Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Military

SHOULD 16 YEAR OLDS BE DRAFTED OR VOLUNTEER FOR MILITARY SERVICE lN IRAQ?
Find answers to your legal question.





SHOULD 16 YEAR OLDS BE DRAFTED OR VOLUNTEER FOR MILITARY SERVICE lN IRAQ?

16 or 18 what's the difference they're still children.


    




Shadow
Agreed. Nobody should be drafted, I think all wars should be decided by the rulers of the countries in a ring, either death match style or mud wrestling. Although if it was death match style they might not be so pumped to start more pointless wars.


Noriega
Rating
no, i dont believe there should be a draft. if anyone gets into military service then that should be because they volunteered to go.
thats my opinion.


pele
ok. so when do you think someone should be legally considered an adult and take on adult responsibilities?

btw-i agree no one should be drafted


blah h
im 17 and would never want to go to iraq, iran or any of those countrys, sorry for wanting to live and wanting to stay with my family!!!! and why the HELL are we over theyre any ways!!!!!


The Platinum Mage
I agree with shadow, however I prefer the paintball approach. Is it really nessasary to KILL someone? I mean come on?! I'm not disordered here. Maybe some hockey style fights out there, you know throw of the gloves and beat the _ _ _ _ out of them. But death? What's wrong with this picture? Tell g-d I'm slacking off. And the draft? Who cares the government doesn't work for the people anyways. Bush? Come on. Certain disaster.


ginger13
Rating
No, they should not be drafted.


misty n justin
Rating
In the eyes of the law, they are children at 16, adults at 18. I think 18 is even a little young to join volunterily, but they are considered adults at that age and can do as they please. 16 is to young to be drafted in my opinion. At least by 18 most people have completed highschool. If the draft is every re-instated i doubt seriously they would take children that young.


marksatguy
Rating
There is a debate over whether 16 year olds are old enough to drive. 18 yr olds aren't responsible enough to be trusted w/alcohol, but they're old enough to "die for their country"?
If They reinstate the draft, they should work from the top down. Bush children first, then the cheney kids, next the pelosi's.....


telemark
Rating
Nobody should be drafted. If I was trading gunfire with an enemy, I sure as heck wouldn't want someone guarding my back who didn't want to be there.


eMale
No 16 year olds should not be drafted, because as you say they're still children. In the USA 18 year olds are considered adults.


Dave_Stark
And when did this happen? What draft are you talking about?

And the whole concept of volunteering is that it is a choice freely made by the individual concerned. Neither you,nor anyone else, has the right to gainsay that choice.


Cassie
Rating
If they can drive they can shoot a gun.


W W D
Rating
16 year olds, experience tells us, are a bit too bloodthirsty and impetuous. 18 year olds can be trained to be professionals. And these guys are that, not trigger-happy cannon fodder as so many seem to think.


San Diego Art Nut
Rating
I'm with Blah.
Also, I don't think we should send another soldier until the Bush twins are drafted and go.


E W
Rating
No.


Betty Boop
Yes Let our American boys come home. 16 year old and even younger defended our country in the American Revolution. There is no reason Iraq Kids should not defend their country too.
Betty.


codex3k
Rating
If they are not going to school, reproducing and living off the government, then "hell yea".


drivingdog18
16 year olds by law cannot be drafted. 18 year olds can be because as defined by law they are adults. Since we do not have a draft, as of now no one needs to worry about it. 17 year olds can enlist (volunteer) if they have a parent or guardian sign for them. Since my kids are not even close to that age I don't know if I would sign for them or not. I would have to talk to them and know what their motivation for enlisting was and discuss other options and what their plans for their futures were.

And before you accuse me of being willing to send my kids off to die, no I do not want my kids to die. But somethings (like this country) are worth fighting for. Sometimes that requires sacrifice.

You're welcome for your freedom.


Laural
Rating
I've got one you can take.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 Why is the Military MOSTLY Democrats and Minoritys?
are the YELLOW CONS who support the war
to COWARDLY to fight in it
OF COURSE THEY ARE dont you think?...


 USA wars - should they finally stop attacking other countries?
... and what proportion of Americans think they should?
Additional Details
Do you consider innocent women and children that have died by the thousands terrorists?...


 How would the USA deal with Iran if the sailors were American?
...


 Why do army guys always where there uniform everywhere?
I am in the Air Force and they tell us to only wear when we need to and if we need to do something in it like get groceries on the way home thats fine, but you will see army guys in the strangest ...


 Gay Soldiers!?
Do you agree with gays in the army? I.E Marines, Paratroopers, infantry most upfront combat roles.
Im not gay or homophobic, I just want to see what answer's this gets.
Additional D...


 Can you see the reason I never want to admit I was once a dog handler for the military?
Never again will I admit I was a dog handler for the military. Read on:......*** The abuse of Abu Ghraib prisoners undermines U.S. efforts to bring democracy to Iraq, an Army prosecutor told ...


 If you could sumarily execute a terrorist suspect with out a fair trial, would you?
In a fair trial one is allowed to see the evidence against him or her.
In a fair trial one gets to face one's accuser. What Bush wants is a vigilantee, kangaroo court where an innocent ...


 What should the U.S. do if Korea launches its missile?
...


 I have a question to all who served in the military or are going to serve in the military?
are or did you enjoy your military service?

and why or why not?...


 What does "semper fi" mean as used by the us marines?
...


 Isn't a soldier out of his depth when discussing geopolitical affairs?
....like a humble construction site worker contemplating architectural philosophy?...


 What would you do if one day you found out that you consist of bones, muscle, tissue, saliva, glands etc?
http://www.innerbody.com...


 Why do all the men all over the world love WEAPONS so much?
...


 What do you think about the navy?
...


 Do you think those Anti-War protesters really support the troops?
and do you think Jane Fonda and Sean Penn really care about the troops??...


 Will World War III begin with Israel and Iran?
As tension continues to grow between the two arch-enemy nations, do you think WWIII will begin when/if one of the countries attacks the other?

Any other thoughts?
Additional Details


 Why do people think that the Middle Easterns are the terrorists and the main cause of the problems?????????
Isn't it AMERICA that went into Iraq and demanded something that did not belong to them???? They wanted Iraqs oil and when Iraq didnt give it to them they caused a war!!! War is always the ...


 Do You Think College Students Should Be Allowed To Carry Concealed Firearms On Campus?
I know this isn't a military question but I figured that those in the armed forces are familiar with firearms.
Whether or not you have a gun carrying license most college campuses ban all ...


 The US Military vs Animal Cruelty/Abuse?
Should military Dogs be protected by law from being subjected to the horrors and violence of a man made war?
Is it right to subject innocent helpless animals/dogs to the shock and violence of ...


 Just how good is a 99 on the ASVAB?
I recently got a 99 on the ASVAB and had not only my recruiter but several others saying that they have never even seen one. I was just wondering how good this actually was and if I should be proud ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Tuesday, May 29, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.024