Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Military

If a foreign force invades your country and you fight them are you a terrorist or a patriot?
Find answers to your legal question.





If a foreign force invades your country and you fight them are you a terrorist or a patriot?



    




leedo2502
Rating
It's semantics... History will decide and history is written by the victors. although how you choose to fight can decide how you are judged also. If you target civilians and ignore military targets you aren't fighting with honor.


mike L
patriot defending your country


solace3290
A patriot will stand up to defend his country soil ..else he should be called a coward.


arsenik
Rating
You are a patriot - unless the country you're defending is not the USA. Then you're a terrorist.


missingora
Rating
Every country has the right and responsibility to its citizens to protect itself. If you protect your country and fellow citizens, you are a patriot.


idontkno
patriot


Ryan
Rating
patriot...if some foreign force entered my country i fight like theres no tomorrow. I'd beat there ****


jellogiggle
i know right? i'm tired of the double standards


chris
Rating
if ur the person asking this question are u stupid? yes i think so!


Ananke402
A foreign force on your soil - patriot
A foreign force on their soil- terrorist
A domestic force on your soil- terrorist
A domestic force that wins on your soil- patriot

If America hadn't won the Revolution, George Washington would've been labeled a terrorist and hung for treason.


Mas S
Rating
If you are American or friends == its ok
if you are not American or friends == you are a terrorist

We re-define double standards!!


happy_jean
patriot or maybe I just want to live. And it depends on if your side wins or not.


Nuke Iran
That depends on if your a terroist nation or not


Captain W
You will never get the correct response. It depends on which globe you ask that question.


knmardix
It depends on what you did before they invaded. If you are killing their civilians and provoke them to invade then you are a terrorist. If they invade unprovoked and you are defending your homeland then you are a patriot


jamie
Rating
If they come in for no reason whatsoever.. unprovoked.. then you'd be a patriot, fighting for your homeland.
Unfortunately, that doesn't apply in Lebanon.

If there wasn't so much bias in your question, you might get an answer that doesn't talk down to you...but that doesn't apply either.


cashcobra_99
JUST GIVE THEIR DAMN SOLIDER BACK!


Mahyar
In fact you are a Patriot. but it depends. If the country which is attacking you is: The USA or Israel then you are not more than a terrorist. this is the way the world thinks!


gimpalomg
Well I wouldn't be a terrorist. I would attack the invading force. I would not put an explosive vest on my grandchild and send her to ride the bus with the other kids.

I wouldn't be an insurgent because I am indigenous.

Being a patriot is a subjective term and in your reality I doubt anyone who took direct action (pulled a trigger) would qualify. Unless of course, they were invading America or killing Americans here or abroad.

I would be a guerrilla. I would wear no uniform (there goes my protection under the Geneva Convention). Just like our captives in every war were not protected. I would hit and run. I would damage anything I could to slow or stop in invaders progress. And I would watch my back closely for you and others like you.

Good day!


tjc
Good question. I suppose when we invaded France we could have been considered terrorist according to some of those above and Germany in WWII .... Hypothetical questions like this one seems to bring out the anger in America haters who like to give their uninformed position. The tendency to think in small terms tends to keep a person from seeing the overall picture. If you would look at all the attacks on the US by Hezbollah and Ha mas since 1979, I think you would agree they are a Terrorist organization. Israel is the only country w/ the guts to stand up for itself. They are patriots to defend their country. We always feel sorry for the underdog which this seems like the case. But it isn't. The Hezbo's are a proxy for another country, Iran. If I was told I wasu need to be wiped off the face of the earth, I would do exactly what Israel is doing now. In truth they are the underdog in this fight. From the nature of your question, it seems you have been victimized by the anti-Israel media. Read some of Clausewitz's The Art of war and you'll understand what the fight is about.


kenhallonthenet
Rating
That depends, if that foreign force is UK, American or Israeli, and you fight it you are a terrorist, if not, then you are a freedom fighting patriot.


