Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Military

I remember one incident in Marine boot camp, we were at the rifle range, one of the junior drill instructors..
Find answers to your legal question.





I remember one incident in Marine boot camp, we were at the rifle range, one of the junior drill instructors..

wanted to sit down on a bench but saw the bench was dirty. he called two recruits over and made them sit down and clean the bench with their rear ends. i know this is a crazy question but did the drill instructor break some rule by doing this?


    




Barry auh2o
Rating
It's called discipline and conditioning.
Did they do it without giving it a second thought, or did they write letters to their mommies???


Brad V
Rating
No! Recruits are lower than whale dung, they have no voice and are not deserving of consideration. This example clearly illustates how DI's break down the will of the recruit, so that he can be reborn into a US Marine. Semper Fidelis !


lestermount
Rating
If you really went to boot camp you understand that nothing a d.i. does is breaking any rules.
Having a couple of privates clean off a bench is hardly against any rule.


ziggyman
Rating
that's hysterical! no, not illegal. didn't break any rules. i'm retired military (24 years) and that is one of the funniest war stories i've ever heard. thanks!


Ahhtchoo
Haha, that's great. No, he didn't break a rule. (Unless they had to clean it and were begging for water and he denied it, had a no-booty-scrubbing profile, or got perforated eardrums from him screaming at them.)


Mike B
Rating
It's not against any rules and it actually teaches recruits to follow instructions without question.

You may have thought there was no reason behind what the DI did, but it's a matter of making people follow until they are trained enough to be leaders.


frenchy62
LOL.....no, there was no breaking of any rules there. The incident you mention is actually quite routine. That's pretty tame compared to many things that take place at Boot Camp.


aimlessarmydude
Rating
no


jellybelly
Rating
LOL, no. They are supposed to make your life miserable.


Billy
Rating
nah

as long as their health isnt in jeopardy, the DI can do anything he wants


WM
That's hilarious. Instills a bit of humility in them. Love Barry's reply, too. Anchors Aweigh!


Kojak
Rating
I was a DI......While I would question the Jr DI's judgment.......no it was not "illegal"......just childish.

My rule......Everything I did carried a lesson.....something the 'meathead' needed to learn......there was no useful lesson taught here.....

I had another DI inspect my barracks..... during the debriefing he said, " I nuked private XXXXX wallocker'.....I said ok......what was wrong with the wallocker?.....He replied nothing.....i just did it......I threw him out of my barracks never to be allowed to return.... you use power for a purpose, NEVER just because you have it


The White Rose
Rating
No, I think it's pretty funny.


Bill
It was a poor example, but within legal bounds for recruit training.

MSgt, USAF (Retired)


realist
Get the hell out of the Marines you little wussy. WAAAAAA. I bet you need to see a psychologist after that tough one. Just wait until you get to Iraq. If this is horrible, you are in for an awakening. Hopefully you are just a paper pushing POG


NSA
Rating
No. Discipline takes many forms.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 What is your opinion: Keep troops in Iraq, or bring them home?
Tell me your reasoning....


 9 US helicopters had been shot down by Iraqi resistance in only one month .What does that mean?
I want your opinion from military and political point of view.And will this developement accelerate the USA withdrawel from Iraq?...


 How can a girl join army?
...


 Why can't I go over to Iraq to fight? At 43 I can still run and shoot.?
Why does our military practice age discrimination when "old men" in the middle east can fight? I'm ready. Let us fight and keep our kids home!
Additional Details
Your ...


 Bush's Iraq policy? Right or Wrong?
I watched Bush's news conference today, and it was basically about staying the course. If the current Iraq policy do not work and the American soldiers die every month, why can't Bush ...


 EU vs USA - all out WAR?
Who is your opinion would win, the combined states of the member states of the European military or the USA military, maybe 10, 20 years ago there would be no chance for europe but times have now ...


 Should Prince Harry be serving on the frontline in Afghanistan?
...


 Is war the only option to end terriosm?should india attack pakistan for killing so many people in mumbai?
...


 How deep do military security clearances go?
Just out of curiosity?...


 Is Kathy Evans, the single dumbest contestant to ever get on "Who Wants To Be A Millionaire?"?
NEW YORK - Idaho resident Kathy Evans brought humiliation to her friends and family Tuesday when she set a new standard for stupidity with her appearance on the popular TV show, "Who Wants To Be ...


 Do you get piss tested at Army A.I.T.?
I have a friend going back to AIT who smoked weed. Do they test you there?...


 Isn't it true that no one likes Americans? They trrail death wherever they go.?

Additional Details
I see they are killing targets in Somalia today, and anyone nearby...how can you like a killer of babies and women, a mass murderer?...


 If you could send the president George Bush to Iraq and make him Fight with are military would you send him.?
...


 What is the most powerful weapon ever used in war?
Besides the Atomic Bomb?...


 Coming soon -- another chance for "President" Bush to prove himself to be a pathological LIAR?
Earlier this year, Bush promised that if Iraq told us we should leave, then we would get out of there. Today, Paul Harvey reported that three major studies were conducted independently of each other,...


 Why are military helicopters flying over my house?
I live between 2 Airforce bases, and I have seen at least 2 military planes flying together each day. Today, however, there are military helicopters flying overhead. I have seen 5 so far, is it the ...


 Can peace be restored if the US government depart Iraq?
...


 Can i stay with my boyfriend in the barracks...
(in the marines) can i visit/stay in the barracks with him when he gets stationed somewhere?
if no, do girls do it anyway?
and if i get a hotel room can he just stay in it with me rather ...


 Do you think it's good to pull out early?
In Iraq?...


 Why did this woman remove her "My son is serving in Iraq" off her car?
Had this large Decal on her back window on her SUV. Today, I noticed it was gone and she has a "The war in Iraq is wrong". Should I ask why she changed her mind?...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Tuesday, May 29, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.034