Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Military

Is it generally true that military personnel are less intelligent than civilians?
Find answers to your legal question.





Is it generally true that military personnel are less intelligent than civilians?


Additional Details
I was told that in the military, you simply react and don't think. If you think too hard, then there are conflicts with your commander.


    




NAZGUL
Troll this question get asked everyday give it up.

Most military members I know have at least a AAS degree or higher and or working on a degree.

Vet-USAF

@dded : 2 Tech School degrees, 1 AS, presently working on 3 AAS degrees and this does not include the Tech School for my AFSC in the AF.


Eric M
lol....as a Mensa member who holds only a GED and a Master Sergeant in the US Army, I'll match wits with any of them....I joined the Army cuz I didn't want college....I wanted real life


Finsha
Where did you hear that from? lol
That's so not true. My husband is military and he's one of the brightest people I know. He's extremely intelligent.


Mister2-15-2
No! There might be difference in level of education, but that cannot be used to infer anything about intelligence.


Untamed Rose
Rating
lol have you seen how advanced the military is now a days? majority of the jobs are in computers and techincal fields... go talk with a navy nuke or one of the guys who work on helo engines.
most career military are very smart.


beernotcider
I'd generally have to disagree with you. If anything, it's the other way around. Military people are highly trained, while civilians remain STUPID.


♥L_A_E
Wow-you are really trying to create issues here,huh? No. They are people too-there is a variety. Just like every where else you go, there are smart people, not so smart and complete idiots.


DUH
No.


dasuberding
No, I have found that the majority of the military is more intelligent than the average American. Why don't you take the asvab and find out. Bet you can't beat my score. Considering that half of college students can't find their own states on US maps these days, you might be asking the wrong question here.


CAUTION:Truth may hurt!
It absolutely is not. I believe I can guess where that stigma came about though.

It IS generally true that military personnel are from low-income households in which education tends to be unaffordable or even unimportant. Those house-holds tend to be run by parents who didn't go to college. An uneducated parent is not as likely to raise a highly educated child. It will be up to that child to choose to pursue a higher education.

Today, lots of young people join the military with the intent of having their school paid for. I'm not ashamed to say that that is a major reason in my decision to enlist. I made very good grades in high school. I was in all honors and AP courses. I did very well on the ASVAB and the SAT, and I was accepted to every college I applied to.


Dennis F
NO, the military is a direct reflection of its society. There are some smart people, some less so and most are average.
The higher you go in the ranks the more it will reflect more intelligence. The "Peter Principal" at work.


Lowey
Rating
no i don't think so. would you be happy with someone who couldn't tell which end of a gun bullet came out of defending your country. they must be as intelligent as civilians because before they were soldiers they were civilians and you can't just suddenly before less intelligent over night. personally i would think they would have to be more intelligent than the average cilivians. either way you should be supporting your army if they are defending you.


The Wise One
Rating
No - the opposite is in fact true! Especially the officers

Eric M - rock on!


yarbigy
Lets see. I am an Officer in the Russian Army. I have a degree in Mechanical Engineering. I dont think that makes me stupider then the average person, does it?

There aer some slow people in the armed forces. But also, this is true anywhere in life.


Harvey
Rating
Everybody I serve with either has a college degree or is working towards completing a college degree. Can you say the same about your place of employment or "civilians" in general?


darrell m
the military wants people who are able to think and reason. you train to react to certain situations, because you won't have time to think when the bullets start to fly. a big difference.


Kats C
I think you were poorly informed. A soldier, airman, seaman or corps man is taught to think and analyze. Every course they attend earns college credit, and most leave the service with an AA or higher. As members progress and meet promotion boards; a promotion candidate with additional courses or higher degrees are scored better than someone who doesn't.


Mr. Taco
No, that isn't true. What IS true is that uneducated people are more likely to enlist. That is not the same thing as low intelligence, though.


THEAmericanPatriot
Rating
How many jobs can you get in the military without at least a high school education? ZERO
How many jobs can you get in the CIVILIAN sector without a high school education? LOTS.
What's that tell you about the U.S. Military?
Those DUM military people are the ones who protect your rights you to sit there and bad mouth them and make yourself look foolish.
(USN, retired)


oldhag
Where do you think they get the military?I know some very intelligent Military men and women. They train them to follow orders and most do, but they still have minds and some refuse to do inhumane or stupid orders.


