Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Military

Can woman be a good leader in military?
Find answers to your legal question.





Can woman be a good leader in military?

a country spends several million dollars each year supporting a public military college tha is open only to males. college officials say that a males-only policy is important to develop strong leadership skills. Recently, however, several highly qualified young women have applied to the college, but were rejected. The country does not support any females-only colleges. From the women applicants' point of view, is the country's support of the colleges fair?why and why not??????


    




Jennifer D
Rating
The military is very strong in preserving tradition. For example, Pararescue jumper is a career field that ONLY men can enter... no if's, and's, or but's.

What will the world come to when tradition is no longer preserved anywhere? Let's face it, nothing is and never will be equal 100%.

I'm a female in the military by the way, and it doesn't bother me one bit that I'm not allowed into a male only college. More power to them. I think that once the women earn their right to the top by other means (and not by blowing our way to the top) that in turn, we're a might more respected for how hard we've worked.


paige700
I am a woman I don't believe most women can make good leaders because they tend to make decisions based solely on emotion. This is not the case for all women just most. Do I think they should be shut out of schools sure if its a mens only school but there should be a womans only school as an alternate


bill
Their has been many good female military leaders throught history


it is me
if she is a goose


chevereeddie
Rating
i served with some women in the army and while some were a waist of uniform there were others that shined and were great leaders. However if your referring to leadership in a demanding role like infantry then i would not include women in leadership roles. I think respectfully there is so much they can do. i was in a transportation unit and seen some women lay down some fire and bust their butts working just as hard if not harder than some lazy males. there were a couple girls who always volunteered to go on missions traveling through hot zones. and while i have the utmost respect and admiration for those women, we cant expect them to go run off and become rangers.


Dave
Rating
Leadership knows no gender. I served 23 years in the US Military and have known exceptional male and female leaders. Leadership is a function of trust earned, integrity shown, and competence displayed. I don't think any one gender has the market cornered on those things.


MuddButt
Rating
In my opinion No. Because other countries would take us for being weak for giving a woman so much power. You have to remember that America is one of the only few places that let woman have a lot of power.


Sweetpea
Which college is this you are referring to?


Maria M
Rating
Yah to be in the milatary we have to be strong and have bravery and so on but that does NOT mean that we cant be in the army, navy, coastguard, ETC. It does NOT MATTER. We girls can proove we are as strong as men anytime we want. I bet you most of the girls in the marines for example would beat lots of those boys out there(i mean the ones not in the marines!) So i think it is very very very unfair that some people think that females(women) cant go into the milatary. i am only 12 yrs old and i have been dreaming my hole life to be in the marines and i hope eventually i will be


ready4sea
It depends on how far they go. Motherhood is a higher calling and it is very difficult to do that and be a leader in the military or the corporate world for that matter. I don't think both can be done well at the same time. I certainly wouldn't attempt it. I couldn't do my job if I didn't have my wife at home keeping things in line. Having her come to war with me just wouldn't make sense at all. And I have no intention of raising my grandchildren because my daughters feel like going off to war.

For women bent on being military leaders to the end without becoming wives/mothers, it can be done, but I don't think they are normally wired for that. Women that strive for that kind of leadership and power are in my experience too brutal on their subordinates to add value to the organization. Seen it, lived it, had enough, thank you.


xsesivelyso2
Rating
I see no disparity between women leaders and male, perhaps you should look at the positions held by world leaders that are female, America is no different. When a woman steps up to the plate that has invested her self to the job at hand her qualifications will assure her the position. This is a self pitting attitude to surmise that women can not attain these positions and is self defeating at best. Stop pandering to your self and get up and do something to answer your own questions


YA! Nazi Hamster
Rating
No.


ASmiles1
Okay my point of view i had at least three very effective female leaders in the Military. On the other hand i had just as many ineffective female leaders. The count for males were much higher but equivalent in statistics because of male female roles.


Juan Francisco Duarte
Rating
I do believe it is unfair but, in all fairness women deal with alot of problems different than men. Women are more swift and changeable, while men are more rigid and stern when it comes to the same situation. I believe we look at matters totally opposite and that comes from what we learnt from birth, from mother to the father.


Mrsjvb
Rating
without knowing which country you are referring to and its cultural past, I cannot give you an answer. In a country heavily Muslim, for instance, I would be less won't to say it isn't fair simply because of the cultural norms of such a nation. and just because one country does things a certain way does NOT mean every country should do things that way.