Simple. Why does anyone not get that double standard?


rab2344
Depends on who's side you ask.


doc
Rating
there's a difference when the so called country being invaded uses the killing of civillians as some sort of way to drive out the so called invading country. if they fought with some degree of respect for innocent lives, thier countrymen, then yes they would be patriotic. but since they kill innocent civillians, they don't respect their fellow countrymen and therefore don't respect their country. this would make them a terrorist. also if you're implying iraq in some way, to let you know almost more than half of the insurgents fighting american troops aren't even from iraq. so hence that wouldn't make them a patriot, but a terrorist. hope that helps.


aliajao
Patriot ,why will someone invade and expect you to be looking as fool, will America allow invasion of cuba for keeping the man that wanted to kill castro as self defence , hahahahahahaha


JDAM
Rating
Terrorism requires an at of terror, usually a shock and awe concept

Defending your country and fighting for the thing u believe in can be considered patriotic


Cyrus
a patriot, but if you're a terrorist before the invasion then you're kinda both.


revolution is brewing
If you are holding your own country hostage and some one comes and to free you from that they are the good guys and you are the terrorist.


^2q2Bstr8
fight them back!! this cannot go forever. i sure that there is a higher force ,no matter how it is called, that will put a balance into this. i know you know what i am talking about


HHH
You would be nothing but something fighting for a country,governments dont care about hteir people.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 What is a good military career for me?
I want to enlist in an armed force (Navy, Army, Air Force, Coast Guard, or Marines), but am not sure which one. I am enlisting to become a more disciplined, stronger person, to gain and learn career ...


 Why did u.s join the fighting in WW2?
i want the real reason not just pearl ...


 I'm thinking about joining the military (navy, because its easiest and air force waiting list is too long)....
Let me know your opinion about this, I just quit my job and need money because school is starting soon and I dont have the money and wont unless someone else pays for it (yeah right). If i sign up ...


 When Americans claim they "bailed us out" of WWII, what about the Aussies?
What about the Aussies, the New Zealanders and other allied troops who laid down their lives? The Indians and other troops from all over the commonwealth who also fought?

The Battle of B...


 Which would hurt more?
being shot in the neck at close range or falling off a moving tank at 40 mph ?
Additional Details
say you were shot by a 9mm I ask this question because I was the person that fell from a ...


 What is your opinion?
what do u think about people who hate America or make fun of it, although they live here
Additional Details
i know alot of people say were lazy. if thata was true, then why do we have ...


 What is your attutude towards women in the army?
Should women be allowed in the army? I, personally, am in the reserves but if I were making the laws, I wouldn't allow women in the army. We aren't as strong as men, physically or ...


 Would you let your child join the army.......?
.....having the possibility to be sent to a war? I mean would you try to talk him/her out of joining the army? I know you can't stop them as they are adults at that time but would you try? It ...


 Should yobs face national service? I say a spell in the army will sort out these council estate scumbags?
Last night as I was returning home from the theatre I decided to take a short cut through a local council estate and to be frank the sight that greeted me was appalling, a complete chavalanche of ...


 Do I choose the U.S. Army or girlfriend?
I was in the U.S. Army and foolishly got out not too long ago.I really want to join the U.S. Army again but my mom and girlfriend is against it and it is really pissing me off that they are trying ...


 What is THE BEST BRANCH OF SERVICE?
...


 What is your instant reaction when you hear/read that someone in the military has died in Iraq or Afghanistan?
...


 Which Country Has The Best Trained Military Forces In The World?
...


 How would you feel serving along side another man or woman in the military who was gay?

Additional Details
I do believe, at least in this area, the general acceptance of the population is growing up!
There is hope after all!!!!!!...


 Is G.Bush sane?
President of USA due to his international policies......


 What are the advantages of going to college vs. staying in the military for 20 years?
...


 In my country(I live in Poland - middle Europe) most people think that USA is agressor(Iraq)?
USA are necessary in the world, only USA are able to fight whit terrorist, beceause Europa is weak. We don't have good army and gov. The people are scared(especialy after terrorist atack in M...


 If Aliens arrived and blew up the united states would you be upset?
...


 Which animal would be best to fire from a cannon?
If beseiging a castle, which animal if fired from a cannon would be most useful. I'm thinking tortoises, armadillos or maybe guinea pigs with explosive crash helmets on?...


 Why are women not allowed to be in combat units such as infantry, armor or artillary?
Relating to present-day and the war in Iraq......




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Tuesday, May 29, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.034