Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Military

If fought today, would the US still win WW2?
Find answers to your legal question.





If fought today, would the US still win WW2?

With the extensive press coverage and editorials on the war that covers the news now, would we have won the war? Or would the military spend a good bit of its time trying to passify the press and public at home at the cost of military success?

Would the atomic bombs be dropped?
Additional Details
For the first two posters, I am well aware we were not the only country fighting. However, to eliminate posts related to the governments, press, and civilians views of war from other countries I have directed this solely to the involvement of the US.
I'm more interested in what my country thinks about this..


    




someguyacrosstown
Rating
hell no. the US today is a bunch of sissies. i joined the navy thinking i was going to be a drunken sailor who got in barfights and risked his life for this country. it turns out the navy is pretty much ran by oprah and dr phil.


artilleryman89
Rating
The allies held the Nazi's off, but they had no chance till the U.S opened a second front in France. And no the pess would be to crazy over everything.


Joshua M
if was'nt the us who won the war, it was the allies.


MiMi Sugar
Rating
I think with the US as it is today we would have lost!!! My son is in the military a lifer serving God and Country!!! Is he appreciated no way!!! He was home on a leave and he never says where he has been or who he is. When out with my son in law the bartender who knew him said hey hey thanks ---- for all you've done great to see you home. He went to the bath room not expecting any trouble and a national guard guy came in and blind sided him from the rear knocked him out with saying he never got any free drinks!!!

The USA must have a strong military and the news needs to stop telling all the negative!!! More people are killed in NEW YORK in a day then a day in Bagdad or Iraq!!! If we had not sent our troops in there would've been more bombings here I'm sure!!!! Think about a football game and more places that would've been bombed!!!

My son sends me pictures of the troops praying together, the people there that show their appreciation, and more!!! He is now in Afganistan (Sky Soldier) People talk about being political correct!!!! From the beginning this country was built on God. That's why all of the buildings in Washington have the ten commandments on them. Think about what the commandents are!!! ! Ten rules that all men no matter what there beliefs should live by!!
Sorry, I'm talking to much!!! something just get me going!!!! I don't feel we are a United country anymore. We need to bet back to the basics!! By coming here we are a mixture of hertiage and different backgrounds but bottom line we came here to be Americans a melting pot of all but leaving that behind have chosen to be Americans!!!


omega2221981
Rating
Being an American I can honestly say that the Allies won the war not just The US but they wouldn't have without our involvement. This question can't be answered accurately because WW2 changed everything. First of all The US wasn't considered a world power before WW2 and if it weren't for our involvement in the war we might have never reached that status. Second a large amount of the engineers and scientists that helped us develop the Atomic Bomb were not born in the US and came here to escape the tyranny of the the Axis Powers, so we might not have had the Bomb to drop. I say be happy thing turned out the way they did & dont worry about what if's.


Jim H
i'm afraid not.considering all the crying that goes on about the number of military and civilians that have died. the battle of the bulge or omaha beach or during bombing raids would have had us pulling out.
we just don't have the resolve anymore.i'm so thankful for those who did were alive then.


syracusecadet
Rating
It'd be tough. We'd fight but I'm not sure we'd drop the bombs. Today Pearl Harbor would still tick off enough Americans to stick with it for a while and today, unlike in the 40's we have a way stronger military than any other country BY FAR! All in all it would still be a slugfest, but we'd wn hands down.


bossdave
Rating
It should, but it makes you wonder, seeing how long Iraq & Afghanstan are dragging out. Technology advances should shorten the time fighting drastically but somehow we still get mired in it.


Winter Glory
well first off it wasn't the US that won ww2 it was the allied forces which included the US-
however given the political corectness of today's society the a bomb would never have been dropped and it's hard to predict what all the media hoopla surrounding it would have done as far as the outcome


NIFman
Rating
good question
I do think history would repeat itself
as for who won, when a giant is woken up from a slumber it has a terrible resolve That still would hold true today
if the enemies were still the same
but the weapons would be alot different
and the need for the Atomic bomb may could be avoided
because of jets, better guns, tanks,
FYI more ppl were kiled by convential warfare then with radioactivity or nuclear weapons


allen555
If they arrived a bit earlier, rather than wait to see the British Exchequer bled dry of money standing alone, the war would finish two years early. The USA watched Britain go broke because they wanted to kill the British Empire and create their own. They now have troops stationed all round the world. Suez in '56 was the last straw. USA broke British and French colonial domination by demanding they pull out. Now who supports Israel? I am not anti American, I am pro history and the facts speak for themselves.


Bob K
Rating
I checked, and Yes we would still win, but it would be very close. Godzilla however would not beat King Kong though, this time the Kong takes him out. Oh, and Alexander the Great? He would only be Alexander the average.


conranger1
Rating
Your question follows a a common American misconception.