In the Unites States, it has been proven that Women can and do make fine Military officers and Leaders, and many have successfully challenged polices excluding female applicants to such places as the Citadel, VMI and even the Military Academies.

if you live in a country where females are not allowed to attend military campuses despite meeting all physical and mental standards, then you have 2 choices: work within the system to change the policies, or emigrate legally to a country where you can attend such military colleges.


swimming.gir06
No, it's not fair to women at all. It's not fair because it's the twenty first century! Women are as strong as men and we're just as smart too. Women can be great military leaders.


Ari
YES WE CAN! PERIOD! I DONT NEED TO EXPLAIN WHY ILL JUST BE WASTING MY TIME ITS NOT LIKE A MAN WOULD AGREE WITH ME ANYWAYS.


Navy Sailor - GAI
Don't know what country you are referring to, but the United States does not have any MALE only military schools anymore. The Naval Academy, AF Academy, Coast Guard Academy as well as West Point for the Army and the VMI (Virginia Military Institute) are all open to women if they are equally qualified to be there. No college is going to allow you in unless you are qualifed including these institutuions. If you are referring to another country, that is your countries problem not ours. Be specific in your generalizations when asking a question here. The military has tons of well trained and outstanding military leaders that are woman. I being one of them. Figure out your facts before throwing out such blanket incorrect statements if you are talking about the USA, because you are dead wrong when it comes to our military and our military academies!





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Why is President Bush failing in the Middle East?
Failed Baghdad security plan forces US rethink by Paul Schemm


BAGHDAD (AFP) - American forces were seeking new ways to stem the slaughter in Baghdad after previous tactics failed to ...


 Do you lie to your children and tell them Santa Claus exist?
This question is for the righteous right, the doctor Phil wanna be.Do you lie to your children and tell them Santa Claus exist? I think its a bad practice reaaly..

Most people tell their K...


 Im thinking about joining the marines..any advice?
...


 Why is the AK-47 famous?
I have seen AK-47s in games, TVs, etc. What makes the AK-47 famous? Is it better than the M16A2/M4A1?...


 What do you think they REALLY have at Area 51?
A recent tabloid article stated that it was a time machine rather than anything relating to extraterrestrial life....


 If all the Flag-draped coffins of killed GI's in Iraqwere together, how many football fields would they cover?

Additional Details
I did not realize that I needed to be "protected" from Iraq. Were they about to launch an invasion of Atlantic City or something?...


 How can people think that killing more people will bring peace?

Additional Details
geoweeg - by saying 'defeat' in place of killing is like saying "destroy" the bear not "kill".

Who are the "they" ...


 How come no College students demonstrate against the war in Iraq like they did back in the 60s and 70s (Vietna
Young men and women being killed everyday so where is the outrage?...


 What is the best workout to do to prepare for basic training for the military?
im not the exercising type... but i can follow a workout. im 17, 5'11" and weight 139lbs ... im pretty sure i have about 6-7 mouths b4 navy bootcamp....so id like to know what kind of diet ...


 Lets get together in the name of world peace..?
The world is burning in the blazes of war.. Humans attack each other with dangerous weapons killing hundreds of thousands of fellow beings not realising the value of LIFE. No matter what race. ...


 A question for Military personel....?
My husband is Army and decided to re-enlist, we were out with a friend who is civilian and he asked us this question...
"Although I understand the serving your country, Why do you CHOOSE to ...


 Should Bush & Cheney & other top Bush Administration officials be charged with war crimes for the war in Iraq?

Additional Details
and be put on trial then summarily executed for the falsed led invasion that has killed and maimed hundreds of thousands of innocents?...


 Should i stay with my boyfriend since hes joining the military?
ive been with friends with my current boyfriend for over two years. last months we decided to give a relationship a try.its working out great. i think i could really fall in love with him. the only ...


 Is there such a thing as supporting our troops AND be against the war at the same time?
...


 England to get their soldiers back! (THANKFULLY) Do you think they MAY have been in Iran's waters?
...


 What's the worst conventional military weapon?
in terms of ...


 Is the f- ing army that desperate for people they have to take a mom from her kids?

Additional Details
sorry did not know it was 4 and 4 but still,...


 Sure you can come into this country amigo. Will you sign this contract to join the US Marines?
...


 If and when World War 3 breaks out, can I be drafted?
1. I have been convicted of a felony.

2. I have a personality disorder. And have been in three mental institutions for inpatient treatment four times.

3. I am 29 years old.<...


 Do you think iran or Britian was right in the case of the captured sailors?
To all,
Who here thinks that Iran was wrong to hold the British sailors captive? I believe they were wrong? Whoever has worn an army uniform in any country should know that Iran is dishonered by ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Monday, May 28, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.014