Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Military

Is It True That Mostly Poor People Join The Armed Forces?
Find answers to your legal question.





Is It True That Mostly Poor People Join The Armed Forces?

Sarah Palin, John McCain, and Joe Biden are rich and all their kids are in the armed forces.


    




Bear
Rating
Mostly middle class. I'm a under educated trust fund baby and I still did my service 22+ years


JK
Rating
The military isn't a money making business. People who join the military come from all sorts of places and income levels. The one thing they all have in common though, is that they want to serve their country and I thank every single one of them for it.


Gaz
Rating
A good part of it does. I come from a middle to upper class family, and I enlisted in the military.


Bill R
Rating
no, income has nothing to do with it, however a lot of middle to upper class kids believe they are too good to join the military and think they are entitled to a pampered life style, most middle to upper class kids who think this way usually are raised by liberals and taught by liberals


beno_83au
Rating
No. There's a good spread of all levels of society. I had a guy in my section whos father is a very prominent doctor and this guy virtually lives off his parents even though he's in. The army, or at least at battalion level, has a very diverse range of people from all of society. It's like taking the population and condensing it to a few hundred people and leaving out the pacifists and all those do-nothing types. But that's the Australian army.


Jared P
Rating
it depends on which level you are talking about and what branch. the enlistment ranks are usually not as rich, but the officer ranks you have to be a college graduate.


RKA
They probably went in as officers.
The military is a good way to start a career. A lot of poor people go in the service because it is a way to get a college education or to simply have a job. Colin Powell for example


uscg_recruiter
NO - It is not true:

October 31, 2006
US Military Recruits From All Classes, Races
Filed under: Science, War — Robert @ 1:54 pm

Some conventional tropes of critics of the American military:

* the military draws mostly or disproportionately from the poorest Americans

* the military draws disproportionately from minority populations

* the military draws disproportionately from the poorly educated

All wrong.

The median household income for recruits is slightly higher than the national median.

The top income quintile provides 22.85% of the recruits; the bottom quintile provides 13.66%. (Suggestion to the critics: switch your argument to an inquiry into why the poorest Americans feel so alienated from their country, they won’t even fight for it.)

Racial statistics are a little harder to pithily summarize, but basically the military is ethnically representative of the country. Blacks, who were over-represented by about 17% a few years ago, are now under-represented by about 4%. Pacific Islanders are the most over-represented group, with a whopping 649% over-representation. Asians are the most under-represented, at 69% of proportionality. Those groups are relatively tiny; the Big Three are all close to 1.0.

Educationally, the military considers a “high quality” recruit to be a high school graduate who scored above the 50% on the Armed Forces standardized test. The proportion of high-quality recruits has gone from 57 percent in 2001 to 64% last year (down slightly from 67% in 2004). Category IV recruits (essentially the “let’s give them a chance but not have high hopes” cohort) are 4.4% of total recruits.

The one piece of conventional wisdom that’s accurate: more recruits come from the South.


norskeyenta2
Rating
No it's not true. Many rich kids join the Military after graduating from College and then they can go in as an officer. Don't have to start at the bottom of being a PFC. During war time and there has to be a draft, the American draft board, drafts both the rich and the poor. Many young men/women , want to know what Military is like and make a choice on what branch they want to serve in and then spend a life time of serving , hence retirement. So No it is not only the Poor men/women.


One Big Awfull Mistake America
the majority of people in this nation are classified as poor/ lower mid class. as far as McCain, Palin & Biden they obtained most of their wealth after their time in service.


Lu W
Rating
The minor majority comes from the middle and lower-middle class. A small portion come from lower class which you would classify as "poor". Most politicians have children in the military due to tradition and country.


SFC M
Ask a recruiter.

Poor people often don't even qualify.
-higher rates of obesity
-lower graduation rates
-more likely to abuse drugs
-more likely to have criminal history

Middle Class is the target market of most recruiters. People who make enough money to understand the value of job training and a college education, but not enough money to pay for college.


Stubs [formerly Lil Ole' Me]
as enlisted it tends to be more that way, but officers have already gone through college and are a little more established


be happy
Rating
yes, and people whose parents emphasize patriotism


Black Sabbath
Rating
Officers are the rich class of soldier.


Terry
The majority of recruits for entry level positions - enlisted men - come from lower-income areas.

Middle class people tend to go in through a University or Officer-entry program, not at the lower ranks.


Jack McSmack
Rating
certainly the vast majority.


George S
Rating
Yes, and other people who have little going for them outside.

That neglects people like the ones you named. Those are just gung-ho.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Could we have won the vietnam war?
...


 What's better, Navy SEALs or Green Berets?

Additional Details
Green Berets speak two languages and they play a lot of video games....


 In order to have peace we must have war?
i think this quote is rubbish. i think in order to have peace you just need to have peace this quote is just an excuse for power hungry, war mongering lunatics. what do u think?...


 Homecoming... How would you handle this situation?
The love of my life is returning from Iraq soon. I was contacted via the KVC this afternoon to let me know the return date. It just so happens that my boss is sending me to a training out of town ...


 Can someone please tell me why the US didn't step in to save lives...?
I recently found out I have very little time left in my life. With sure dearh I have found myself thinking of things that I am ashamed to say didn't catch my attention when it happened. So I'...


 Should i join the army or ta?
...


 How do people who believe Israeli troops are trying to hurt civilians or do not care?
Siraelis are spreading leaflets and making broadcasts to specifically direct civilians out of the way. If they wanted to hurt them, why would they do that?...


 Are french people really so afraid of everything?
lets take wwII......


 Why American, British& Canadian complaining that their soldiers & Children were tron apart with bombs?
I am proud Iranian. I have never witnessed a suicide bombers in Iran,until after CIA conspiracy against Shah in Iran and ended Ayatollah Khomeini took power in 1979.

And as soon as A...


 I'm 22 years old. Am I too old to go into the Airforce?
Ok, so basically I've been wanting to go into the air force since I was in high school, but I was held back by my mother and my ex-boyfriend wanting me to go to college instead. And like a ...


 Seriously, how friendly is friendly fire?
...


 Which do you prefer modern figher jets or my favourte ww2 fighther planes?
I loves world war 2 planes over the modern jets any day they look great Eh.....oh wait they are great they look cool and the sound from them engines.incredible!!...


 Is it true?
I've heard from a friend of mine that was in the marines..The marines "program" their guys..but when they leave, they don't unprogram them. Hence this can hurt the family life. It ...


 Short of using Nuclear weapons, can the U.K. defend its self alone?
...


 Is George W. Bush a pretty good Commander in Chief?
...


 What famous historical event happened on this day in 1941?
What famous historical event happened on this day in 1941? I KNOW some of you servicepeople (especially sailors and marines) know the answer - some of you are stationed where it happened!...


 Who is the greatest military hero/leader ever and why?

Additional Details
in the world, in your opinion......


 Why are we involved in war about religion ?
us as Americans juct passed a new amenment to seperate church and state. If that's our belief than is it true this war is really over oil? Is that the only reason our men and woman are dieing ...


 Will u accept the war between israel & palastene?
Hai everybody, also will u accept the war between india & pakistan?...


 Would I be considered a veteran if I got discharged in basic?
Hi, I had a quick question. Over the summer, I went to basic training on May 23rd and got discharge on August 23rd for Panic Disorder (It was a general under honorable conditions discharge, free from ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Tuesday, May 29, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.024