Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Military

Military People Help. Did i cross the line?
Find answers to your legal question.





Military People Help. Did i cross the line?

My husband is home from iraq i think he has PTSD He won't seek help. He blames me for not being nice to him 24/7 though i try not to raise my voice anytime. i finally got fed up when he started doing the whole yelling in my face, and pinned me to floor and start doing all those military moves of bending wrists and arms in positions and pressure points to cause pain & harm me then wonders why i try to hit him off me, Hello it hurts. So i sought help through the Army Family Advocate program, and he thinks i'm jacking up his career cause i want him to seek help. And if he won't they'll do something about it. Did i cross the line taking it to his superiors, or was it okay to reach out for help.


    




mariner31
Rating
I think your actions were correct. I'm ex-Navy and had the same issue with one of my "kids". We had no idea anything was wrong until the wife finally screwed-up the courage to go to the Ombudsman.

She had waited longer than you... he had already passed the point of "pressure points" and had broken her wrist.

He had troubles... did some time in brig, got a TON of counseling, and finally came to understand it was HIS problem, and NOT his wife's. Thankfully they actually stayed together and are happily married to this day.

I can't promise you the same happy ending... but I'm thankful you sought help before your husband does time for putting you in hospital or worse.

I wish you luck and happiness.


The Scorpion
No, that's a dangerous situation and needs to be dealt with. What he did was not "military moves." That's not something taught to soldiers, that's just abuse and he has no right to do it.


Crosseyed Kitty
No. You did the right thing. He could become a danger to you.


Mary S
Rating
He sounds like he does need help. You did the right thing. Don't let him hurt you. It's always okay to reach out for help.


Common Sense
Nope..
You did not cross the line.


DOOM
If he's physically restraining you, I'd have him arrested.


Baking Master®
Rating
you did the right thing. my grandma on my dad's side had to do the same thing.


marie
Rating
I'm not a military person but I am a person with a lot of common sense. If he does not want you to seek help why is he treating you as if you were the enemy? His using his training to hurt you is so wrong! Walking on eggshells around him is only making him think you can manage to live like that all the time. You need to leave if he can't straighten out, because if he isn't trying to get help you need to do what you need to do to survive.


Mercadies2000
Rating
It's physical abuse and he could hurt you bad sometime. He needs help and you are doing whatever it takes to get it. You didn't do wrong at all. He no doubt has PTSD and once he gets treatment he may become your loving sweet hubby again! Good luck to you both and I hope in the end you will have a happy long marriage.


nesescott
Rating
He needs to get help before it gets out of hand. You did the right thing. I'm sorry to hear that he's not coping. Seeking help from family advocacy shouldn't ruin his career. Now, if he doesn't seek help and does something, then he WILL get in trouble. It's better for him to seek help than to wait until it's too late. Of course, I'm coming from an Air Force perspective, but the military that's what the program is for...HELP.


Melissa P
Rating
It's always ok to reach out for help. It is true that the military is required to report things like this to his commanders (they don't want to send unstable people into war) however, if he was treating you this way then he needs to seek help. In my opinion, he's lucky you didn't go directly to his first shirt yourself.


RHD100
Rating
You helped him by telling his superiors. I guarantee you, though, he has two choices, help himself & you & seek counseling or face jail time if he continues to hurt you. You took the first step, now it is up to him.


larry m
Rating
I am an Air Force Vet. No you didn't cross the line.

Your husband needs help whether he thinks he does or not.

Trying to be supportive is one thing, but being allowed to be abused is not an acceptable form of support.

PTSD is a very serious medical condition, so please make sure you take it very seriously. Your safety is most important.


trooper (canine bad citizen)
You did the right thing...he needs help. I just returned from Iraq, and I would never think of laying a finger on my wife..not because of my career, but because I love my wife. Now..I am not saying that he doesn't love you...he just has to go work through some issues. and for your own safety, you need to have a back up plan in case he does it again. make sure that when he gets in those moods, you leave for a while before he gets out of hand. talk to his leaders about what is going on. to many spouses in our army are becoming statistics....good luck...


jamie s
Rating
I agree with Brian B, maybe you should separate yourself from him for a little while and try to make him understand your feelings.


winemkr
Rating
Get rid of the undisciplined piece of garbage. Hopefully the military will to.


jkah33
yeah! let him deal with his own problems you should stop pushing his button and makign him snap





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 My teacher went to the war in Vietnam, do you think he killed someone?
Im not sure his position but i think he was a lead attacker of some sort. Do you think he killed anyone while he was there? I mean he is alive and ...


 Why are these military members crying so loudly?
Pentagon moves to increase U.S. troop levels in Iraq By Will Dunham

WASHINGTON - The U.S. military is delaying the departure of thousands of soldiers from Iraq while speeding the ...


 What makes the US military great?
...


 Which branch of the military is it best to join?
I joined the army and I want to know if that was the best idea!...


 Do you think that US purchased the Iranian arms and distribute them in Iraq for trapping Iran?
By looking at the Anglo Saxon involvement in the 3rd world specifically in Middle East, it is highly possible that British and US Gov. have purchased these weapons form Iran through 3rd party and now ...


 Why is the US Navy creating a blue camoflauge uniform?
Is it to blend into the ocean? Seems like if you went overboard you would want to be HIGHLY VISIBLE....


 Will you please show support by flying your "American" flag on 9/11/06?
Please send out an E-mail to everyone you know. Also don`t be the one to break this chain. Take a moment to think back to how you felt on 9/11 and let those sentiments guide you. ** Fly an A...


 Will the UK put pressure on Osama to force yanks to speak the queens English proper or let them speak Mexican?
Best answer wins a 13 week self catering caving holiday for 3 in Pakistan (flights not included) 1000 shares in woolworths and a crisp £4 note....


 Do you think that the U.S. should send troops to Darfur to stop the Janjaweed?
Please give your opinion and some things backing your opinion.

Personally, I think that we should stay out of Darfur as American soldiers are exactly that, American soldiers, they should ...


 Want to see how British troops are bringing democracy to Iraq?
http://www.youtube.com/w
I have to warn you that the video is GRAPHIC. Especially to those sensitive to the pain of children.
Yes, that&#...


 Why does today's youth not have to be worried about being drafted into the military?
serious answers only plz....


 Why won't Republican leaders send their kids to Iraq?
Except for maybe 2 or 3 congressmen or senators, non of the Republican leaders who are all for the Iraq war send their kids to Iraq.

I can understand why democrats wont want to, because ...


 American Soldiers will SOON be in American STREETS?
...


 Anybody fascinated by the Vulcan Bomber?
Just had it fly over my house about an hour ago. Fantastic!...


 Will there be war in the Balkans again?
Russia is regressing to cold war tactics, they support the Serbians, American and parts of Europe support the new Kossovar state.. will this lead to East and West conflict in Eastern Europe?...


 Will our troops really be out of Iraq in '08 or am I fooling myself thinking this will be his last deployment?

Additional Details
Do you think we will have a permanent base there like Korea/Germany?...


 What would America be like if the south won the civil war?
please ...


 Should india attack paksitan or continue to peace talk and loose army in J&k ???
india & pakistan ...


 What are your opinions of the draft? do you support it today?
Also, do you think your childs school should make and aggressive effort to encourage all male students to register for the draft?...


 Can i join military if diagnosed with mental disorder but stopped taking meds?
...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Tuesday, May 29, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.044