No one special
Rating
I would not say that military personnel would be less intelligent than civilians b/c Most people in the military have to overcome some type of hardship in their life. I.E. No money for college, join the service. Now that person can get a college education and build a resume at the same time.
Available jobs may not pay well enough for people to fulfill their dreams; join the service now you get paid to travel the US and/ or the world. Those are two examples I have seen with my interaction with military personnel.
Who's to say if military personnel are less intelligent than civilians, cause it's the civilians who join the military.


wichitaor1
Rating
Let's see, I have a BS in history/political science and am currently pursuing a master's degree. How many people who believe military personnel are stupid can say that?

Nearly half of my reserve unit have college degrees or are currently in college.

As for the "just reacting" presumption, it is a total fallacy. Military personnel are trained to think for themselves, so that they can make the right decisions. That makes them more intelligent than people who just repeat the mantras of others.


hehe
Rating
Not necessarily. Especially when it comes to keeping things simple, military personnel are the best at it in my experience. If you think too hard, you can make a simple task more complicated than it is but it shouldn't make such a big conflict with your superior or commander. Conflicts happen when someone in the military doesn't know how to address the problem in a respective matter to another, not because one is smart or thinks too hard.


Mullah Obama
Rating
No, actually they are smarter.


inmyname2003
no. That only applies to the army personnel.


Ya-sai
True





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Is WWIII a Possibility?
How can WWIII Happen? Atomic Bombs couldnt be used on Russia, China, Korea, etc. because they have them too and the exact second they find out we launched ours what do you think they'll do, they&...


 Why do soldiers get mad when you ask them if they have killed anyone?
I mean, whats the big deal? Its a simple question with a simple answer, why do they get so weird with it?...


 An extremely sensitive question about NFL star turned Army Ranger, Pat Tillman?
In all due respect for this fine young man, I wanted your opinion as to what you believe happened to him.

Evidence is pointing to something very sinister, and I'm hoping upon hope ...


 What will happen in Afghanistan?
Afghanistan is a Thirty years distroied country should it becom a peaceful country? if yes When....


 Design your perfect army?
if you were to be allowed to take the best aspects of world militaries what would you have?
~British training and professionalism
~American equipment and funding
~French bravery... oh ...


 My girlfriend wants to join the Army!?
My girlfriend wants to join the Army and i know its selfish but i dont want her too!

She says she wants a career and its something she wanted to do for years, i'm worried about her ...


 Why are our troops still in Iraq, dying?
I don't understand! It's just wrong!...


 I am a newly commissioned Officer. Is it okay for me to date enlisted women?
Besides, the Enlisted women are younger and hotter.
Additional Details
I got a direct commission in the US ARMY medical service branch. I never went to OCS. I know about fraternization, ...


 At age 18 why can we go and die in a war but cant drink?
...


 What is the best firearm of all times?
...


 Who thinks gun control is needed in America?
I would like to know your point of view on Assault weapons only. I believe in the right to bear arms, I do not think it is wrong to own a gun to protect yourself and family. I do not believe ...


 How comes America seems unable to win any war since WW2 ?
Corea, Vietnam, Cuba.
Irak and Afghanistan are far from a happy ending.
Now Iran and even Venezuela are challenging the USA.
What is happening?
(Sorry, I just forgot Grenada!)
<...


 How would winston churchill have resolved the iran problem if he was prime minister today?
...


 Would you let your child join the Military?
Why or why not?...


 Why do so many people seem to think there is a war in Iraq, when all the facts and evidence say otherwise?
So many seemingly intelligent and articulate people talk about a war in Iraq like its actually happening right now.

But the hard facts and evidence agree that the war ended in 2003, and we ...


 My son wants to join the marines, security forces. Is this good?
He is only 17, so I have to sign a waiver for him to sign up because this job is few and far between. If he waits until he is 18 the security forces job might be gone... is this true. Should I sign ...


 Who thinks they will join the military?
...


 Why is the american flag has red and white stripes when the american civil war was between the "gray and Blue"
...


 When we lose the terrible and unjust war in Iraq should I have compassion for the Troops?
Or should I treat them the way I was treated by the fine upstanding American people back in 1975?...


 Pretend a war, USA vs UK?
Who'd win? I'm confident that if we had the same number of troops against them, we'd demolish them!

Imagine 20 US Marines vs 10 Royal Marines!

I'd put my ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Tuesday, May 29, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.084