Home     Links     Contact Us     Bookmark  
 
   Homepage      News      Legal Forum      Dictionary  
Home : Legal Forum : Military

Vietnam war?
Find answers to your legal question.





Vietnam war?

can someone plaese tell me why the French left Vietnam in 1954


    




Valerie
The French had a large colony in southeast asia. Back then it was referred to as French Indochina. After WWII this area fought the French for their independence. You have to remember that France had many problems after WWII including Algerian colonies, African colonies, etc.. and many reconstruction efforts within their own home country.. all with very little funds.

Fighting in French Indochina lasted until March 1954, when the Viet Minh won the decisive victory against French forces at the gruelling Battle of Dien Bien Phu. This led to the partition of Vietnam into the Democratic Republic of Vietnam in the North, under Viet Minh control, and the State of Vietnam in the South. The North was communist. Other parts of old Indochina also converted to communist rule including Cambodia. There was a great fear in western countries that communism would spread further and further around the world through these small wars.

The State of South Vietnam had the support of the United States, the United Kingdom, and France. The events of 1954 also marked the end of French involvement in the region, and the beginnings of serious US commitment to South Vietnam which led to the Vietnam War.


thud.fan
They were defeated in battle at Dien Ben Phu and the French government did not want to spend any more money or resources in trying to keep the place...It wasn't worth it to them.


Chief70
Because of all the French blunders in fighting the first Indochina War with the Vietnamese and finally they lost the final major battle in 1954 at Dien Ben Phu. The lost of this battle resulted in the split of the country - North Vietnam and South Vietnam. Fighting in Vietnam resumed and President Eisenhower sent in American soldiers as advisers to the South Vietnamese, as did President Kennedy by sending special forces to serve as advisers, and then the Vietnam War escalated with the number of Americans forces being increased. America, as a signatory on the SE Asia Treaty with SE Asia countries, was obligated to help defend the country as it was an ally but so many people forgot that major
obligation America accepted as the war escalated and soldiers were lost and injured in battles.


ANN-MARIE B
The French had got themselves into a difficult military position. Despite huge American help, the French could not cope with the Viet Minh's guerilla tactics. The Viet Minh were by now receiving help from Communist China - Mao Tse Tung had taken power of China in 1949. The fact that two sides had developed was classic Cold War history.


The White Rose
Rating
The Vietnamese kicked their butts is why. And Eisenhower declined to support the French militarily in holding on to their colonial possessions.

Unfortunately, LBJ did not have Eisenhower's wisdom ten years down the road.

Also lack of support for the war at home defeated the French, similar to why America left.

Vietnam was a civil war and western powers had no business whatsoever being there.

Time and history has proven this to be correct, as Vietnam is now reunited and there was no "massacre" and no massive communist take-over in SE Asia.

Does all this sound familiar once again?


bob08886
Rating
The same reason they leave everywhere else--


Dragonden6389
Rating
not easy to win over a citizen army .


l d
Rating
Three words: Dien Bien Phu


Sgt Big Red
Read what Joe T states, that answer is the most short and to the point. Not like wikipedia copy and paste answers.

He is right on the mark. short and sweet and shows no self bias, well spoken.


Dougal
Rating
Do not listen to the morons that say the French always cut and run. Wally is right on the money for the most part … the account of the breakup of French Indo China and subsequent end of France’s involvement in the region. France had outsourced the war to the French Foreign Legion including a battalion made up of all former Nazi Waffen SS troopers numbering around 900 troops that where used extensively during the conflict and where also present at Dien Bien Phu, the battalion was never reassembled after the war and those who survived by all accounts were spread throughout the legion. So in short the resources to maintain the region both militarily and economically where stringent and the French people were unwilling to commit regular French forces. Some contend that the lack of support from both England and the United States lead to the French defeat and the subsequent US involvement and withdraw.


Jerbson
Rating
The French are always first to run


dsm37127
it was mainly because of their humiliating defeat at dien ben phu. that and the fact that the french government let them be overwhelmed and anniliated.


danor
Rating
the same reason as USA left, they got their *** kicked by people who didn't want foreigners in their country


haroldfinster
They realized that Vietnam war was a quagmire, something that the US could not realize.


Big kid
Because they are French. They never did have a stomach for a fight


pierric
Rating
they realized 20 years earlier than americans they had no business being over there.
Some nations are smarter than others and that's why they get rants here from dim-witted bush patriots.


joe b
Rating
The french knew they couldnt beat the vietnamese so they did what theyre best at and ran like the arseholes they are.


