Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Military

SAS against Navy Seal's who'd win?
Find answers to your legal question.





SAS against Navy Seal's who'd win?

Ok if there was a direct conflict and the British SAS went up against the American Navy Seal's who'd come out on top??


    




chindit
oh dear another "my dad can fight your dad" question, YAWN......


proud to be british
why ask stupid qustions


Master me
The SAS because they train the navy Seals. look it up lol


Anagram Lacking
Rating
Chuck Norris


Rt Hon Alfy G Returns
Rating
Well you know all the UK people will say the SAS and the yanks will say the Navy Seals


Icebreaker
Royal Marines are better than than the US Navy Seal's and some say the SBS are better than the SAS. Well in a fire fight between the SAS and Navy Seals I think the SAS will win because they have far more tactical training than the Navy Seals while the Seal rely on firepower shoot scoot while the SAS takes the fight to the enemy.


Bonzo
S.A.S.... REAL and properly trained...


Bamford1000
Rating
The British Special Boat Service (SBS) have more in common with the US Navy Seals than the Special Air Service (SAS).

I also agree with Anagram Lacking in that Chuck Norris could be an important factor.

As for who would win, I am British so it would have to be SAS.


Will
Rating
SAS SAS SAS SAS SAS SAS SAS!!!!!!!


mason442101
Rating
the SAS every time the navy seals are about as well trained as the ppl pushing trolleys outside tesco


BJLA
SAS- Easy


runforfree
To the above answer if you want to storm an embassy you use the SAS, if you want to storm a pirate ship you use the SBS.


AndOfHisChrist
hmm...two stealth-oriented forces against eachother...nobody would ever get a shot off...


wensleydale
Rating
What does it matter? If you want to storm an embassy you use the SAS, if you want to storm an pirate ship you use the Seals.


Altair
Rating
Apparently the Royal Marines are the Navy seal equivelent. The SBS are in a league way above any maritime special force in the world.

As for who'd win, the SAS, because Americans would kill each other in friendly fire.


Doug
Im American i should lean towards the seals but...not this time SAS
But if US Marine Force Recon and SAS came to fight the moneys on the Marines

Swift Silent Deadly


R'- @\/_1
SAS would win they have better training

although the SEALs have better weapons, theres no point being trigger happy if you cant hit the target


George W
Rating
Well its obvious THE SAS !!
THEY WOULD KNOCK THE SEALS OUT !!
THEY ARE TRAINED PROPERLY HAVE BETTER GUNS AND THEY ARE THE BEST !!!


Joel
Rating
Dumbest Question EVERRRRRRR!!!


Kieran
Well i'm Irish, and i reckon the SAS would win. Dont rule out the Irish ARW though ;)


306
Rating
the A.S.A.S. (Australian special air service)would win because they would be only ones still alive! lol by the way im American and the SEALs are bad-as$ hooyah!


lone butcher Spartan remembers
Your "if" is mighty loud. . . they will never ever have a direct conflict because the countries they serve are very close allies. Keep in mind that they share training techniques and technology, being such good friends.


Frank N
As Harry Hill would say on TV Burp..... I like SAS and I like Navy Seals but which is better..... there's only one way to find out.... FIGHT!


Justin
Rating
The North Koreans... think about it


Hereward the Wake
if it was sas hero paddy mayne, he would win single handedly. He's dead now so that aint gonna happen. There is no way to really compare as it's unlikely either will fight each other, they may do war games but that isn't really a true test. The SAS are the original special forces


mr.chicken1
Rating
SAS....well unless the Russian Spetsnaz came in...then they are all dead


armstrong
Rating
SEALS


GUMBIE DAHMIT
Rating
SEAL's



HOOYAA #176


Pizza Box
Navy Seals!


