Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Military

Pretend a war, USA vs UK?
Find answers to your legal question.





Pretend a war, USA vs UK?

Who'd win? I'm confident that if we had the same number of troops against them, we'd demolish them!

Imagine 20 US Marines vs 10 Royal Marines!

I'd put my money on the Royals to stuff them!


    




Lisa S
Here's something to think about. The actual reason why the Brits are the often victims of friendly fire is that they are not very good at coordinating with other forces.

I have heard many accounts of how the Brits were in places where they were not supposed to be, and paid the price for their laziness or stupidity.

As far as the Brits being the best man for man, what is the basis for this? They have not been able to prove any real competency in over 100 years. In Iraq they were assigned the least dangerous area in the country and only did a middling job of it.

The Americans are having to step things up in Afghanistan after the coalition countries made a mess of the progress that had been achieved.

I'm afraid the British are the only ones impressed by their military.


tikitiki
Stuff them with what-fish and chips? lol....


D B
Rating
UK couldnt beat them back in the 1700's and they coundnt beat they today


dolfanhappy
This is not a serious question, is it? The British Marines train and the US Marines fight.


Ron g
Rating
What happened when a bunch of US farmers took on the professional British military? Also in 1812 the US kicked their asses again. ww2, the US bailed them out after the Nazi's steamrolled them.


fantazamaraz
Firstly, it's a silly question. America commands nato for starters and we aren't that popular in europe to warrant their assistance in such a scenario. But having lived in the US since the sixties and being familiar with their massive military resources Worldwide, there is no comparison, And let's not forget that in today's newspaper headlines, it states that half the uk army wants to resign.! So morale ain't good.!America would win hands down. Not because of better training,etc. but sheer resolve and they would do it with a humorous smile, one hand tied behind and a wink.!


Watson 123
The United States is the greatest military power in the world. In a potential war the U.S. could overwhelm them with troops relatively quickly or just blow the whole country to pieces in a few minutes with a few nukes.


Neil T
Rating
Not again!!


bulletsponge
being from Ireland, of course i would support the US, but the brits aint to shabby, with 20 vs 10 odds obviously the US would win, but if the numbers were better, its pretty much fifty-fifty


Curtis M
Rating
Everyone Making Great Points but Imagine if this happened 5 years from now .... if the European Union Was Getting Closer nd Closer to Joining there militarys together ,..... the rest of europe wouldnt stand and watch as Britain Gets Involved In Conflict With The US ....

I Mean At First They`d Try To Prevent Any War .... Push If push goes to shove, it`ll be an all out contenant war!

So If Everyone Played fair and left the nukes out of this ....The UK Would "Suff Them" ... With The Help Of Their European Buddies


Justin M
Rating
The United States, but why would we fight are strongest Allie?


David H
Rating
Let me guess. You`re a spotty faced 12 year old schoolboy.


Gerry Atrix
Get knotted. We have enough of the real thing without going into the realms of chest beating fantasy.


shanook_queen_of_alaska
We all loose! we hold the Nukes for the USA so we could nuke them with their own bombs.
To be honest though even in Iraq the Brits loose a lot of lives to the USA due to friendly fire. (not very friendly really is it)
The Brits might beat the USA in the war but then what? we would be without fuel, steel, medical supplies etc.

I think with Mr Bush and his amazing aptitude for geography France would be fooked as they would get bombed instead of us.
We could fire doughnuts laced with arsenic at the USofA!


68w
whatever you say kid


PeguinBackPacker
It depends. The US has a larger population and bigger military yet a lot of what the US knows, they learned from the Brits. Does The British has the support of other big players such as the EU, China, Russia or some other rival nation of the like or are on their own? If the UK was on its own without allies, it would be crushed quickly. However I doubt the US would be able to hold down the British population when they revolt against their authority ( the British have a long tradition of bucking would be invading nation from their homeland and proved to be remarkably resilient.) If the UK politically isolated the US and had allies on its side, I can see it becoming a bloody and long war with the US eventually being worn out and have the yanks spend their ability to support such an effort.

The only reason I can see the US invading the UK is as a staging point for a further campaign against main land Europe in order to invade and take it over. Which I do not see happening any time soon for there is not a reason to do so.

The last time this happened was WW2 when the US used the British isles as staging point to invade Nazi controlled Europe and to stage D day. If Britain was conquered by the Germans before the US came, I doubt the allies would have won.


probablygraham
Unfortunately wars don't get fought by soldiers any more. The US could bomb the UK to bits in a few hours.

I agree that British ground troops are probably better - should get a few points knocked off for that :-)


Dave C
Rating
Ok no technology,no 'smart' stuff.
The British army would clean up,
they are real men,the yanks are soft.


ivan_drago_185
to waston, although america would try to overwelm what happened with the greatest military vs vietnam?
Anyway if ameica used nukes they would win then afterwards be invaded by many european countries involved in NATO.
The largest army in the world is owned be China then followed by India. Without NUKES i think the UK could possibly win.


