Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Military

Should women be drafted into the military and why?
Find answers to your legal question.





Should women be drafted into the military and why?

please give a thorough answer to support your answer.
Additional Details
hypothetically speaking if the US has a draft.


    




furious_george
Rating
If they institute a draft, then of course women will be included.
Different obligations based on gender? I don't think so.
There are plenty of support roles that women are perfectly capable of doing, and while there are female soldiers in combat roles, every female could not qualify.
I have a feeling that the ACLU will be oddly silent on this issue.


Jon
Equality in the military is a load of BS
Women will never be drafted
If they were, why would they? Their PT standard is far below a male PT standard, they get treated better by hardcore sergeants, and if they want out of a deployment/draft, they can get pregnant.

Don't get me wrong, roughly 70% of all the women I've met in the military are hard-working and push themselves to meet or exceed the male standard. But I highly doubt drafted women would have the same personal dignity as most of the current serving women do. I blame society...


tallerfella
Rating
Into the military? No. But I do think that everyone between the ages of 18 and 25 should perform some sort of national service. Not just the military. It would be a great way to give something back to the greatest nation in the world instead sitting on your butt and saying "gimmie" all of the time.


joe
Yes! All hands to the deck when the ship is in danger.


chasen54
There is no why etc.Women willnot be able to be as competentas the guys


Your #1 fan
There is no draft. If your question is should women play a bigger role in combat the answer is yes. If you want to be treated like men, you should be allowed to fight.


Old Scout
Rating
I hope we don't start a draft for men or women. Volunteers make the best soldiers. After I retired from the Army I went to college, all my fellow students were about the same age as a new recruit. With the exception of the ROTC students, I wouldn't want any of them on my tank crew or in my Scout squad.


0123456789
Rating
yes
men and woman at the age of 18 should do a minimum of 2 years. give em some self respect, some manners and some patriotism.
Many countries do.


regerugged
Rating
If you are in the US, the answer is no. We do not have a draft in the US.


charlottemc1
Well i would say yes, if they can fly planes now and be in the front lines why not.


quassy
Women in general still havent proved they are better than men in combat situations. They should be allowed to be drafted, if ya saying dis as a rule, cause women in the USA cont to say they are equal w/ men. So why not share their own silly ways to fight war as silly as men do. Nuuf said!


ang1492
Rating
No because the need seems to be soldiers for combat arms and women, are not allowed in combat arms MOS's.


kim t
Rating
So far the draft gos is not happening yet where are you getting this info at?????? My daughter joined the Army at the age of 17, she wanted to give back to her country, and to help protect the USA. This is a good answer, and I'm damn proud of her.


utahmike42
Funny. Women complain about not being treated equally except when it comes to serving their country. Why should you be exempt from the thrills of sitting in a fox hole and getting shot at? So yes, if there is a draft then you should go if called.


robert43041
I'll say no. Maybe it's macho thinking, but a woman can give birth, a man can't: that should be on her priority list. Sure, a woman can kill just like any guy but even in times of war tons of jobs may be of more importance than straight military service.


corpsmanlove1!
if we had the draft right now: no. they are not given equality yet. they still restrict the women from doing certain things, just because of a bunch of chauvinistic @$$holes. once they get equality, then yes.


badbender001
Rating
First off the purpose of the draft is to quickly raise an infantry. Women are forbidden by law to perform front line combat operations so that is why women are not required to register for selective service. Now to your question: Yes, they should be drafted because they can fill all the non- front line combat jobs and free a man to go fight. Many civilian women did exactly that during WW2, ever heard of Rosie the Riveter? With the rapid increase in personnel a draft would incur then there would be many jobs for women to perform and they all would be vital and important.


sanityinga
Rating
FYI: Every man between ages of 18-25 signs up for selective service whether a draft is in place or not. It doesn't necessarily mean they will be called for service.

That being said. Yes, I believe every one at the age of 18 should have to sign up for selective service. However, if a draft is called and you are a conscientious objector then a government type of volunteer option should be available.


wuzzasailor
Since you are asking for an opinion, I'll give mine. I think there should be a 'Universal Draft'. Everyone in the country, upon reaching the age of 18, or graduating high school, should be given a choice of govt service. Two years, but I'm not just saying the military, the govt needs manpower in lots of areas, infrastructure construction projects, maintenance of govt facilities, social programs, etc.. I think it might give people more of an identity as a citizen, and provide a couple of years doing something useful and time to grow up.


crdndn
well there is no drafts, but i think women should be treated the same way as guys do, there are a lot of us woman joining the military, i also agree that it may be that we are not qualify to do many of the duties but we sure could help.


