Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Military

How do soldiers deal with emotions when involved in a real battle situation ?
Find answers to your legal question.





How do soldiers deal with emotions when involved in a real battle situation ?

I understand how training is used to help a soldier to deal with a situation of actual combat, but struggle to take in the amount of emotion that goes through the mind of a soldier that comes face to face with killing an enemy whether dropping bombs or using a bayonet, before and after the event


    




Lillian
Rating
Now you know why basic is a *****. It's getting you ready. Nothing can make you 100% prepared, but it can help. Training, training, training.


The White Rose
You don't use a bayonet anymore.

Mostly it's mass confusion, fear, LOTS of noise and many just crap in their pants---perfectly natural reaction.

You could start a fire fight and "wake up" 20 minutes later with bare feet and no rifle. You have no idea how you will react. Some laugh like crazymen.

It's not like the movies or what you read on these boards I can tell you that much.

Everyone's different and every situation is different. Things happen so fast it's hard to react rationally.

The better your NCOs the better off you are as then can sometimes straighten you out and get you functioning.


Gerry Atrix
Rating
In ACTUAL combat you are too busy to be scared.
After combat in a lull or quiet time it scares the hell out of you.

A loud bang concentrates the mind and constricts the bowels wonderfully.


Hank H
Rating
You have to psch yourself into the mission, oblvious to what is around you, youdo it 4 your country, like the perverbial 1000yard stare.


Ginger D
They go through a lot of debriefing and also have mental health professionals to help one on one. I think their debriefings deal with the combat as well as what each one may or may not have experienced personally. There is so much talk about PTSD these days, and the military is really trying to step up and help our guys and gals out.

From my observations of my husband, I think most of them sort of shut off some of their emotions so that they can detach or desensitize themselves from their surroundings and/or experiences. Its kind of like a switch that he turns back on once he is home and safe.


frank_blandori thunder88
Rating
well your scared and your heart beats real fast then your mouth gets way dry and you think of your family and look around you and wonder who maybe next or even worst if its your day or will you loose a leg or both arms and the list goes on, but during the firefight its really to fast to explain and so much happens in such a short time! and when the medic is called and they yell out a friends name you get real pissed and want some *** now and if they bag that person and you see that dark plastic bag that holds a man you partyed with or read a family letter with it can damage your very soul! the hurt lasts for years and so do the funny memories, now as for hand to hand combat i have never seen it but i have seen them in the bush and the muzzel flash and the mud fly up around me and the boys.its all bad and the sound of metal hitting a human body is a very sick sound! and then make it back to the base camp and inside the bunker for the night and then to do it again in a day or so, well you figure it out and lets not forget now we have to place your bros items in a box or foot locker and gather all there personal items to send home, where once life once layed now only a darkness stays and then in a few days a new man arrives and it starts all over again. this is what i had to deal with in 1969!


blissman
Soldiers are trained in a lot of ways, from unarmed combat to evading capture.
But they are not trained to deal with the emotional scars after killing a man.
When out on the field it is kill or be killed, the majority of the time you will never see the people you have killed as it is long range fighting, but it is a different ball game when you have to kill a man who is right in front of you.
To see the skull explode in front of your eyes, blood, bone and brain splattering on you and the nearby walls, feeling the warmth of the thick gunge as it drips down your face.
Staring into someones eyes as you cover their mouth to stop them screaming as you plunge a knife under the enemies sternum, twisting the blade into the heart, hoping for a quick kill.
All the training in the world does not prepare you for what you see and really do out there...you either learn to live with it or you crack up....
How strong are you?
This used to be called 'shell shock', now the government agree that it is now called 'post traumatic stress'.
The human brain can only handle so much horror before shutting down.
But..there are a lot of offers for counselling to help soldiers who can no longer cope.


The joker without makeup
well some soilders like in nam do not get over it and they become killers because they could not handle seeing dead bodies ect, the way to deal with it is be cold hearted that is really the only way if you can leak your emotions out then your fine.


GHampshire
Rating
u have just got to think just put all the bad thoughts to the back of your head focus your emotions in to killing the enemy


Shoot4TheMoon
It depends on the soldier. Everyone handles things differently. Some become more attached to their loved ones, some become more distant. No on can comprehend the emotion they go through except for the ones who have lived it. I do not envy them, it is not an easy life.