Nintendouche
Rating
100 USMC v 1 Royal Marine

Id put my money on the Royal Marine since the yanks will take out about 50 of their own men with FF first

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eNGSyACeY8A

EDIT: to all the dumb *** yanks who are claiming they won ww2 no it wasnt, if it was anyone it was the russians


Nigel101
lol.

Ron g , 1812? The British burned washington down - ever wandered why the White house is white, its beacuse of a quick white washing job, a monument to American weakness.

Average British soldier vs. average American soldier.... British soldier i think, we train our men for years, and turn away more than we accept, they get snow, desert, urban etc. training, the Americans are short on all that.
The SAS are the most feared force in the world, the entire SAS could beat the US special forces (i think).

But realistically they'd just bomb and nuke us off the map, we'd respond with a nuclear strike. Everybody loses...


PARA-Hunter
Rating
The US marines are a bunch of phycos and would probably kill half their own men in the first hour, don't get me wrong the US marines are great but have no brains at all. I think the Royal Marines would win as they are all higher trained and are very tactical.


myrz
Man for man, lb for lb, the UK would win, because they have the best military in the world man for man.

But the US has 5 times as many people as the UK and much more firepower, so in real life they'd win.


kevin1959
we would whip the yanks as for 1770 you had the french dutch spanish and a hand ful of native americans you have never won a war on your own but always late for one the 1st ww 1914-18 not 1917-18 the 2nd ww 1939-45 not 41-45





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Do you think women should be allowed in the SAS/marines/infantry?
???
Additional Details
no i have not been watching ultimate force ********, i wanted to know people's honest opinions. i know i have mine i wondered what everyone else ...


 Who is telling the truth?
How can you be so sure that the British sailors did n't enter Iranian waters? I don't know if they did and i don't know if they did n't.
Its not as though Britain have a ...


 What should i tell a friend who wants to go to iraq?
he is a friend of mine. i tried to tell him some time ago that going there isnt a good idea and that he could possibly be killed....


 Why will the world laugh at the United States when we once again lose a war?
...


 Who thinks hitler was a great leader?
...


 Can anyone explain why Vietnam Veterans were treated so badly?
My grandpa is a Vietnam Veteran. He got drafted because he dropped a class that he was getting a low grade in college and the draft board said he didnt have a enough college credits to keep his non ...


 Who agrees with me?
A Marine and his rifle is the best weapon in the world
Additional Details
hey lisa... say that to a Marine in his face.... thats right...hide behind your computer. maybe you should ...


 Middle east, why can't we let them be?
Let them deal with each other, I mean, seriously these people just hate each other, we should not even be in the picture. They are waiting for each other to do somethign so they can get back on ...


 Why did bush stop the hunt for bin laden??
I mean, don't we owe this guy? BIG time? Why does bush want him around?...


 We are both serving soldiers?
So would it be ok for my girlfriend to polish my weapon in public?...


 Should we ban all religious symbols in schools.?
...


 Should the world boycott US products to protest the terror attacks on Iraq?
I and friends have boycotted US products in Australia since the US terror attack on Iraq. How do Americans feel about other countries' people boycotting US products?
Additional Details<...


 What do soldiers wear in bed?
I am joining the army and I am wondering what do I sleep in, in the baracks? I am going in as a Lieutenant, will I be given something or can I bring my PJ's? Will I have my own room, or a dorm?<...


 Why does no-one understand, that i dont HATE the soldiers. I hate the idiot who put them in harms way?
Theres a difference. I protest this war because I dont want to see US soldiers die in Iraq just because of oil or because Saddam pissed his Dad off. you all talk about the reason for being in iraq ...


 I can't believe I'm talking to people that are proud of their country going to war?
I though I was in the XXIth century....


 What do you guys think about people that protest at soldier's funerals?
...


 Why can't Bush just come out and say he wants to torture people ?
I would have a modicum of respect for this weasel if he just admited it. We know that is what he actually wants to do. Remember how hard Bush fought against the McCain amendment against torture? <...


 Was any of the destruction that happened in Lebanon over the past month worth it? If yes, why?
...


 Do you support the the military?
I was just wondering who supports the military. After reading all kinds of questions on here I see we have a lot of support and I think I speak for all of us by saying thank you and for thanking us ...


 This should be very simple question. Are you "FOR" or "AGAINST" the war in Iraq.?
CNN News just said only 32% of the American people are for the war in Iraq. That is shocking! So, are you for the war or against. Just say Yes or No. Thank You.
Additional Details
Thanks ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Tuesday, May 29, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.024