RayN-is-back
Rating
The north were using the V C in the south to aid them in the south Most VC were Buddhist who felt the christens were mistreating them Much aid was coming in from Russia via China Much like Korea The French pulled out we come in We were winning But the U S public tried of the war and the house cut the funding we had no choice but to pull out Now the rest of the world love to tell us "you lost in Vietnam" not true But let them have their fun.After the north took over they disbanded the V C sent some to reeducation camps Had a brief war with China and invaded Cambodia The left did not care about that only that America had pulled out Ho sorry lost


Scourge 0' Fascism
THey realized that it was unwinnable. Their interest in imposing their will did not equal the will of the Vietnamese people in getting rid of colonialism. It took us 20 years to figure that out, with a waste of 58,000 lives.





 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:




Legal Discussion Forum

 What the Arabs are afraid of if they challenge U S A?
THE PRESENT DAY CONFLICTS WORLDWIDE ESPECIALLY IN MIDDLE EAST AND WEAST ASIA IS ACTUALLY US HEGEMONY OVER ARABS.ARABS HAVE OIL AND MONEY STILL THEY ARE AFRAID TO TALK AGAINST USA WHAT ARE THEY AFRAID...


 Is there anything I can do to try to bring American troops back home?
I lost my brother, 2 of my cousins, and very nearly my dad because of the stupid war. Is there ANYTHING I can do to bring them back home?...


 What is the main reason rumors continue about Vietnam Veterans (Late 60s early 70s being spit upon?
STORIES ABOUT spat-upon Vietnam veterans are like mercury: Smash one and six more appear. It's hard to say where they come from. I found nothing. No news reports or even claims that someone was ...


 Any clever uses for the American flag, apart from burning it to keep warm?
...


 Is China a friend or a foe of the US ?
...


 Should the draft be reinstated?
...


 Does it make your blood boil when you read that an Iraq civilian?
has been awarded 2 millions pounds compensation for being mistakenly shot be a british soldier?

It is wrong for anyone to shoot an innocent civilian whoever they made be...but where is ...


 Timothy Mcveigh: terrorist bomber, or CIA mind controlled robot?
keep in mind: science has concluded that a truck that size filled with plastic explosives could not have done the damage it was supposed to have to that particular building
Additional Details


 Should the USA set a deadline for pulling out of Iraq?
...


 Why do people say "I support our troops," when they really haven't done a thing?
...


 Is it completely my fault?
I am being charged with three counts of assault in the army. One on an NCO female and 2 more on male privates. In each case, I was never STARTING the fight because the other individuals put their ...


 Is there any special forces you can directly enlist into without prior millitary experience?
...


 I want to join the marines after hs, but my parents will only let me join after college, what do i do?
ok, so i have talked to my parents about joining the marines. i want to enlist after HS, which will be in 2 years, im a sophomore but my parents say that the only way in hell i could ever join the ...


 Why hasn't the military draft been reinstated?
The fact the military draft is not in effect is insane- Our troops are stretched out thin, we need more soldiers, and this war may last a long time, if it spreads to Iran.
Not having the draft ...


 Are gay people accepted into the Royal Marines?
Im thinking of joining up the marines in a year (uk royal marines) as i come from a family with a lot of military service, grandad was in tank corps in ww2 in middle east, my old man was a para in ...


 Our plane landed at the san diego airport and as soon as we got off the plane all hell broke loose. screaming?
drill instructors telling us to get in line! i met a girl on the flight to san diego and the drill instructor "greeting" i recieved was quite embarrassing. the girl laughed at me! Marine ...


 Does anybody else think we are only in Iraq to?
Have a central military location in the middle east? I think it is nothing but that right now. So support your troops and your country!! What happened, I dont see any more flags out there.
A...


 What's the difference between a sergeant major and a warrant officer?
...


 Solution for peace without war?
Now don't get me wrong I fully support our troops they are doing their jobs and very well also. But every morning I feel for the parents who are finding out that their son or daughter will not ...


 Why investigate 9/11? What are you patriots afraid of? The truth?
Why Investigate 9/11 ?
http://www.911truth.org/ http://www.prisonplanet.
George W. Bush admits ...




Copyright (c) 2009-2011 Wiki Law 3k Tuesday, May 29, 2012 - Trusted legal information for you.
Archive: Forum  |  Forum  |  Forum  |  Links
0.064