OCELO
if there was a draft women will never be drafted, some men wont be drafted because they are the only son in the family.


Negligence
There's shouldn't be a draft in any case, for any gender.

I feel though, that there should be a bit more balance in men/women ratio, recruiting efforts should be tailored to that effect.


anonymous
Rating
No I do not believe women should be drafted because women are the cradle of civilization.


ARMY STRONG!
Rating
Why shouldnt they? They are volunteers as much as the men are. The females alot of the time make better soldiers than the men do.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 A Sailor ,an AirMan, A Soldgier and A Marine get into a fight who wins?
...


 Would you rather be in the military or in college?
Every person in society is told that college is where they should go after high school. Why are they not encourged to go to the military? What advantages does an 18 year old college student have ...


 Do you think that women are good at police or military jobs?

Additional Details
i forgot to say and why??...


 Should illegal immigrants in the military be automatically given citizenship?
I was wondering, should illegal immigrans in the military be automatically given citizenship? Yes there should be restrictions like they must serve their entire service, but if they fight for the ...


 IS IRAQ WORSE THAN VIETNAM?
i THINK SO...


 Does it irritate you when people who call themselves an American bash on Bush and our troops?
I mean seriously if you call yourself an American support Bush and our troops. B/c if it wasn't for America's troops in the past we wouldn't be here getting to say what we want, wear ...


 Why has the military done such a terrible job?
Scattered violence kills 15 in Iraq.



BAGHDAD, Iraq - Fifteen people were killed in scattered violence around Iraq on Saturday, including eight who died when a suicide ...


 What do you think of people who join the army, and then run to Canada or other countrys to avoid going to war?
...


 Don't you think that if the US pulled completely out, the war would stop?
I'm talking pull completely out of the mid east. Say screw all of you. No American's, No Money From America or American's, No Aid from America or Americans. Have at it, We are going ...


 What do you think about the Marines Corps' murder of two dozen Iraqi civilians?
What do you think about the Marines Corps' murder of two dozen Iraqi civilians?
WASHINGTON - Investigators believe that their criminal investigation into the deaths of about two dozen Iraqi ...


 What was the best fighter plane of WW2?
Do not include jet fighters (10 points for the most knowledgable answer)....


 Is the United Kingdom still a major power in the world?
Or is it simply a small country with illusions of still being an empire?
What's your view? do you think that the armed forces will continue to get smaller with all the cuts they've ...


 When was the last time u thanked a vet?
Thank You Soldier

Have you stopped to thank a Veteran today?
For the price of freedom they had to pay?

Did you gaze into those distant eyes?
Did you see the ...


 A substitute teacher who was a Vietnam vet said this quote, do you agree with him?
For one of my semester electives back in the school year, I chose to be a teacher's aide at the junior school. One day the teacher wasn't there and a substitute was running the class. B...


 Why would anyone be in the military for 20+ years, & stay enlisted?
I know that some soldiers aren't smart enough or motivated enough to become an officer. I just want to know why anyone would choose to stay enlisted rather then becoming a warrant officer or ...


 Why did we ever go to Iraq in the 1st place?
1st of all, I don't SUPPORT the war at all, I want it to end. I wonder why it even started, most people say it was because it was for oil, that Bush doesn't even care about Afghanistan....


 If The United States Of America Went To War With The Commonwealth Of Australia, Who Would Win?
Since they're both NATO countries, allies can't help. Only the national armies can help....


 A man says he was a member of the S.A.S. Any way of finding out?
I know of a man who purports to have been a late member of the S.A.S. However,I have no proof of this as he has nothing to prove it, no photos, no history at all. A friend of mine has photos of ...


 Are nuclear weapons necessary for the defence of any country?
...


 Why are we in Iraq???
The people responsible for 9/11 are in Afghanistan right? Did we ever find them?...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Tuesday, May 29, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.044