The USA did not win W.W.2. ALONE

they were part of a team called the Allies.

While we thank you for your help you were not the only ones involved in WW2.


Bear Walling
As far as the European Theater...

Assuming that WWII was fought today, and Hitler knew know what he knew then, and knowing how the outcome would be... We would be screwed.

As far as the Pacific Theater...
We would be frigged from the word "Go"

As far as "Would the atomic bombs be dropped?"...
No, NATO and the UN would step in and point their fingers and say that the US is a very bad boy and to go to its room for thinking of such a horrible thing.


none
You bet, we have way more bombs than the 2 we used.


pierric
Rating
You as well as some people answering here seem to forget one BIG fact,which is always forgotten by the bush fans or sympathizers.
In WW2,japan and germany declared war on the USA.
The iraq war was a unilateral US agression based on disgusting lies by the white house.


We won! 20 Jan 09 (Erudite)
No way would we have won. (62 years ago YES!...Not now) The USA can't beat a group of insurgents now in Iraq. And they (Insurgents) use basic weapons.


mh15
yes


Kestril
Rating
The US would win WWII like it already has the war in Iraq.
The US is now fighting insurgents ,( the Iraqi people who were on Saddam's side.) There weren't many insurgents in Germany , most were glad the war was over .


ross
Let's not fight any more wars...we already have two now that the media is not doing a very good job of reporting on. Plus the fact that keeps getting swept under the rug that 9/11 was an inside job.


Daniel
Hate to bust your bubble boys but the us didnt win the second world war. Russa won the war. Sure the us and the commonweath held a front at normandy but russia front was over 3 million men. compared to to 750000 us and commonweath men. RUSSIA HAD THE WAR WON WELL BEFORE THE US LANDED in normandy. Its funny how the us media dosent point out this glaring fact.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Who won in Iraq war?
pls don't relpy as iraq or usa
Additional Details
If someone noticed it's who won in iraq war not who won the war in iraq.It' retoric at all senses.Anyway i've chosen ...


 If they'd have kept their eyes shut?
They'd have one that war?

What do you think?...


 What u think of iraqi shoe thrower?

Additional Details
Thanks for sharing all your opinions.
In my humble opinion I really look up to that man Muntazar Al-Zaidi, mostly refered to as the infamous shoe thrower. At ...


 Why does the US have 120,000 nuclear weapons?
...


 Are there Muslim soldiers in the US army?
i mean fighting muslim against another muslims country is a big sin but not listenin to their leaders is a big sin too
i mean if theres a muslim american was born there raised there and happened ...


 I am in the Army Do you think i am dumb and cant read?
http://newsbusters.org/b
i cant read.........another Stephen King book again
A...


 Is the UN Afraid? Why no action against Israel..?
I quote from BBC .....UN peacekeepers in south Lebanon contacted Israeli troops 10 times before an Israeli bomb killed four of them, an initial UN report says.
The post was hit by a precision-...


 My Husband is in the army. He is in basic tranning and he wants out does any one know if he can quite?
...


 What was the best tank of the second world war?
I would say the Russian T34
Additional Details
Actually the tigers in Kellys heros were converted t34s made to look like ...


 Is Iraq worth it?
I say yes.

http://www.timesonline.c...


 Do the Republicans know the Vietnam war was lost under a Republican President?
Source: CNN. President Ford made the Marines and Army run like scared dogs on 30th April 1975. Thanks Republicans....


 Why are we losing so many Americans ( soldiers ) in Iraq in just one day?
Military News:.. U.S. casualties will rise in next 90 days, Commander says.
The U.S. military announced the deaths of 11 U.S. soldiers killed in combat along with an embedded journalist Sunday, ...


 I Could die in the military?
I've been deciding whether or not to join the navy for a long time. I eventually pretty much decided and want to be a Gunner's Mate. I brought up the subject of the military to my mom the ...


 Am I wrong for not thinking this is funny?
I have members of every military branch in my family. when we all get together we usaully laugh at each other, jokingly putting the other branch down. The other day I read an answer to a question in ...


 Whom do you consider to be the greatest American military man (army,navy,air force) in history?

Additional Details
My own choice would be admiral Nimitz, for his perfect naval tactics and victories against equal odds and for the breadth of imagination in his plans....


 What is the longist US war?
...


 Why are people quick to down talk the Military but can't thank a Soldier for their freedom of speech?
I'm tired of these uninformed rejects (Sunsar Taylor & Co.)running their mouths about the Military! Hey sweetheart... you don't stand behind me and my brothers & sisters at arms???...


 Which war claimed the lives of the most US soldiers???
...


 Do you think the Government should bring back National Service to keep the teenage crime figures down?
...


 Which is the best military branch to go in?
...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Tuesday, May 29, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.034