A pissed off American
For you british people who are so wrapped up in your precious SAS and SBS saying you train the MOST DEADLIEST WARRIORS known???? I say BS. I have researched your SBS and SAS, if the SAS were told to take a dip they would drown, if the SBS were told to go off of the coast, they would get lost. The SAS and SBS stick to only one area. SBS Water, SAS Land. My dad was a Navy SEAL. So i know what im talking about when it comes to Special Forces. Do you know why the SEALs are called SEALs in the first place??? It stands for SEa Air Land. Almost every big time OP Your boys were put on, the SEALs had to baby sit them. And by the way, SEALs train SEALs....No one else. Who got Bin Ladin? Who rescued that captain from the pirates??? Sure that was US drama not britain, but Bin Ladin was the top most wanted man IN THE WORLD. Where was SAS? Where was the SBS?? Have you researched the long process and ridiculously painful training you go through just to get close to being a SEAL?? There is a week in that training process called ?Hell Week?, look it up. I bet your boys go through nothing like that. The SEALs would eat SAS for breakfast. Not that it would matter because of the whole alley deal. I just thought id point out the truth for the people who just wont admit that there NOT better than every one else.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 How can people not support our troops but then demand freedom?
They are fighting for YOUR freedom....


 How many american`s belive this adminisration is bring us way to close toWW3?
IM worried about MUSLIM TERRORISM an Europe`s aliination towards the U.S,They thinkwere wrong for IraQ,So dont I how about you?...


 Are you glad our troops will be leaving Iraq?
I hope they will leave Iraq totally though as in 0 British troops left!! I say let the Americans handle it because they started it.....


 "How can I be sad over a person in military dying when they are there killing voluntarily?"?

Additional Details
huh? troll?seriously....
how can someone feel it is OK for the military to be killing, torturing, and yet when one dies that is our own..oh no, we should all be ...


 What tank is the Best ?
What is the best tank ?

The British Challenger 2

or

The American M1A2 Abrams
Additional Details
actually... what is the best tank in ...


 Rules of war?
do you think that the rules our soliders fight by do put them in more danger should we fight by same rules as the emeny and let our boys wipe them out with no threat of punishment war crimes etc
<...


 Should America be worried by what Russia says?
Russia earlier this year said it would use unidentified "military means" if the U.S. deployed a missile defence shield close to its borders
Additional Details
http://uk.news....


 Could the US ever have won in Veitnam?
I don’t know a great deal about it being British but it strikes me that despite all the technology and training, they never really stood a chance. The tactics of the North Vietnamese, guerrilla ...


 Do you feel like veterans are only appreciated when it's convenient?
My close friends and my family are appreciative all the time, but it seems like the only time veterans are thanked is when there's a holiday to remind people. Most people only want to know if ...


 Should military recruiters be banned from targetting kids?
The US military is desperate for recruits. After Iraq, many view the lies and brutality of the US military as a reason for not joining. No longer does the US military fight for freedom and justice ...


 Is it cool to join the military (Navy)? I'm 22 and have no college education. Does the milt offer decent deal?
Does military offer good deals on college tuition. Has anybody had any bad experiences....


 Has the war in Afghanistan and Iraq made the U.S look weak?
...


 Does anyone believe the USA can restore any order to Iraq?
...


 Have Israel gone too far?
I'm not on any side in fact Im not religious or aphiliated what so ever. I beleive this is an advantage. But Hezbollah kidknapped 2 soldiers. Instead of doing a prisoner swap, which Israel has ...


 Did the US EVER win a war alone?
Is it even possible? One needs somewhat "intelligent" soldiers...not robots who are the same as the sucide bombers....


 Your Country Needs You?
Will you answer its ...


 Which boot camp is the hardest? Marines or Army?
Who should I join? Marines or Army. I want to be the best there is & I want to go to War. Marines are the first to fight right?...


 Air Force or Navy?
I'm a Senior in High School and I want to join the ROTC program. I want to do something with computers and I was wondering which one has better opportunities. I really don't know that much ...


 What are soldiers still doing in Iraq Should they not be out by now? Isn't it long overdue for them to home?
...


 Can you suggest some relatively UNbiased sources for information on the Iraq war?
...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Tuesday, May 29, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.064