|

oscarsix5
|
How about....
Tora, Tora, Tora
The Longest Day
The Rough Riders
The Red Badge of Courage
Patton
The Lost Battalion
Platoon (Fiction)
The Deer Hunter (Fiction)
The Boys in Company C (Fiction)
Full Metal Jacket (Fiction)
Paths of Glory (Fiction) |
|

RUESTER
 |
I think the most realistic movies made are: We Were Soldiers, Hamburger Hill, Black Hawk Down and Saving Private Ryan.
I enjoyed the others you mentioned, but one Civil War movie you didn't list that was really good and from the research I did was fairly accurate was Andersonville.
I am surprised you didn't mention Band of Brothers. Although there were many Airborne units that trained and jumped into Normandy and were as close knit as the company depicted in the movie, they were the ones that got all the attention. It was very common for Airborne units to be that close. First, they were the pioneers of the American Army to test, develop and use parachuting to enter the battle, so there was a certain amount of pride there, plus they got to blouse their boots, had the Airborne/glider patch for their cap, and the mighty jump wings on their chest. |
|

Chief
|
Band of Brothers, Tora Tora Tora, We Were Soldiers, Midway, The Longest Day. |
|

Jerbson
 |
If you like Vietnam movies read "The things they carried". A true account of life in Vietnam. It's very well written and gives you the feeling of being there. I know someone that served and they recommended it. Sorry this is off topic but it just came to mind. |
|

The InGLeSH MaYJuR
|
Saving Private Ryan was great, the opening sequence was so real and morbid I get chills just thinking about it, truly sick |
|

grips
 |
Hamburger Hill |
|

carrieluvsredsox
 |
saving private Ryan. somebody brought up band of brothers and that so amazing to watch. makes you appreciate the vets even more. |
|

Richard S
|
All of the Star Wars films: not only are they just plain awesome, I really like the theme of "the road to Hell is paved with good intentions." |
|

MCR2020
|
Even though it is not actually a movie but a 10 hour series, Band of Brothers is by far the best war film ever made. |
|

Aaron W
 |
I didn't care as much for 'The Patriot.' Some other good ones are 'Gardens of Stone' and 'The Longest Day.' 'Band of Brothers', of course, and 'Schindler's List' are good as well. |
|

TartanTerror
 |
Braveheart! of course, Freeeeeeeeedom |
|

0123456789
 |
Men with Green faces |
|

Mutt
|
One of my favorites is "The Big Red One". |
|

acdcrocketman1976
 |
Hamburger Hill
The Iron Triangle
Black Hawk Down
Flags Of Our Fathers
Windtalkers
Heartbreak Ridge
Kelly's Heroes
The Dirty Dozen
We Were Soldiers
Band of Brothers |
|

Michael W
|
1. We Were Soldiers
2. Hamburger Hill
3. Saving Private Ryan
4. The Patriot
5. Black Hawk Down
6. Patton
7. The Longest Day
8. Tora Tora Tora
9. A Bridge Too Far
10. The Great Raid |
|

AFwife
 |
well braveheart is definately a war film and i thought it was great! |
|

Daniel
 |
Black Hawk Down
Saving Private Ryan
We Were Soldiers
Behind enemy Lines
Enemy at the Gates
Full metal Jacket |
|

Michelle M
 |
Flags of Our Fathers and Letters From Iwo Jima
It was great to see the same battle from both sides. |
|

cpu1s9m7c2
|
Saints and Soldiers was a great one Saving private Ryan, Platoon, Black hawk down were all good too also The Patriot was incredible |
|

wichitaor1
|
I like those on your list, but "Hamburger Hill" is the best film about the Vietnam War.
The worst: "Apacolypse Now" |
|

|
|
|