Jamie
repent and reload.


news hound
,the only emotion present with highly trained soldier in face to face contact with the enemy Is kill or be killed, that is why they train so strenuously. it does not mean of course, they do not show any emotion subsequent to the battle they do, -often- if they do not, then there is something radically wrong and it will be spotted, and dealt with, that is what the seniors are also there for.


K.T.S.
Rating
its a case of get on with life or go down its hard but you have to fight


TheHitcher
Rating
a soldier has to visualise thier fears, and emotions, and then shoot the **** out of it.


Emanuel A
yes becouse they miet die and they will miss there family and the family is going to miss them.


It's That Guy
Well-trained soldiers act more or less mechanically. They make them practice running up to a dummy and bayonetting it, and when they do this with a person they are not really thinking 'Hey, that's a PERSON!' Often it is a matter of kill or be killed.

The great majority of killing in wars today is impersonal. You never see the victim. Pilots fly over 'coordinates' and drop their bombs. They never know who or how many they kill. It's one reason we try to conduct all our wars from the air and with long-distance artillery, etc., cruise missiles, etc.


trish s
A real soldier can't afford emotion.........................





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Who will win an all-out nuclear war: Russia or US?

Additional Details
haha. Australia, very funny. I say China will win. lol....


 Do you think the USA will put the draft back into affect because of the war?
...


 Why do the Amercan youngsters think only they fought in the second world war?
The action where the Cambletown rammed the lock gates at St. Nanziarre when my daughter was at school an american boy thought only usa troops took part and his father tild him American pilots were ...


 When Scotland gets its independence, will we see a return of all those glorious kilted Highland Regiments?
...


 Friend wants out of the USMC?
he wants out weather it be good or bad I told him just to smoke weed and they just kick him out
is smoking weed and poppin the piss test a fur sure way to get out or ...


 Do u like war?
...


 How do you think China would deal with Terrorists who venture into their country?
China seems to be one of the very few countries in the World that hasn't terrorist attack in their country.

What do you think would happen to the terrorists who venture into China and ...


 Why are we in war with Iraq and not Afghanistan?
To many people are getting killed in Iraq and we shouldn't have gone over there in the first. So why did we go over there?...


 How has the Iraq war benefited the Middle East?
Or the US for that matter?...


 Which do you think was the most brutal war for soldiers to endure.?
Personally, I think it was WWI. Check out this video of he physical and psychological aftermath on some of the troops.

http://www.youtube.com/w...


 How often do you soldiers get told thank you by a complete stranger on the street?
Just curious. By the way, thank you guys so much for protecting this great country! You have no idea how much respect I have for you guys!

Thanks for answering!
Additional Details...


 Would wars be quite so barbaric if leaders had to put members of their own family in the front line.?
...


 Theres a movement now to ban all adult mags on military bases--do you agree or disagree? Is this another?
attempt to legislate morality?

when I was in the AF, the guys (and gals) all read Playboy and Penthouse, etc-----whats the big deal?...


 Where you will drop an Atom Bomb?
If you have an atom bomp and a right to drop wherever you like. Where do you drop the Bomb?...


 Shall I join the army?
I am 18 and I am miserable, I have considered and tryed committing suicide many times. I wanna run away from my problems and kind of get away from life, do you think joining the army would be the ...


 How much is a WWII Nazi Flag worth?
During WWII, when my grandpa was in Berlin, he stole 2 quite large Nazi flags. My grandpa recently passed away and we got the flags. We're thinking of selling them, but we don't know how ...


 Why do I think that liberal anti-war folks did this?
http://www.chicagotribun
Marine Sgt. Michael McNulty -- now on his way to Iraq for his second tour of duty in the war -- took ...


 If someone has been shooting at you, trying to kill you, is it still WRONG to shoot them in the back?
...


 When you say "Marine Corps" is the 'P' silent?
cause when people say Marine Corps it sounds like they're saying Marine Core....


 Patriotic question?
Is anyone as proud to be an American as I am? Our president is doing an amazing job, I'm so glad we have a president is so compassionate towards middle easterners and immigrants, is doing such a ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Tuesday, May 29, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.024