Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Military

Does it make me a good soldier if im not afraid to die?
Find answers to your legal question.





Does it make me a good soldier if im not afraid to die?

Im willing to go above and beyond for my squad, im even the first to enter a unchecked building. Or am i just crazy?


    




thst209
It makes you an exceptional soldier. Thank you for protecting us =)


fr_chuck
Rating
Of course we all realise you are making this up for some reason, mostly to try and start some BS.

But no a good soldier is always scared but learns to control that fear and use it. A person who has no fear is a bad soldier since they will make mistakes


raininmyshoe
When you graduate from high school,are you going to join the military? Or just play solider like you are now.


Ted Pack
Rating
I would guess that your job is to make the other guys die. The longer you live, the more bad guys you can shoot. If you can't be afraid, at least be careful.


Abrams Tanker
Rating
Through my years as an NCO, I have learned this.......

Don't expect your Soldiers to do anything you wouldn't. An effective leader sets the standard. Though you don't have to do it all of the time, it is a good gesture to show your Soldiers that you are willing to do the same as they are. Doing this shows your Soldiers your level of committment to them, and will also gain you respect.


Shawn S
Rating
Fear is what will make you make smart decisions. If your not afraid you just may run out and get killed stupidly.

Its my experience that people who say they arnt afraid change their tune when they have bullets wizzing over their heads.Or morters going off close by so I think you will be ok


funkyourcouches
If you are in Iraq right now, you'd probably make good leader in the field as long as your lack of fear doesn't translate into lack of sense. Keep up the good work, unlike these trolls here on this board, America is behind you guys.


Lorne
Rating
no


fathead
Rating
Your attitude demonstrates why we have a problem with Islam today.


Daniel
Rating
im in the special force and afraid from dying.. bro .. its the human nature


Cassandra C
No, it does not make you a good soldier! A good soldier takes care of others and self! You have to stop, step back and look inside yourself... is there a reason why you are doing these actions.


wolf
Rating
u are loyal and courageous i feel the same way . i leave to become a medic with the marines in a few months and i feel the sdame as u. thank you


Forgiven
Rating
Jeremy,
You are a liar. I have read your "Questions" history. You dishonor yourself. You are an overweight college freshman in remedial math, who enjoys riding motorcycles (that is what I gather from your question history).

If you were in the military i'd tell you this:
I think the reason you are the first to enter the building is because that is the position you have been assigned by your squad leader.
Not being afraid to die doesn't make you a good Soldier. A good Soldier is one who follows orders and adheres to the Army Corps values.

I am in the Army, and I am in Iraq, and I have been in Combat. Your insinuation of the fact that you serve and that you are at the forefront of combat operations is an insult to those of us who are here. You haven't got a clue young man - join up and you will learn first hand about "Fear of Dying." Honestly, there isn't a "Fear of Dying" it is more of hoping your decisions and actions don't result in the death of innocent by-standers or the Soldiers on your team and under your command.


DrB
Rating
I think that being willing to give your life for a higher cause is noble—but George Patton said something like "we don't want you to give your life for your country, we want some other soldier to give their life for their country" (or ideology).


tntwade
Only you can answer that! LOL! I doubt you're crazy, but have you ever asked yourself why you do what you do? Maybe a need to stand out, get recognition? Feels good to have people notice how brave and selfless you are? Maybe your just an overachiever. You want to be the best at what you do, no matter what you do. Please, take care. A little fear is a good thing, it could save your life. Thank you for all you do. My son, who is 17, is a member of the Army National Guard. Scares me to death.


Scorpio
I think all soldiers are prepared to die for their country. Because if they are afraid of death, why would they join the force?


shrty0525
God bless you!

Thank you....and I hope it doesn't come to you dying.


somegal321
Rating
Depends. I dont know you but some soldiers suffer from PTSD and tend to block trama out and thats why they are no longer afraid to die. They become numb and that makes them a danger to themselves and others. Some are just fearless or barry their fear deep inside and believe it makes them weak and less of soldier to admit they are in any way like a regular civilian.


Shaka
R U actually in the military? Do U command or do U lead? Does teamwork register with U? Looking after and thinking / caring about the guys your with? Watching their backs as they watch yours? I'm not sure about U! Not at all sure I'd have wanted you on patrol with me! Can't make it out / U don't ring right!


Nat
Rating
I can't believe a question like this even exists to pander to idiot civilians who don't know better than to "ooh" and "ahh".

Yeah, I read your question history. You're a college kid studying game design and computer drafting - IF that's even accurate, I'd say you're something even less - but you're definitely not military.

f you're really military (and every indication is that you are not) then you know what a good Soldier is without having to ask. It's all there in your unit. Have you been boarded, either Soldier or the Month or Promotion Board? Do you take Military Correspondence Courses? Have you completed a requisite number of DA Schools (ABN, AASLT, etc) that earn you leadership skills and promotion points? Do you follow AR 670-1 without fail? Do you follow the Army Values without fail? Do you lead PT Formations and commendations for your discipline? Are you technically and tactically proficient for your skill level and the two right above your pay grade? You already know the answers to these.

The idiot civilians you pander to don't know any better.

Willing to go above and beyond is good and entirely normal in a line unit, but taking point consistently is something that doesn't benefit anyone. It screws people in MOUT, and your squad leader should know better. It's not beneficial to the squad to have you as point over and over again. It screws with professional development of the other members of the squad, for starters. It reduces your efficiency because point gets burnt out if used repeatedly - and that endangers EVERYONE in your squad when number one man goes down because he goes through charging room after room after room and gets careless, ends up getting hit.

