen to run into this young man, make sure to congratulate him on his choice and should he make it through Boot.. please make sure to thank him for his dedication and commitment to our Nation's Safety.

I wish you well.


colt008
Rating
i think its clearly the break up point,if he cant even use the term girlfriend his not worth her time move on and find a guy that can love and respect her she worth a lot more


Redbrd
yeah, he got what he wanted and ran. Guys will do that. What scum bags. They run after they get what they want. He now has an excuse to get another girl. He will ,most likely do the same to the next girl.


monster23
Obviously he doesn't want to be with her. His life is going in a totally different direction than hers.


inyoung.minwooe
Rating
It would seem so!!


Sarah S
sorry to say but he uses her like toilet paper. there are 54174749 more guys out there and my advice to her is erase him out of her mind and go get another boy


tinkerbella
i think he could care less about her, she's been spinning her wheels on this guy


Juan Q
Rating
I dont know but I think they want to break up


kateanator
Rating
He sounds kinda mean.. and afraid of commitment. If she loves him she should tell him that he either straightens up and treats her right or shes GONE. Easier said than done.. I know..


something in the way she moves..
Rating
I don't think he "broke up with her" , he might have not eve wanted to join the marines, he might have been drafted., or not.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Im going to be making a video, and i just wanted to know, what was the war that upsetted you the most?
I going to be making a video and wanted to know which war was the most stupid tyo go into, or if we were be lied to as a nation, and if you had to pick a war with a reason, what song would sound good ...


 Conservative people. More likely to be brain washable?
Than no conservative?...


 Does Iran REALLY have the guts to take on America?
...


 My husband is being offered a job in Iraq...?
How safe do you think it is & why? How unsafe do you think it is & why? The position is with hazardous waste & materials. Any guess to how much should be the $ amount he should be ...


 If people are not mature enough to drink at age 18, then why give those same people a gun in the military?
People can join the military, where they could get shot at, bombed, gas'd, kidnapped, and tortuted. They will, more than likley, be separated from family and loved one for months on end. Yet, ...


 Do you support the military troops?
As a vet I would personaly like to thank our troops. To all our troops serving, veterans, and theirs spouses and families,THANK YOU for helping keep the right to celebrate Christmas. I hope you all ...


 What Country Has the Best Military?
I mean over all, training,weapons..

Who is the best?...


 How many unnecessary deaths (American included) has American imperialism caused from the Korean War till now?
Bush has just acknowledged a parallel between Iraq and Vietnam, both unnecessary wars resulting from America's desire to impose its will on the rest of the world since 1945....


 Who was the greatest army commander in history and why?
...


 Which is the biggest threat to the US: Iran or N. Korea?
...


 Do you beleive w should have went to war in Iraq?
...


 Why do military personnel get discounts, but people who?
give their lives to promote peace don't?

Cuz it's better to kill they enemy than love them?

I'm confused....


 What are 5 reasons that Republicans don't want to leave the war in Iraq?
Please include accurate facts. It's for a research project at school. It's due tomorrow....


 Will the Republicans ever support the troops and take them out of harm's way?
...


 Will the US pull out now?
Now that the surge is over and the Mahdi Army has restarted operations will the US pull out of Iraq or reatreat to a safe haven in the Northern Kurdish Territories or will they just abandon the major ...


 War is the greatest injustice of our age?
Do you agree or disagree, why?
Additional Details
To say "its human nature" doesn't address the whether its just or unjust....


 Why can't the Navy wear some kind of blue cammo?
I think the folks in the Navy would feel better about those uniforms!
Additional Details
OK, Blue or gray it doesn't matter, just so long as they can wear a BDU!...


 If I join the millitary as an illegal how long do I have to serve before I can retire on welfare?
please no silly answers I have very bad ...


 Call me sinical. but..?
any1 else think the asian tsunami was from a nuclear test..maybe from north korea
Additional Details
sry had a few beers.........


 What is the probability of a nuclear attack on Britain from the east?
I was wondering what the chances might be given the political climate, would britain be a target because of our allegence to the U.S....




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.024