I've been in MOUT and I know firsthand the LAST sort of person I want to clear rooms with is someone like you - who "isn't afraid to die". Because when you actually do charge ahead on point, ignoring commands, and get hit? Guess who has to now step over you, screaming for dear life, in the fatal funnel and deal with the threat. Not you. Definitely not you.

Then again, the chances you're actually military are low, low, low. I dare you to prove otherwise. Not that it matters.

You're not a Soldier. You're just a fraud.


timer
A good soldier gets the job done, he does not think that he is God.


Ridgely
Rating
NO that makes you a casualty, get with the program any assault or tac. is a TEEM effort! DROP and give me twenty five !


away.laughing.on.a.fast.camel
Crazy. I don't think it makes you a good soldier. It's all well and good your ready to fight but most times fear of dying is what keeps most people alive, and sane. Like your not scared to go into an unchecked place, well you go marching in and there is heavy fire power or a bomb, you die. But a scared person will be a little more concerned with thier life and wait for it to be checked or whatever. And hey, they live.


Incorrectly Political
Rating
The best soldiers are the ones who are afraid to die, but do what they must anyway. It is a good thing to do your job without hesitation, but being unafraid causes you to take stupid risks that WILL get you killed.


breeze32461
The first time you get shot at, All that will change.


Ali
Rating
It doesn't make you a bad soldier at all. In fact, it could help you and your squad if you are less afraid. But if you are afraid, that's ok because it makes you an even better soldier for going out and fighting even if you dont want to die.
Whether you're a good or bad soldier isnt based on if you are afraid of death or not.


LadyRebecca
Rating
We can see your Q&A History you know


Dick Skinner
Wellllll, it's hypothetical, but if it were reality, you'd be either crazy or stupid. By being unafraid to die, and not afraid to enter an unchecked building. Fear's not to be denied. It's a natural defense mechanism. It causes adrenaline, and makes the nervous system (including reflexes) go into overdrive. This is the principle behind the "quick and the dead" cliche. Someone who's too dumb to be scared, or too nuts to care about death is almost certain to get himself, and those around him dead, and quickly. Going above and beyond is'nt the same thing at all though. I think Mark Twain said it best: "Courage is'nt the absence of fear, it's mastery of one's fear. Bravery is defined by those who do what must be done though they're terrified to their very core." or words to that effect.


quickblur
Um no, it just makes you dumb. You're probably going to be a liability if you keep talking like that.


ZigZag
No it makes you a dum one.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Question for my fellow Britons... I keep seeing Americans say if it wasn't for us we'd all be talking German..
but in all seriousness, right now, if we lost our independence would you rather lose it to America or Germany.... I must admit I'm swaying heavily toward Germany.
Additional Details<...


 Do soldiers who die in iraq go to hell?
I mean killing is wrong period so will they go to hell? I am not trying to offend anyone but it's just something that I have thought about.

PS: I do support our troops for making such ...


 Do you think the conflict between Russia and Georgia over South Ossetia will develop into a larger scale war?
Vinay Shukla Moscow, Aug 8 (PTI) Russia today sent tanks and troops to South Ossetia after Georgia launched a major military offensive to reclaim the breakaway republic, triggering heavy street ...


 What will result if Iran uses nuclear weapons to destroy Israel?
...


 Is my country strongest in the World?
I'm Chinese living in Shanghai (one of the most populous cities in the World)

And I'm wondering if we already are the strongest in this World.

Economically and ...


 Navy or Army. What is the best to enjoy and do not have the risk to be on the front line in one war?
I am thinking about my kids in the future if they decide to go for one of them.

I would like to have as much information as I can to give for them....


 Im a soldier and i see we are doing alot of good in iraq since i been here. why are we getting no support?
I know people say they support the troops and all, but dont the american public know that when they keep the media attention on getting us out then it only screws up progress? i see the good we are ...


 Do you wear a poppy?
...


 Should we send more troops to Iraq to finish what we started?
When Iraq attacked us on 9/11/01, we responded by going to war; we responded by going to wipe out the threat that presented itself to us. Now we've been pulling troops out, and trying to fight ...


 Who even likes Americans any more???
...


 I don't want to sound anti American here but........?
What gives America the right to tell other countries to get rid of their nuclear weapons? Doesn't America have a very large arsenal of nukes of it's own?

Plus, America are the ...


 Would America win a war against England?
I think not as they are incapable of hitting the target and would probably blow Australia instead....


 What did my husband die for?
I and my husband, a brave American soldier, had been married 25 years when he was killed in Iraq while deployed with the Army National Guard. I don't support this war. I don't believe what ...


 I forked out £1.60p for my poppy. How much do you pay for your poppy?
Only for them scots as did die though....


 Why are soldiers being paid so much? It encourages laziness!?
I would like to go back to the days when soldiers wouldn't be paid so much, they're taking advantage of our war on terrorism to make "careers" for themselves. The problem is, by ...


 Whats the difference between a Muslim extremist and a right wing conservative?
...


 Do only poor people join the military?
I think that if one cannot afford college, either entering the job market or joining the military are both options. What do you think? Why would a rich white kid from Orange County join the Army?...


 Did I ask the wrong question when I was talking with this United states Marine?
He told me this morning (At the Big Boy Restaurant) he was going to Iraq in Dec. I ask "Why are you going to Iraq when Iraq did not do 9-11 and is no threat to the USA". The Marines said.......


 If he's fighting in Iraq, why is he always on myspace???
My ex is infantry and in Iraq. I thought he was over there fighting hard but he seems to be able to log onto his myspace almost daily. He posts some jokes, changes his profile around and add new ...


 Do you think the're gonna have a draft for war in iraq?
.. scary.... my brothers 19... and my mom doesnt want to go.. disasterr and my mom says if he does we'll move to canada!!!! ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Tuesday, May 29, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.074